Deeoldfart

I've always made a point of not criticizing the MFC on here, but the absence of any information about this match, with senior selections potentially hinging on it, is shameful. It disrespects us supporters who, after all, are the lifeblood of the Club. Grrrr!

I rate myself very lucky to have been been around in our 'glory years', and mention of the names from that era bring the memories flooding back. To coin a modern day phrase, I'm still 'proud to belong'. I have a wife, 3 kids and 5 grand kids, all of whom share my passion (they had little choice on that!). I only hope that they, and all Demonlanders who have not had the privilege, will soon experience the joy of #13.

Agree, but the concern for me is that the VFL doesn't start until 17 April. Horrible arrangement if we are looking for our under-done players to have one or two serious / competitive hit-outs to get them cherry ripe for the seniors. Same applies to other clubs who have a VFL team as their 'ressies'.

I'm moderately surprised at the lack of love for the Dees ......... but at least reading these predictions won't provide a lot of bathwater for our boys to drink.

Brilliant work PF. Thanks for effort on behalf of all of us!!

When you do the basics right, you give yourself a chance. When you don't, you give yourself no chance. That just about sums it up.

I'm absolutely gutted for the kid. Nobody deserves that sort of luck. Bloody hard, but 'keep your head up' Aaron.

Why couldn't we play like that in the first half (goalkicking notwithstanding)?

My assessment was based on what I saw in the B match against Richmond, and the odd mention in training reports. Based on these (albeit limited) showings, he seems way off the pace to me. The 2020 draft was compromised by the limited exposure of many of the Vic based kids, and for this reason it's likely that many decent prospects were overlooked by us, and other clubs. I'd much rather give these kids an opportunity to show their wares early, and pick one up mid-year, based on performance (ie. best available principle). Koby's turn will come then (or most likely later) IF he's good enough!

He looked 'lost' for most of the practice game against Richmonds B and C graders. I can't see him being given a rookie spot based on that performance. If possible, I'd like to see him get a spot on the Casey list for the upcoming season. That way we could ensure that he has a specifically tailored work program and see how he progresses. Maybe a list spot next year IF he shows enough.

We need to win this one. The addition of two of our top liners makes us much stronger. Go Dees! https://www.melbournefc.com.au/news/869739/aflw-round-5-team-two-additions-for-pies-clash

Clarry has been very good from day one. Extremely resilient, having played through a heap of his 99 games with a bung shoulder. Definitely has it in him to go to another level, especially with a bit of tuition and guidance from Adem.

Early days, and the opposition was VFL level, but it's easy to see why we took Bowey and Laurie in the first round. Both are 'natural' footballers and have the class we are crying out for. Petty should be a 'lock' against the Dogs next weekend. Beyond these three, not too much to get excited about from the B game. Rosman showed glimpses of potential, but is not a 'natural', and will take time.

1. Great just to have footy back. 2. Credit to our boys for the win over the best team in the comp., especially given we had some key 'outs'. 3. Pleased to see how well the forward line functioned, even with our two main KPFs on the sidelines. Can only see improvement when they return. Increased competition for small forward spots is great. I 50 tackling pressure looks to have improved. 4. Defense held up ok with May and Lever clear standouts, but need to apply more pressure to oppo small forwards 5. Mids won the day, even without Viney and Brayshaw. Max, Clarrie and Tracc continue to be a class above. The stand--in mids were solid 5. The game plan seemed better, with flexibility, and run and carry through the corridor. I'm always an optimist at this time of year, but I didn't see too much to deter my confidence for 2021.

Chandler ok. Bang, a goal. RIPPA!

Great choice 'soup! That last 5 minutes was unbelievable, and the outpouring of emotion that followed it will live with me until the day they drape my old red and blue jumper over a pine box. For an old fart like me, the only possible rival would be the last 5 mins of the 1964 GF vs Collingwood ...... the Froggy Crompton goal and the Ray Gabelich 'drunken' run. Indelible memories!

Very sad. I will never forget Murray's clashes with RDB during our golden era. They were epic. Sympathies to Sam and the Weideman family.

Damn, it never rains but it pours on the injury front! ............. but hopefully Tom Mac, 'Tom' Petty and Jacko can make it rain goals, to compensate for BBB and Weid's crap luck.

Well, at least C'wood now has some chance of developing a culture befitting the 21st century.

A typically honest chat with Tom. Leaving no stone unturned to get back to his best, and if he can, it will make us a better side, no matter what position(s) he plays.

It's a long way from home (in a couple of respects), but I'm almost starting to believe.

Great choice! Just another reason to be a 'Demonlander'.

For the first couple of seasons, the AFLW frustrated me, but that's all changed. I now respect and enjoy it for what it is, and look forward to it as an exciting prelude to the AFL season. A close game involving the Dees has me on the edge of the lounge, and after a win, I sing the song almost as loud as I do for the men.

Great article, great memories. Thanks WJ

Great work Stinga, thanks! Is it just me, or is there a hint of 'Demonland' excitement in the air?