Bystander

Good appointment. Look forward to Geelong v Casey in 2023.

Needs to do more of a lot of things.

That doesn't make a lot of sense to me. No point playing in the 2's if a foot is dodgy. Better to play firsts if able and rest if unable. 14? games plus finals may be ok. I doubt his doctors have indicated as reported this far out and would have made that suggestion in any event.

Correct. That is why so many bakeries here are run by Vietnamese. French colonial architecture great also. Strategic exits, not so good.

In previous years players got slaps on the back and some abuse over the fence. Now there is an avalanche of personal criticism. "Your opinion of me is none of business" would help. But easier said than done.

I would be interested to read the business plan. I've read hundreds over many years and have yet to see one which didn't show a resounding success.

Does anyone know how to get access to the draft rules ?

I would say you are correct: Brown Bedford Tomlinson and Weideman did far more than both Laurie and Woewodin. I wouldn't say the top 3 ( deservedly ) "carried" the team. Far from it. Very widely spread effort with spots very contested for non listed players. But White and Munro outstanding competitors.

Hi Sue, I hope you never get to sit on a jury.

What I mean is that I would be surprised if those accused of this agree with what has been alleged. Those accused are entitled to give their version of events. Independent means independent. It is not clear if the authors of the report spoke to the alleged perpetrators.

Who did the review?In the absence of admissions, documents or independent witnesses it will never be fully resolved.

In the absence of admissions, documents or independent witnesses it will never be fully resolved.

Very hard to absorb this. But there shouldn't be a rush to judgement. Such a shame. There better be a coherent response.

What a great day. After some early jitters, the boys just didn't blink. Relentless in pretty uncomfortable conditions. They were never going to lose with that application. They seemed to have played the whole season in good spirit. Only one gripe. Why oh why do they play that terrible music after goals. It is horrible. After a goal you want to cheer, boo, explain, clarify to your mate, complain about the umpire, whatever. Leave the music to sports that need it. Our game doesn't. Go Casey.

Saw Daisy's comments. Also read with interest the comments of that girl who won MasterChef. Goodwin? Can't wait to hear from someone from The Block.

No, Grey wasn't playing for Casey in 2018. He was still at st Bede's. I am told by his schoolmate that he won 5 straight GFs at st Bede's plus 6 straight at Beaumaris. Tomorrow will be 12 in 7 completed seasons plus a Herald Sun shield if Casey wins.

Agree

Munro unlucky.

I'm not sure $ can be spent on players. There are very modest caps in place?

Human nature being what it is, I can't help thinking that if a few players had been demoted for poor form the rest of the team would have found something extra in the second halves. I know my performance at home improves if I think I might be replaced the next week.

I believe Rivers is ineligible, played more than 12 AFL games. Bowey same.

Agree, the commentary around the Rosman incident was inappropriate..very 1970's. In fairness, the commentators have only an instant to frame their words. But not good.

I believe they are both good to play. My understanding is that because Joel Smith didn't play in a home and away AFL game after 1 July, he doesn't need to have played 6 VFL games. Tom is also good to go...he didn't play an AFL game after 1 July, so similar applies. My understanding is bowey can't play as he played more than 12 AFL games. Rules are poorly written plus I stand to be corrected.

Perhaps Malthouse can help the demons negotiate the Grundy deal as he did for Carlton with Daisy. Oh, hang on...

I'll speak to charles