RalphiusMaximus

I'm glad I'm not watching/listening. Sounds like it sucks.

Wasn't this supposed to kick off at 7pm?

I'm really not liking the push towards Langford. Where exactly are Trengove, Toumpas and Tyson these days? All highly rated juniors who had everything going for them except speed. I'd be absolutely furious to see us blow another top ten pick on a guy who looks amazing at u18s, but can't keep up at AFL speeds. Especially with so much talent left on the board.

I keep going back to that interview Oliver did just before trade period. They mentioned Patrick Cripps and Oliver's comments about him just being too big and powerful to stop have really stuck with me. It also reminds me of something one of the St Kilda mids said about Melbourne in '20 or 21, that our players were so much more powerful, they basically ignored attempts to tackle them. That's why I really want us to bring in Smillie. The thought of having that midfield titan who is just overpowering for opponents is so tempting. Someone the size of Cripps but with better speed and kicking? Lets grab him and get him in the gym to start adding muscle.

Honestly, I expect him to want to stay up north. That's kind of obvious. What 18 year old is going to choose to move across the country rather than do the same job for the same pay in his backyard where all of his friends and family live? Assuming both clubs want him, he'd be insane to pick Melbourne.

Wait. Pendlebury played basketball? 🤯

I'd be thrilled with Smillie, but a hard no on Shanahan. How many 195cm forwards do we need in the squad? Does he provide any point of difference over the players we already have in those roles? Much better off bringing in more midfield class.

My unqualified and highly suspect opinions: If Smillie is there at 5 (6) we should jump on him. Similar size to guys like Cripps and Bont, he's a much better kick than Cripps and has better burst speed. Was rated #1 all the way until he wasn't, but that ability hasn't gone away. Not outstanding on the 20m sprint, but more than solid. If not Smillie then Langford. I'm really tossing up on these two. Langford has some insane courage with his marks, both of them are good kicks and good size. Langford did better with the 2km time trial, Smillie was better on vertical leap. Lacks burst speed, which I value highly, so that counts against him. If he somehow slips that far, I'd love to pick up Xavier Lindsay with our pick 9. Skillful left footer, highly rated leadership and footy smarts. Missed the combine with injury, not sure how his pace looks from those highlights although there were a few moments where he accelerated to lay a tackle or burst past an opponent that suggest he's got the speed but prefers to save it for when he needs it. There's talk of us looking at Murphy Reid for this pick too. I wouldn't be at all upset to get him. Great vision and freak factor, I think Lidsay has better penetration on his kick, but both look quite good. Another one who missed the combine, but he certainly hits the scoreboard and gives us the outside skills that we lack. Either he or Lindsay would compliment the contested beasts in Smillie/Langford.

More importantly, what moment did you describe in 25 words or less?

Easy. Make a lowball offer. If they take it he's cost us nothing much and if they don't we move on.

Richmond look like they'll have a bunch of first round picks to play with. I wonder if we could get three out of them?

Yes

I'm just wondering. We have some players with significant currency wanting to leave the club. What if we just put them all on the table? What would we get back for Petracca, Picket and possibly Petty? Would Oliver want to stay if his mates all left the club? It could turn into a hell of a rebuild if we came away with half a dozen or so first round picks. Plus we'd legitimately finish well down the ladder next year, so more high picks in that draft. We'd bottom out just in time to avoid the worst of the compromised drafts for Tassie. (Note: I do not in any way advocate for this to happen, but I do wonder about how much we could get selling off quality premiership players right now)

I'm sad that we won't have his ruck knowledge anymore, but as a forward line coach he was a total failure. Hopefully now we'll get someone who understands leading patterns and creating space for each other.

Not the only one. Our season is over, time to give the kids a run and see how they look at the top level. GC have only lost once at home this year, so it's not like it's a game we expect to win. Jefferson has more than earned a call-up.

My money is on them changing the Father-Son rules to prevent us getting access to any of the kids coming through in the next few years.

6 - Rivers 5 - Viney 4 - May 3 - Gawn 2 - Salem 1 - Sparrow Honourable mention to K. Brown. His first stat in the seniors was a goal-saving run-down tackle to preserve our three point lead. You couldn't script it better for that kid.

From the limited footage I've seen, Harley Reid is well and truly top of the class. He already looks like one of the best mids they have over there.

OK, I just need to highlight the Gawn Game tonight. His stats are insane. The guy is a legend.

Sam has concrete hands. For someone whose game is meant to be built on contested marks, that is a fatal flaw. It's not necessarily a lack of effort, but the ball bounces off his hands every time he tries to take a grab. If he can't mark the ball, he has nothing else to offer.

You remember Jarrod Molloy at Brisbane? They kept him a bit on the heavy side so he'd be more of a beast in tight spaces and harder to bring down. When he went to the Pies and dropped the extra weight he was half the player. Have to say, I think that was the best game I've seen all year. Scores level at half time, multiple lead changes, a massive arm wrestle for dominance between two very different game styles. It had everything. And of course, the right team won. I can't believe how quickly Windsor is adapting to the top level. So very happy we have him in the side. I'm hoping we'll all be equally impressed with the Kolt when he gets his chance.

Can Maynard write?

I can't believe how much they continue to underrate Juddy.

Good reel. Looks to have real pace and a good jump. I also like how he picked up the ground ball at 23 seconds. He didn't lead with his face like so many do looking for the cheap free kick.

I'd love to see Sanders on our list, even if there's every chance he'll be gifted to Tasmania in a few years. He's absolute quality and makes the players around him look better.