Deesprate

Is this the same old Melbourne or have we improved. Cats are severely undermanned. It ours to win no excuses really.

Why did TMac handball that

Viney tackle superb

Dermie was quick to say it was an accident just prove it was deliberate. Selwood is without doubt my most hate opposition player. Yes Brayshaw was a little late but Selwood would do Laurence Olivier pround. Then he has the gall to whinge. Pathetic

Hawkins swinging elbow duty of care. Pathetic

At least we did not give up a goal at the death. Very un Melbourne like.

Cats are down on players but they play such a stodgy brand of footy. They make us look like Carl Lewis

Hawkins is to strong for Jackson. Loving Langdon game

Petracca is so strong. Just threw them aside like rag dolls

Absolute stager. Make everything look worse and never get called on it. Good part Frosty plays for Hawks

If Clarkson can rebuild Hawks he truly is a genius. Should have taken the big money and gone elsewhere. They are ordinary

Geez Geelong have been unimpressive.

Selwood is worse stager in AFL

Never thought I would say it. Smash them hawks! Cats could be vulnerable

Agree it not easy and he is doing his best. What other options are there. But he is a stop gap and in the last quarter was moving like a glacier. The point is against good team he will be a weak link. Winning three in a row allow supporters to drink their own bath water but we have only played three teams who have 2 wins out of 9 games. Shudder when thinking Barass and McGovern teaming TMac. Hopefully we bank our wins and have our A team when we play the big guns

Spot on assessment. Not sure Cats are real deal though. Particularly with no Danger. Reckon we have their measure except for TMac as a big forward.

Great position 3 - 0 real cause for optimism. If you keep winning you give yourself a chance. 2018 proves what possible when you get on a role. Cats are definitely beatable they are older and slower without our depth. I don’t think there a top four outfit. This is a massive statement game. Go Dees

Always good to win but we so need Brown or Weed back. TMac not suited by conditions but he just won’t cut it. Also Jetta big question marks

TMac butter

Why is Jetta in this team

Old Melbourne would win this by 6 - 12 points a ruthless side would be looking for percentage

Sorry but Jetta going to cost us in big games

GWS have no big forwards. We wil eat the long kicks

Unreal

We are playing well enough