TheoX

Carlton will beat us by 10+ goals

He fits the mandatory highly injury prone bill for our high priced recruitment, but he's actually a good player and plays a position we need. So we will pass. Plus it sounds like he wants to play for a decent team which rules us out. Only Gillies and Dawes-esque players would be attracted to this trainwreck.

Where are the arseclowns that said trading Hogan wasnt a massive loss.

Good, if we're after him would like to screw them over in any deal given what they did to us with Hogan.

We would overpay hugely picks and contract wise no doubt.

We need a decent key forward after trading the best young kpf in the league for way unders.

Jeez he lays a good tackle and looks to have nice agility from that video.

He wasn't even offered a contract at GC, and if not for being steak knives, would've been a token 3rd or 4th rounder in exchange. As you say seems there's more to it. Hopefully works out for him/us though. We need a gem after being screwed over for Hogan.

Hope he can actually get on the park with his concussion stuff. GC didn't offer him a contract so they cant have been too optimistic.

We need a no1 key fwd now after trading Hagan for way unders. Tmac will cop double teams every game and his output will drop. Weed completely unproven. Forward line's gone from a strength to a glaring weakness.

5 year deal jeebus. Takes him to 32 on huge money no doubt. This is the kind of player we should get as a free agent.

Not to wish injury, but wouldn't feel bad if his foot's [censored].

Well we better win a flag in the next few years cause at 27 May's only got a few good years left.

Sack Mahoney the friggen [censored].

We got [censored] reamed. Pay overs and take unders is our motto in trades.

Wow what a [censored] joke. We actually had to give a sweetener lol.

In terms of picks in the trade it's pretty objective. Sure hope we stick to our request for 2 first rounders, completely reasonable given what they'll be getting.

Seriously how can the Dockers get more for Neale that we do for Hogan FFS

Surely we won't trade him for 5 and 23, that's way below what we paid for him when he was unproven. May is 27 and worth nowhere near pick 5. If those go down we are the shittest negotiators in the league.

Hahaha Freo, so unbelievably unprofessional. Bunch of [censored] muppets.

Tackle on Mcdonald was high lol.

Not overly happy trading a contracted best 22 player for a guy who played zero games this year and a useless pick.

May's 27? Jeebus he's only got a few good years left

5 for May would be ridiculous overs. Get him next year for nothing, KPB isn't even a pressing need. 5 and 11 for Hogan not enough. We paid more for him than that before he was proven.

Straight swap for Preuss? Ew, guy can't get a game at Norf, Tyson is best 22 for us. Preuss will play VFL unless Max is injured.