DaveyJones'sLocker

i dont know how the voting works.... but i have a feeling it might be somthin like this 1.Brock 2.Bruce (just behind) 3.Green (just behind) 4. jones 5. could be between Aussie wheatley and maybe miller mcdonald really has not stood out this year, his work effort is still great but i just cant see him gettin as many votes as the above

went to school with brent and spoke to him a few times on the off season. told me he was happy at the cats and would stay there this year.

i think we should remove this thread. he did a good job on goodes and found some ball himself which was an improvment. who would u bring back?

prismall never asked to be traded last year.

get back to u later fudge, going to watch the replay of todays game

criticism LOL u are going to get crucified for this trash

ur posts get worse every day.....

LOL

2 things i already started this topic , but it got moved into the davey hanger thread Do u realise foley is very fast and dunn came from behind mclean who was chasing foley and still manged to tackle him.... the goal is irrelevant the effort isnt

Everyone get on afl.com and vote for aaron davey for mark of the round. was a nice grap, not mark of the year but it would be nice to see him in contention with Robbo and u can see the footage again on the site Also vote for dunn for the afl army award, look at this footage some good work by dunn ,

"Richmond’s Shane Tuck can accept a $1950 sanction with an early plea for making negligent contact with an umpire in the Tigers’ win over Melbourne on Sunday." wouldnt mind seeing the replay again but that would be one terrible decision from the afl, he was clearly pushed by brock

he should be a tagger. excpet there is no one else who will fill his role. and the problem with mclean is he is not as near as damaging as i wish he would be.

id think if his role was so important and there was noone to replace him, you would assume it would be unlikley he would get dropped. and for memory this is not the first time this year i think ur just being stubborn, he has been useless and its not like we are tryin to replace a neitz or mclean etc

guess the proofs in the pudding ey Out bell in whelan CJ emergency frawley

i think ull find on monday medhurst had a pretty poor game, credit to bell but as the game went on medhurst pushed a lil furhter up the ground at times, and i would have liked to see bell run off and get more possesion like when he had the shot on goal.

have to agree with the wise yze magic hes played as well as miller if not worse over his career, and atleast miller adds toughness and is not injury prone

average to good games maybe! not good, point being his position is not the hardest to play, nor easiest BUT its likley he could be easily replaced by cj bode frawley if fit, whelan, and if his short term replacement/s find some form, he may miss several weeks, and has his self to blame

u say whelan is a better chance than any, when he is the smallest of the lot. bode is about 4-5cm smaller than bell. and i think ur grossly overrating bells speed and agility, when frawley would be the same if not better. 'bell is easily replacable, but they might not replace him directly' ? what type of statement is that? it means he is playing [censored] and deserves to be dropped and any player put in his place could prob do a better job for the time being, if not another player can come in and player (unknown) could be moved into bells POSITION which also u are grossly overrating (ur making it sound like BELL KPP? ) your giving to much credit to a player that has done [censored] all year,he might have stopped is opponent at times, but he doesnt help out his team mates, he has no awareness and as shown on monday he consistantly creates COSTLY TURNOVERS, ur basing ur whole argument on height and speed when height can hardly be considered significant unless u can give me there agility and 20 m sprint results from draft camp i might review my opinion

umpiring was very good..... sure didak was lucky for the first goal. but it was touch and go.... my main problem still lies with the holding the ball decision/incorrect disposal it very touch n go, between nathan jones gettin penalised and josh fraser not getting penalised i wouldnt mind seeing these two again also daniel bells dont argue... i think the player should have a right to push off a tackle, it may have been high but it was not open fist and no elbow. i guess fingers in the eye is a problem. i would like to see the replay on that one to

Last year he was GREAT .... this year he has gone so far backwards its crazy. one thing which did impress me when i watched the replay his kick on goal was from inside the centre sqaure! apart from that it was very ugly he cost us atleast 2 goals. as for frawley being to tall ... why is that a problem? if anything its a plus, we all know frawley is still pri fast and buckley is not that strong i know, but i guess he might provide more run from the back, at times on monday bartram was back playing on didak, but i think he is hardly a "strong" defender and he seemed to do well on a few occasions. u got Carroll Whelan Garland Warnock Wheatley Frawley Bode CJ bell i think bells spot in the team is easily replacable, these players might not replace him directly but a re-jig of the side and he is out the door. i think u will agree.

i dunno... dunn seems pretty mercurial to me..... he has the ability to do some really good things..... i just hope one day he can explode on to the scene. take a look at alot of his goals over his career, lot of really nice snap or cheaky goals. done some good taggin roles but id like to see him come into the game more

did u watch the game???????????? he might be a good kick in general ... but it was very bad today i sugest u watch the replay.

I couldn't really care less about Caro.

Moloney wat an ANIMAL.... i loved his game today was into everything and everyone ...... at a time when our clubs seems to never sheperd the player with the ball, moloney loves it.... somtmes maybe he gets in one to many fight.... but i think its alot of heart and passion hope he can recover ASAP

certain incident with moloney and bartel comes to mind.... also apparently goodes has no good of bad record so he can get 25% discount.... .goodes should rot in hell