monoccular

Sounds a bit like - Would you rather be an optimist who is sometimes wrong, or a pessimist who is always right ?

But he does share at lest a couple of characteristics with Big JC.

I understand that you may not rate Joel, and I remain unconvinced, but please show a little respect for one of our listed players.

“Jackson didn’t do much but was out there early and then later. Maybe having a light day or has a niggle. Didn’t seem injured. (Read afterwards he has Achilles awareness and will be back training next week)” Achilles awareness - sounds like a promo for some Greek mythology

True - prior to his ?ankle injury he was really on fire. But, sadly, like #13Jako beforee him, he didn't handle injury recovery at all well.

And older old buggers such as myself think of Bib Bob Johnson.

In the highlight reel his kicking, albeit under junior pressure, was one of the standouts.

Will we see more of Joe Gutnick now?

Does anyone have a drone? How about KC? Lovely post, Ernest But you need to summarise it for the younger members whose attention span wouldn’t allow them to wade through it, and appreciate the wonderful prose

Surely young enough to be reinvented or adapted to some other position, (or to displace one of the established inside mids ?) ?

I remember Dermie, that brilliant scientific intellect, once saying of the teams that used to stand in the shallows at Port Melbourne beach the day after a match, that is was “to wash out the lactic acid”! ???

Surely if the AFL have signed off on this trade, there must be details of who pays what, somewhere. If the AFL have sanctioned this they are even more of an amateur joke than I thought.

I am very concerned regarding the forthcoming Australian Open Tennis - bringing in hundreds from overseas hotspots, putting them in Victorian run central city quarantine hotels, and allowing them to mix for training and practice seems a recipe for disaster. IF they must have this event, surely the incoming players could be quarantined out of town at a resort with outdoor tennis courts, live in security, and decent catering, but with no contacts in central Melbourne at least until their events.

Understatement. And Derwayne is too dull to realise that Jackson isn't just a ruckman - he could play just about anywhere, including as a midfielder.

Surely you are exaggerating - missed the decimal point - 1.9 In the mid 1950s the greatest coach of all time had a brilliant and totally innovative idea. Instead of running two lumbering ruckman and a rover follow the ball around all day, of course with “resting” ruckman in the forward and back pockets, he had this young athletic guy named Barassi who would run around doing a bit of ruck work and a bit of roving, and a bit of goal kicking when “resting” forward. The first ruck-rover was invented. Young Jackson fits the rôle, and hopefully takes part in a similar age of success as did young RDB.

As I recall, Hawkins was in year 6 or 7, in a regular finals team with a dominant midfield, before he “took off”. (Please correct me if I am wrong).

My point is that it is a dynamic situation, and if the ball is coming your way you will go for it, without having to think "am I crossing an arbitrary line". Totally out of the spirit of our game.

19th and 20th man - we won our last spate of 6 flags with that set up ... so it must have been good Sort of a nice idea, but how absurd would it be seeing Kossie dashing up from the pocket, only to find the incoming ball stops 52 meters out from goal. Instead of going hard for the ball, would he have to look across the ground to see when and if someone else enters the 50 on the other side of the ground, and stand like an [censored] waiting for his opponent to catch up with him?? daisy - tend to agree with most of these. I would also consider regarding kick in from a behind, that the defending team not be awarded a mark until the ball has left the 50 meter arc. It would keep the game moving and reduce negativity.

I obviously didn't read the detail..... docking rotations as a penalty!! How about in the dying moments of a close game - who cares about rotations at that stage?

rjay - can you elaborate please? If you are referring to zones like in netball where players have to give up the chase if they come to a certain line, it would be a huge NO from me. Or is this a certain number of players in a zone at stoppages, maybe, though if umpires cant adjudicate the current rules then how could they enforce yet another complicated rule correctly.

As Aaron's ancestor once said:

My MFC paranoia tells me that the AFL will see this MFC player having something of his own that he can now use to help us, so will change the rule to our disadvantage. How did this get onto the Ben Brown thread? I know their coiffures are similar. Should we rename the thread ugly hairdo players?

Well you might P2J ...... I’d rather give current day Robbie Flower a contract ...... problem is where are these “I’d rather” players coming from?

I am ambivalent about Alex. I love his work ethic and second efforts, but he remains very inconsistent.

Do we, you, or anyone know that we are not interested? Maybe “we” are just being cagey and professional?