picket fence

Grimes shouldn't get a game for starters, Harmes Kennedy, Bugg, right now are the future and much better! Probably quicker as well! Would prefer any of these ex Grimes to get a game at present!

Still to be answered! Where would he play and who would he replace??

Yeah well I can't wait to see your, "Sheeit Fence was right! response"! He has missed 2 plus years out! Name any other player that has had such an extensive time out that has come back? Look he was reasonably good early, but in all honesty given his injuries and the pace of the game , can anyone really see him forcing a place in this current side?? And if so what position would he play?? In front of Who??

Yeah well I can't wait to see your, "Sheeit Fence was right! response"! He has missed 2 plus years out! Name any other player that has had such an extensive time out that has come back? Look he was reasonably good early, but in all honesty given his injuries and the pace of the game , can anyone really see him forcing a place in this current side?? And if so what position would he play?? In front of Who??

Their list is PUTRID! I, for one wouldn't mind seeing them go out of business ! Period! Get rid of them and get a Team from Tassie involved! Unbelievably they and supporters ,Still cannot accept they did anything wrong! Get rid of the cancerous idealistic,cheats! who put themselves above all else including the game! OUT!

Paaark Me! Jeremy Bloody Cameron! [censored] a million pages about one less than proven player and we go through Purgatory thinking our first game might be decided on whether this bloke plays!?? We are Melbourne and going along very nicely indeed! What Greater Western [censored] have to fear is OUR MAGNIFICENT RESURGENCE!! GO DEES

Club employee!?? ah with a club foot?? 5-7 WEEKS?? for Trengove this would be a disaster! For Demonland followers re Petracca this might push a few " Over the Edge" Into the Abyss!

Nup! Questionable!!?

After yesterday and assuming Pederson doesn't get suspended I think Out Lumumba ( not ready) Grimes too slow and turnover King! possibly M Jones IN KENNEDY & HARMES possibly Brayshaw ( depending on fitness! Also Trengove?? Seriously hasn't played for nearly two years game will have passed him by

Who?? Past Tense player will not get a game unless team extremely depleated! That's assuming he actually gets on the park! IMV both Trengove and Grimes, far too slow for the game now. Just look at how Slow Grimes was yesterday!! Out with the Old, In with the New Guard! The rebuild is progressing beautifully!

I wanted Wines we got Toumpas I wanted Oliver and we got him, Sheeit how many on this site now would have Curnow, Parrish and others now?? Yeah, not too bloody many! Sigh, Oliver is one of the brightest stars we have had in a long while, could be anything and I'm tipping 200 games plus! Thank Christmas we got one high pick right, FINALLY!

Rob Flower never wore one!!

For discussion, Norm Smith clearly the best Melbourne Coach and maybe the best coach of all time! I know Checker Hughes statistically just on Premiershipos alone must have been a superb coach, but given what John Northey after us being so down and out for 25 odd years, is there any merit in thinking that he was a better coach than Checker Hughes?? Then of course we have a raft of coaches after that The Rev, Barrassi etc. Anyway just thought I would spark a bit of debate!

Tom Mc Donald ????? Seriously????

Jack Trengove will really struggle to play another senior game at the MFC. Anyone who thinks otherwise then do this.... Pick your best 22 and decide who you would play! Would Trengove get a game??? And what position would you play him?? Hard??you betcha! After that then come back to me ! Too long out! Unfortunate but ... lets focus on reality! Eh

Rob Flower never wore one!!

Agree Lumumba cannot possibly get a gig Round 1!

Agree with Dazzle and ohers He is the weak link in the core chain, 1 Can be outpositioned 2 Makes elementary Skill errors 3 Worse still some of his decision making leaves a lot to be desired as well! I reckon throw Frost back to CHB and play him as a "Wild Card" Forward He is far too iffy defense. Also if he wants to hedge on contract negotiations , So be it I don't actually rate him that highly!

I was at Highgate arena today and I watched him very closely. I will file a comprehensive player personel report later but I have to say. This Bloke is the "Real Deal" On so many levels he is an inspired selection. I say inspired because the Toumpas fiasco of yesteryear, The pressure to pick Darcy Parish, and or one or two others. So I'll give you my observations, 1 He set's himself in the right position for Offence or Defense 2 He has uncanny spatial competency! I'll call it the Dr. Who factor! He creates time and appears that he has plenty of time and peripheral vision to assess the right option for disposal which he gives off effortlessly. I have previously called the is the "Greg Williams" effect. I reckon if Greg saw him he would agree coz he's just as tough and Quicker!!!!!! 3 I saw him dispose of by foot today and he is very precise and clinical. 4 He has serious "Grunt Factor" got crunched once or twice got up dusted himself of and stared again. 5 Went for a few "Species" again don't mind a Mid playing tall, infact he was in FF for a period of time 6 He is taller than I first imagined but with good Musculature in the Thighs which then prepare him for good "Core" strength. I hope I'm not getting ahead of myself but Sheeit I reckon he is Bloody GOLD nugget! I'm putting a lazy $50 on him as the 2016 Rising star and I hope to Christmas he doesn't read Demomland and I've' put the mozz on him Oh one other thing I agree with Dazzle Man, I don;t read anything into the Chuckin and 70% game time It was friggen Bloody hot out there today!!

"Oh ye men of lttle faith"

Not to mention "other Issues"... lets be frank, Bloke shafted us, got good money and up and left. But agree we sure did dodge that bullet!

Can I suggest if not mentioned before that when the essendrug faithful stand and applaud we turn in the opposite direction and put our arms and hands across our chests in defiance of this cheating mongrel club!

I am going to buy a general entry ticket, proudly wearing my MFC Colors, sit right in the middle of the see no evil, hear no evil, do no evil supporters and let fly with the biggest Sledgefest I can muster!!

Quad insertion tendon tear?? Given the riding into the ground with knees bent I wouldn't put this out of the question. If it is this ah he will be missing for a while! I also would question that you would wait for Julian Feller if thats who they are waiting for. Many other emminent specialists around such as Prof Richard De Steiger, Dirk Van Bavel, Cameron Norsworthy, all very very highly regarded!

Sheeit Bobby I played a truck load of cricket but this ones got me stumped!! Just wondering if its got something to do with boundary permeters ???