Jump to content

whatwhat say what

Life Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by whatwhat say what

  1. whatwhat say what replied to Romey's post in a topic in Melbourne Demons
    mcg precinct was dead long ago caulfield will be a far better result imo really hope this is all true
  2. entertaining contest
  3. i'd argue it took trac 5 pre-seasons, not including the one where he did his knee whereas viney came in-built with said tank so...depends on the individual? someone like tapscott could never build it, as an example
  4. this was the first year that sestan has been given significant game time in the middle at vfl level - he deserves at least a full year to get up to the required fitness levels to go from a deep forward to a midfielder from watching a lot of the casey streams in the last few years, what's clear is that the talent and skill is there but the tank and the consistency needs significant improvement i'm confident that sestan has attributes to compete at afl level - i see him as similar to a player like harmes who was far fitter yet still took his time to establish himself in a significantly poorer side, first as a forward who could play a bit as a mid, then as a tagger, then eventually as a second rotation mid in his own right
  5. fingers crossed clayton doesn't have the same slide into ignominy
  6. All these good people staying on? Kulcha
  7. on the list - sparrow, chandler, tholstrup, pup brown coming onto the list - noah yze, who looks to have a strong running game as one of his core strengths
  8. sounds like the sort of thing he would do his fall from skipper to the slums was super sad
  9. maintain it's a complete bargain for the crom essentially anb for mcadam i know who i'd rather have; i know who plays afl regularly and who is mired in the magoos
  10. my best guess... blue for northern academy red for sa yellow for wa i thought it might be bold for vic country but that doesn't seem to be the case...
  11. gosh he's tiny does anyone know if he's actually eligible to be selected by us, or is it another ah-mu myth?
  12. you just KNOW that polynesia will be included in 2026 and beyond
  13. pfft, you don't want to talk to the hoi polloi when there's corporates to engage!
  14. whatwhat say what replied to adonski's post in a topic in Melbourne Demons
    i think it's a moot point regardless, as it seems we're not in the conversation for him all the talk seems to be that the cats are his most likely destination as they are prepared to take on his full wage and see him as a first rotation midfielder going forward
  15. whatwhat say what replied to adonski's post in a topic in Melbourne Demons
    i don't see how he can play the nibbler role at all if we had shipped one of petracca or oliver, sure, but another not-quick first-possession midfielder is not what we need
  16. jack steven was a former aints skipper who had a slew of off-field issues, including being stabbed in the chest shortly after the trade to the puddy tatts was completed he didn't even complete a full season down in sleepy hollow and retired at the end of his first season with a year to go on his contract
  17. he's our second most experienced player and should, if he keeps his form up and has a bit of luck with his body, go past 250 games great story indeed
  18. speed interview was a very good listen but i doubt very much he would have spoken about the tigs quite like that - stating that the review was a “last resort to reset the club” was overly dramatic it'll be interesting to see how public the club make any findings from it - clearly speed is of the belief that it should be kept entirely under wraps and not publicised but you know the medja is going to be baying for blood over it
  19. whatwhat say what replied to Romey's post in a topic in Melbourne Demons
    well i don't think any review will exactly help push caulfield along so...pretty much irrelevant?
  20. And meth coke would still say no; Reid is a special talent
  21. Sounds like something the MFC would have been long aware of - I suspect the news about his ineligibility is to calm the fawning masses (e.g. us) from getting over excited about a player we were never eligible to select
  22. Jack Stevens
  23. swans mate tells me callum mills did his hammy at training today