deeflog

Some twit over on Big footy is saying that its basically a done deal that Davey is going to Collingwood for their first round pick and Chris Dawes. He is saying Anthony Corrie is his cousin and they desperately want to play together, and this is the only way it will happen. I would have thought if they want to play together, the only way it was going to happen was in the reserves, as thats all Corrie is good for I personally find it very very hard to believe, but what do others think?

must have been a shallow draft that year

wouldn't have thought he deserved one

how would Brock fit in at Sydney? the smaller ground would suit him better, so if he is tempted to walk out could a deal be struck with sydney for their first round pick?

Shane Tuck has been told by Richmond you are free to find yourself a new home, and is reportedly of to sydney

I personally would not go after burgoyne. He is too much of a risk with his knees, and when we are ready to have a crack at the flag i don't think we will be able to help us

the hawks are not going to want both Gibson and Rivers, so you can rule him out, but i do think Jamar could get this trade scenario done, and if thats all it took i would do it in a heart beat

There is a quick and simple answer to this.... No chance!!

What mahoney has at his dispoal does not help his cause, no argument there, although it is getting better, but there just seems to be a lack of structure there, no improvement from the forwards, especially shots at goal. I just think westy would give us more than what mahoney is capable of

i would have thought thats how clubs have looked at trading for the past 100 years, its the fans and media that make biased and unreasonable trade scenarios

I think the other 3 should be Buckley, Bartram and if we can't trade McNamara then delist him. buckley has plenty of competition in his position now, and i don't think his decision making or disposal are up to it. batram also has plenty of competition in his spot and i think Bennell and Cheney has over taken him in the preferance stakes All reports are Mvnamara is home sick, so send him home, either by a trade or delisting

your kidding....aren't you?? One of the most over rated players to pull on an AFL jumper Can't kick, can't read the play, can't impose his huge frame on a contest Happy to wait for Watts, Jurrah, Bate and co to create a potent forward line in a couple of years time

sean charles

would much rather try and get West a full time position on the coaching panel, and for mine it would be good bye Mahoney, but i believe he is a bit of a bailey favourite

where are you getting 8 spots on our list from?

they can't all play in the same team in defence together, we would just get exploited by opposition coaches who would go small on us. One is expendable, and Rivers would get us the best deal, and if things got desperate down there, we could throw Martin or Miller down there

No thanks, not the sort of player we need

very well put HT

jacks brother, a bit taller than jack so will be more suited to key position, currently playing at northern knights

i think there is more to this behind the scenes, would this ground be used for any other purpose? games that atrract smaller crowds for us, the roos, the doggies? or is it just a ground that will have a small stand for a gym and change rooms

oh right, i thought we were going into the new rectangle stadium? Who is pushing our move into this new stadium?

Not interested in a move. i love the mcg and nobody plays it better than us when we are up and going

Hands off. I think its time to offer Westy a full time roll and let him really get stuck into our midfield. get rid of mahoney if we have too

its just fact of where our list is at. when it comes our time to push hard for the elusive flag, will certain players be in contention for a spot in that team? to be realistic i think Rivers would be border line for that and so i think if we could get the right trade for him now we gain an extra high draft pick, but if no trade gets done so be it and Rivers continues to play at CHB for the MFC and is hopefully around for our flag

arrk yeah!!