old dee

I don't need that much pain in my life Redleg.Off to the Amos for me this week.

Saty I don't believe I have ever said fling him. In the scheme of things I believe he is an average at best player. If he was involved as a part of a trade deal for a better player I would do it in a heart beat. What you say about the improvements he has made under Roos might all be true but IMO he is at best average and that is it. Now it is only my opinion.

I am not suggesting we fling himI would trade him if a good deal came up. That simple for me

There lies the problem IMO.For bail to be a walk up start to the best 22 shows how poor the rest of players are that would replace him. On his good days he is an average quality AFL player. He would not get a game in the top ten teams.

For the right deal in a heart beat, I might add bb there are only a few plus half a dozen kids that I would not trade for the right deal

The difference between the MFC and when Roos went to Sydney was he had a reasonably good list to start with. Now he has a list that is the worst in the competion. It is going to take time to change that problem. I hope you are right but I seriously doubt it.

I don't disagree but I still think that Scully is still well over paid even allowing for their salary cap. Is he worth the same as Ablett?

Correct but that is not going to happen for some time yet. Hope you have the patience to wait through to 2017

The problem is he is getting paid $1+ million PA To justify that money you need to putting in Buddy or Ablett performances not average results.

Agree nutbean there are plenty of juniors selected in the top 20 every year that do not make it at senior level and plenty outside that group that do. Being a top junior does not guarantee you will automatically be top level senior.

NGE!

IMO if you leave out half a dozen kids there are only four players that are exempt from being traded given the right deal.

After the Clark experience I am not sure we know a lot either.

Fairly confident it is in the toilet right now Grint

Garland is UFA at the end of 2015. Lets not have another Frawley year in 2015. Resign him now or put him up for trade this year. Get something while the opportunity exists.

Ha ha ha

Pretty much of the same opinion, IMO Casey do not make that many mistakes in delivery by hand and foot.

I wish you would strengthen up your opinions a bit A little on the timid side.

100g

No there at least two of us dd

Don't like him then Jnr?

Is there a message there?

Just differences of opinion DA

I doubt a Captain would be traded RB simply because he is a captain.However if you were looking at ability only I would have him towards the front of the trade for advantage queue.

My problem Dr is that i see lots of MFC supporters who want to blame bad luck for our misfortunes when the majority have been self imposed .Over the last decade we have had a series of poor administrations, poor Coaching, Poor player selection, poor development and looking to take the easy option by tanking. We may have had a few unexpected player failures but to lay our problems at the feet of "bad Luck" is IMO just looking for a handy excuse.