Bring-Back-Powell

I can’t see GC finishing bottom 4 next year.

I could be assessing that incorrectly but that’s a great deal for Carlton. I highly rate Hayward.

Hawks looking like they’ll miss out out Merrett if the footage of the Hawthorn room is an indication. They should’ve offered up a player of note.

Interesting. I just heard David King and Jon Ralph slamming us for paying the entirety of Steele’s wages on Fox’s Trading day. King said it’s a poor pick up without actually uttering the words. He’s allegedly on a $1 million a year.

Wouldn’t be shocked if this happens. I hope it doesn’t for King’s first game.

Happy to get a couple of solid citizens in Steele and Checkers.

Yep count me in for wanting GC to have a horse manure 2026. At least three clubs will fall out of the 8 next year. GC could be one of them if they fail to take the next step which isn’t new for a club who has finally broken their finals drought (can think of one club in 2018 into 2019) Alternatively they could finish 7th and lose their wild card game and end up finishing 9th (assuming the wild card weekend comes in)

On a scale of Harry Sharp to peak Steve May, you’d probably have this at a 6 in terms of opposition recruits. Solid pick up if he can remain injury free and can bring some speed to the team.

I’m not buying into the “let’s circle back next year” narrative. I expect us to win less games next year, even with Goodwin gone, while Hawthorn probably make a prelim at worst. I’d have a hard time believing a potential champion in the making choosing a bottom 4 side over a team on the verge of a flag. If BH was indeed interested in coming to the MFC, this trade week was now or never and we couldn’t get it done/GC wouldn’t allow it to get done.

Statistically he plummeted this year. He went from his career high point in 2021 with 29 touches per game and 26 Brownlow votes to just 20 touches and 2 votes this year. I still wouldn’t mind him. Veterans can have a career renaissance at a new club. For example Luke Parker was more than serviceable for North this year.

Really wish we as the club had taken this stance both publicly and in the negotiations. We had the best leverage tool in holding Trac unless GC caved in with BH. (Maybe GC aren’t even that desperate for Trac given they’re so resolute in keeping BH) We’ve obviously told Trac to clear out his locker and he’s not coming back under any circumstances.

Carlton mooted to get two first rounders and Hayward and Florent. What else are we getting on top of our first rounders for Trac?

I’d be happy if we got 2015 Lumumba productivity from CJ. (2016 not so much…)

Not a bad pick up. Bits and pieces of his career has been exciting. Received 4 coaches votes against us in round 9 so I’ll have to watch the replay to see what he did that day to warrant votes.

Played a blinder against us in our earlier loss to them this year. Got 4 or 5 coaches votes that day.

Pretty much agree with this. With Trac and Clarry with us next year we probably win 8 or 9 games instead of 5, 6 or 7 without them. Hardly needle moving. It will hurt seeing them in different colours in the first 4 rounds of next year, and potentially finals, but we’ll move on like we have with Luke Jackson.

The very uncharitable side of me kind of hopes the Petracca trade is emailed to the AFL at 7:30:03 and therefore deemed null and void.

I enjoye the 5 minutes an hour of actual content on Trade Radio. (Not so much the other 55 minutes of the same irritating ads on repeat)

I suppose the return we’re getting from GC is going to be less than we hope if they’re going to pay Trac’s entire salary. Being freed from his salary is a win for us. A boring behind the scenes win, but a win nonetheless.

Yes. 7 and 8 is reasonable. Why do we have to bend over backwards to satisfy Gold Coast when they’re the ones gaining a player that could help take them to a prelim or even GF next year? I don’t care about GC’s academy picks. I only care about getting proper recompense for losing a super star.

Trac might get lucky and the Suns home attendances dramatically increase to 13K a game.

Hopefully Rankine kicks another 6 on him next year and he plays out the year at Peel Thunder.

I’m loving the comedy value and suspense of this thread. An all time great thread. But it’s time move on from BH I reckon. Let’s enjoy the next wave of talent that picks 7 and 8 will deliver us (or a new list manager if he fails to secure those picks)

Quality player who had a down year. He’d easily be one of our better kicks if we acquire him. Spargo comp for him?

Disappointing to lose two games to mediocre teams that won't be playing finals this year (maybe Freo sneak in but Port are BOG average) Would really like to take a scalp in Brisbane in the last round to give the girls some confidence for the finals. St Kilda was clearly our best win of the year, but I'm not sure I'd include them in the elite bracket.