Dee*ceiving

Would be dangerous off a half back flank

Maybe nervous optimism but the more I think about it I feel like we have selected well for the conditions (or at least I've been able to apply logic to justify it). Hibberd not tall but tall enough in wet conditions when marking is tough and brings some ground ball agility (theoretically moreso than Turner / Tomlinson). Smith again tall (but not huge) bu super athletic. Very fit, good foot speed and great leap. Can be used forward and back (again more flexible than Turner / Tomlinson). Laurie sub. Small, quick, agile, good kick & performed well as sub last two weeks. Go Dees!

Is that Brownie's undies?

Petracca Fritsch ANB Viney May Brayshaw

Also more comment that question and a topic that's ripe for a Binman rant... Not unusual by any stretch but how sombre were the commentators once Melbourne got on top late in the third and right through the last quarter? I know a famous Swans victory at home to farewell Buddy was the order of the day but you'd swear they were commentating a funeral towards the end of the game. They basically laid out on making any comments for some outstanding play eg. Trac's goal and Nibbler's holding the ball tackle and said nothing of the Melbourne effort, strength and determination to win in hostile territory.

Disco was terrific if you ask me

Outstanding win. Belief, determination, strength and class. Petracca, Fritsch, Viney, May, ANB just huge!! Many others too, including the coach. Bring on September. It's our time!

Agree with recent sentiments, hard to fathom the need to send Max, on a plane to Sydney to play on a heavy track in a dead rubber before finals. Gold Trip doesn't run on a heavy 9 at Mornington the week before the Melbourne Cup.

Sestan and Verell good chances to forge a career as well. Sestan and elite runner in juniors I am told, belying his size and strength. Also bottom age.

Great analysis, bodes well. But should be noted JVR is playing in a better team now, than Charlie was early in his career.

I think it was more in reponse to Hawthorn subbing a tall for a small. Tommo our slowest/most lumbering defender just wasn't needed any more. Agree re: Shache

To my mind... Fritsch, fitness permitting we must get a look at him in the forward in combination with Melksham... Smith > Tomlinson (Smith moves to the backline to make room for Fritsch) Spargo > Laurie Out: Tomlinson, Laurie In: Fritsch, Spargo It does leave us small up forward, but also very lithe...Not against trying TMac but working him in is harder...Sub?

6 - Lever 5 - Melksham 4 - ANB 3 - Rivers 2 - Brayshaw 1 - May

An absolutely outstanding game from Melksham, he completely nullified Sicily who was even run on the ball to try and get him into the play. Having seen this, and with Fritsch coming back in, can Jake still effectively play that defensive forward role on the oppositions tall interceptor? Having seen Smith (forward and back) & Tomlinson back it seems Smith is the better option overall of the two. Tomlinson out, Smith back and Fritsch in seems and easy change. Does that leave us too short/small in the forwardline? Or is that speed and agility potentially an advantage?

Hibbo being managed I reckon. Will be sub and assure the defense for the last qtr and a half. Where we'll likely be looking to protect a lead...

And white...

WTF would Jon Ralph know...

You're not wrong Praha. I was in Adelaide for the game v Port in R4 2022. The one where Port kicked their first goal half way through the 3rd quarter... Every Port supporter I spoke to, both strangers and those known to me were: Certain they'd win before the game Looked at me like i had steaming [censored] protruding from my face when I mentioned we were reigning premiers and coming in to the game undefeated And completely astounded they didn't win after the game Just bizarre...

I feel like Brad Green kicked 6 at some stage and I reckon Cam Bruce did too (or perhaps 8 or 9 against the blues one time?)

No chance

If nothing else I am confident the FD have given a lot of thought to the factors that resulted in our straight sets exit last year and have plans to prevent those factors from recurring. I would agree with most posters here that having our key players as fit and free from injury as much as humanly possible come Septmber is paramount. Theoretically there are many ways to achieve that and it doesn't necessarily have to be through players missing games...that said I can't see why we'd be putting Gawn on a plane to Hobart if we didn't have to.

Hibbert... Hibberd...

Such a wonderful thing to imagine though...!

I agree. if not resting Max entirely at least lighten his workload a touch. Plus it provides a chance to experiment with Grundy in the forward line. He won't be learning much forward craft at Casey with a bye or scratch match at best

I think we all know for sure they will save it for the last round against Melbourne 🙉