old55

Nope can't see a doctor if you can't run. Medicare rules.

If Tyson is on $500k as suggested here then there's salary cap dump involved too which helps our cause. I expect Preuss will come on less per year over 4 years. That is a factor in evening out the trade value.

Norf poster at Big Footy referring to him as Andrew Gagf.

Maybe it's because Carlton have got 26, 28 and 43 to offer and we've got 36 and 46?

Agree and there's only a finite capacity for player welfare at the club. There's an opportunity cost associated with burning a whole lot of it on one potentially problem player.

Massive accusation totally unsupported by evidence. http://www.melbournefc.com.au/news/2018-08-14/hogan-eager-to-help-teammates “The doc told me there was a bit of a stress over the navicular [bone], so it’s three to four weeks completely off it, and then three to four weeks in the moon boot. I’m just trying to prepare for 2019. Did he wear a moon boot for 3-4 weeks for laughs?

Injured after break-out game - disappointing for Billy and the club.

Good initiative,. But the main issue is posters opening new accounts - it's hard to control that though and I don't think you should bother trying. The community will call this out when necessary - most long term posters have a distinctive style.

You say your opinion never changes but that is a very limiting approach - everyone sometimes gets it wrong about a player's potential. What did you think of Jake Melksham before he was recruited? Has your opinion changed there at all?

You're very keen to call out other posters' shortcomings recently, that's about the third time in as many days. A quick tour through the "Is Goodwin the right guy" thread doesn't enhance your own reputation for foresight.

"Get a big dish of Beef Chow Mein"

I think it does matter because posters should own their posting history. That said like @Nasher said I changed my username but it is pretty transparent. Some of the best posters here like @Vogon Poetry and @ProDee have had various incarnations for various reasons but it's fine if it's transparent I think.

No but I like to dine at Lee Ho Fook

Thanks. @RalphiusMaximus would've been more worried about the Lewis recruitment if it did apply

Just for interest, is there ever a player you have been positive about recruiting? In my observation you have dissed every opposition player we have shown interest in. Then once they arrive - alchemy!

Kreuger is likely to be able to play too. Geelong's recent record with this type is excellent - Tim Kelly and Stewart. If Carlton use the pick on say Setterfield then it looks closer to the AFL intent.

Good post - you're very welcome here from my POV. I agree and was hoping for that lose-lose outcome.

WTF are you talking about. What's this "lifetime ban" rule. You've been watching too many US cop shows "3 strikes ..."

That would make you my grand son.

Let's stick to your expert subject. Would Norm Smith trade Hogan?

Started using the "Next Unread Topic" button on the Trade board to navigate between threads - very happy with how it works. Revisiting its value on this board though after stumbling in here ... Don't get me wrong - I'm very happy for all you dawgies to be contained in this here corral.

Well that idea went stale pretty quickly - 42 now at Carlton from AFL Trade Talk:

42 now at Carlton from AFL Trade Talk:

Sydney don't have a 3rd rounder - they have 13 and 31 (after Lynch compo). Might end up with this pick 42 for VDB - not ideal.

Getting in deeper. Brisbane's pick hand weakened further with this trade and they now have 5, 23, 54, 57 for Neale and Adams. Brisbane's future picks will have to be on the table - they'll be banking on improving next year too which is very reasonable.