old dee

I don't believe that Brayshaw should return to the AFL before he has displayed a good block of games at Casey . There are years ahead for him lets not ruin him by rushing him back.

You are leading with your jaw jr.

Based solely on those statts Four players screaming "I should be playing in Darwin' Dunn, Grimes, ANB and Oliver. ANB won't be the coach did not give him a big rap. Dunn and Grimes are in the dog house so that probably means Oliver we be the only change.

And that is the saddest part of all. I will give him one plaudit He tries hard.

Sadly neither do I jr. Next week there is no real alternative. I hope to God Pedersen is able to resume soon.

Ok he was good for two minutes in 100. Reminds me of an old Jack Dyer comment. "Stand still son it will hit you a couple of times each match".

Sorry to harp on jr but his good games are rare, his ok games are occasional but his bad ones are often

And not a lot more for the whole game G

If it was one bad day then there would be no comment jr. The problem is that Dawes occasionally has a good day and the rest are crap.

He had 75% game time Steve beyond that I have no idea.

You win my prize for comment of the day Brownie

What the Pies have promised him he can play in the forward line?

SJ that is a "do you still beat you wife? " comment.

Yes but he was a bit heavier guy that I remember BM but I have to admit my memory of that era players is beginning to fade a little. It is hard not be excited by him, when he gets the ball you have the feeling something good is about to happen vs a number of others that you hold you breath.

That is the biggest wrap so far by anyone in the Football world in 2016. He is still a long way off that level.

Like AW LDC you would be stone cold in no time. All the Dawes effort in the world would not keep you alive.

Your Dead!

Preferences LDC. If a mark was going to save your life would you pick Dawes or Dunn?

But is he good enough at this point for AFL jnr?

Then like AW we are going to disagree Biff. Amount other things he is too small. Like Kennedy he will have the occasion day out but when it get tough they are too small. Yesterday we had too many small players and too many poor large players. We are still 5 class players short of being a top six side.

Then we are going to disagree AW

IMO so far Petracca has shown he is a reasonable young player in his first season. I actually think it is time he had a freshen up back at Casey, I did not think he was influence yesterday.

We will see Mr. Shadow but I am bullish about 10.

Sorry to disagree dd but I thought he was average at best and IMO poor. He is too small and holds onto the ball for too long. He seems to run around with the ball for so long that he loses where his team mates are and inevitably gets caught with the ball. I do not see him making it.

Agree nutbean I also think that there no.1 ruckman played a lot better game than Gawn around the ground. He took a number of telling marks.