Jump to content

george_on_the_outer

Moderators

Everything posted by george_on_the_outer

  1. How much easier if it is a goal if it goes through the goals. No touched, no posters, no guessing. Would also force defenders to keep the ball in play rather than try to put it through. I have never worked out how a "touched goal" is a point, but a "touched behind" is also a point.
  2. Maybe he saw you on the big screen at the match, like we all did?
  3. Why are you euphoric?
  4. Allocations are 50:50 to competing clubs.
  5. Great report @Meggs.....after the game, I heard comments by Bec Goddard, the Hawthorn coach. She noted the interchange cap of 60 really limits most sides who only have 2 or 3 mids of quality. This means they will have to spend longer on the field and as a result tire. Importantly, she noted Melbourne has 5 or 6 quality mids unlike other sides.....Purcell, Hanks, Mithen, Paxman, West, McNamara and even Hore and Heath were run through there in this game. Combined with now 2 rucks in Pearce and Campbell ( a revelation in this game). It means we can keep running fresh bodies through the middle without taking them off the ground. This game was the perfect example with Davey and Bonnici tiring badly, and Taub-Frederick unsighted in the second half, apart from on the bench.
  6. ....and if you don't receive the email, how will they know? If you do receive the email but don't notice it, how will they know?
  7. Pies will be much stronger this year with the return of Davey and Bonnici. Good to see Eliza McNamara back to strengthen the mids. Our side is looking particularly strong as well, given Gabby Colvin can't get into the side for her return after injury. She was definitely one of the first selected in the past. And when Rhi Watt and our super smokey Aimee Makin aren't in the running, it makes for a truly competitive unit. We just have to stop Livingstone controlling the backline for them, so someone out of Hore, Harris or Zanker has to make her accountable, particularly in marking contests.
  8. Why? He certainly isn't going to be playing AFL level any time soon, and is not going to be playing in a Premiership side any day. He hasn't been used without TMac, BBB, Petty & Fritsch out injured, so what is the value? Just get another kid in the draft
  9. Why does the team need 3 FF's and 3 FB's while they name only 1 ruck ( English)? Curnow, Walker and Larkey. FF's Wilkie(wtf!), Stewart, Moore. even Sicily? FB's It just means very good players in other positions get denied. e.g Rowan Marshall is a far superior player to Callum WIlkie.
  10. Let one go through to the keeper??
  11. Finally.....we have someone running the show. This position, while temporarily filled by Laura on a part time basis since only May, has been vacant since the departure of Brad Scott nearly 12 months ago. All while she has been doing other tasks. It is no surprise that the furore around umpiring, goal reviews, fixturing and biggest of all the CBA ( still not agreed after nearly 2 years) are tasks for the GM of Football. A fine mess you have left for the lady Gil.......
  12. Any chance we can get a couple of copies then. We seem to be running out of forwards.
  13. Also covered by Pink in more recent times. Alice was Alice Liddell, who urged Charles Dodgson ( Lewis Carroll) to write the story of Alice in Wonderland.
  14. The difference between pick 8 and pick 6 is nothing. There are multiple examples of good/better players being selected behind others. Geelongs next pick in this draft is pick 82. They have more problems than trying to gain pick 6 instead of 8. You cannot rebuild with 1 player. Tanking used to be all about gaining EXTRA picks under a defined formula. That disappeared years ago, so there is no longer any incentive to tank.
  15. Only boomers would understand that....
  16. I think you kick better on your left when on a set shot, but have noticed doing more on the right lately. what is your preferred?
  17. At a sponsors event in early 2021 we were told there would be an announcement by year end by the CEO. ...still running the same line.....
  18. ...another week to go...FIFA requires the stadiums to be free for a week AFTER the last game is played. https://sport.optus.com.au/news/womens-world-cup-2023/os59834/fifa-womens-world-cup-2023-host-stadiums-melbourne-aami-park
  19. No he has a broken wrist
  20. When the AFL and multiple medical specialists are hell bent on trying to reduce the effects of head knocks, and warning of its long term consequences, it seems rather silly to be pursuing this activity.
  21. Spot on.....Alan Joyce at Hawthorn when he took over for one year from Jeans. They had won the Premiership in '86, runners up in '87 and under Joyce ruined our hopes in '88, and took out the Premiership in '89.
  22. Maybe we could call it "appointment" then.......same as " by appointment to HM of Romsey Manor" Surely a bit of extra internet browsing of dubious opposition sites, could sit alongside with browsing of other dubious internet sites? Or you could "delegate" said task to one of your underlings?
  23. Should do this tonight…..
  24. How the mighty Hawthorn have fallen.......love it, we always knew they were fudging their figures.