Redleg

Would be great to see him extend his contract with us.

Well done Jack. hopefully BOG in a winning side.

He never went for a ball that was there to mark. He braced and hit a player going for the ball. He could have even just put his arm out and spoiled. That is the problem. IMO the concussion came from the player hitting his head on the ground.

Tom is bigger than Tommo.

With 8.03 left in 2nd Quarter, Chol runs up behind Max and lifts his knee, hitting Max in the back. We know he hit May and he also got JVR high with a knee in a ruck contest. This knee first type of play is more than coincidence imo.

I would swap Tommo and Tom Mac. Tom Mac is better suited to Dixon and Tommo to Marshall.

This will make you happy. IMO Jeffo and Kolt will be regular players for us in the future.

If that’s the case, he probably needs to get in before McAdam is ready to go. AMW had another good game for Casey, good not great.

Great player but a repeat stager.

Webber, is it just semantics on words “cracked and fractured” or medically, are they quite different when discussing rib injuries? Whatever, I see May missing both Adelaide games and then the Lions and with the bye, he would have a 5 week recovery. That is the non medical assessment of course.

Yes he was, but he didn’t and got 2 weeks. That’s the very point. They are just so inconsistent. The MRO and Tribunal said Maynard did nothing wrong. He knocked an opponent out cold, ended a guy’s career and possibly cost us a flag, but the 2 bodies responsible for this said “nothing to see.” Yes the MRO and Tribunal trigger me.

But the Tribunal has already ruled a hard bump can whiplash the head and cause a concussion. They have suspended previously. Ask Kozzie about his low impact to Bailey Smiths chest, how he felt about the 2 weeks suspension he got.

Box Hill have 3 of them running around today.

Any talk on Newcomes’ late shirtfront on Clarry?

And hopefully Horne Francis hamstring is at least a 2 gamer. PS: Butters should be fined for staging. Just on half time milked a 50 and goal, pretending Lynch hit him in the head after a mark. Nothing said because he is a star, but not the first time.

Tracc- what a footballer Clarry- contested ball goat

If Newcombe doesn’t get suspended for that shirtfront on Clarry, after he got rid of the ball, they are pathetic. Clarry’s head jolted back and he hit the ground and it was a very hard bump. The very thing that can lead to concussion. That is a suspension.

Not sure he is even that good.

Carlton by the circumference of Earth.

Has anyone noticed that when you watch Foxtel footy in 4K, it’s a slightly better picture than HD, but the sound is out of sync with the picture?

Battle of the the Hustwaites

Only one way to stop it, jail time.

Little Mac or Mac Jnr.

No and yes.

The older players like Pendles, Sidebottom and Howe are struggling and it is costing them. I still think a few of them won't see out the season.