Deesprate

You buy memberships, attend games, donate money. We have been terrible for 60 years yet we have guys like this carrying on. If it true there should be no second chances. Culture is a big issue at this club

If it confirmed dump him. Seriously has not learned lessons. There are definite leadership issues at this club

It a goal but why did weed handball that.

If he kick another four he forgiven

Smith on Danners does anyone see a problem

Bit early to write us off. We were the better team just poor execution

Oliver handball will cost a goal

Viney great effort people to tough on him.

Really liking Brown game

Ah mathematics you know your stuffed when your relying on that. Still haven’t got over 76 let hope it 87

Viney has been a great player losing captaincy was a kick in the guts. I think that has never sat well with him. To me losing him confirm a cultural problem at the club. Beyond football has given his all for the club.

Umpires what do u say

Your entitled to your views and have no issue with your other comments. Many thing are said in a pub I don’t think it necessarily equates to putting something in writing. But as I say rack to there own

Yes just look a player just such a contrast with so many of our other B graders. Rivers; Jackson are the only good thing that have come out of this year. Liked he was hurting at end of game showed he really cared.

“Some say”how Donald Trump. I am no fan of Goodwin but pretty unfair to say this without evidence.

Great post totally agree. The cycle can’t be broken just by sacking the coach. Hell look at the help Suns have had that the type of help needed to turn this around. Melbourne are there to make up the numbers it was only the intervention of the AFL and Roos/Jackson that lifted the place. There need to be something similar. Barassi set the Dees up in the early 80s for some sustained success we need something similar.

Yes last night was bad but it pale into insignificance compared to the view moving forward. This is just so incredibly damning and fill me with dread that we peaked in 2018 and we are on downward spiral. Can anyone provide me with evidence to the contrary. The football department and it recruiting has been a disaster since Roos left. Make the most of nearly making the eight as it is probably the best we can hope for in the next 3-5 years. Our Board and Chair have backed Goodwin and his merry men and can’t be accused of not being patient. There has to be serious change that at least give the supporter base hope and a feeling that where not just drifting aimlessly.

This thread is the saddest aspect about being a Melbourne supporter now. It the realisation that after seven years we have a broken B game list. How did we get this bad it inexplicable. The only thing worse than the list is the coaching panel a complete list of C graders. The broom need to be put through the coaching panel. A list review also need completing with a dont come Monday for as many players as e can off load.

Thank god for Rivers a great young player

Goodwin presser was a kick in the guts to members. Platitude after platitude. Dead man walking and he know it.

Goody Freo were better than us have to rely on other results - wtf we need to get more ruthless - sack himself where in it together good we have experience of nearly being in finals where not quite there - please we were boring but intensity ramped up after half time disappointing - understatement two game to go simple be better focus on what we can control prepare as best we can. Bingo where going to work incredibly hard Lyon cut him asunder about being ruthless. Stop talking DO Lyon no answers well done Gary

Rivers and Langdon positive

Totally agree multitude of issues including a list of players who are not AFL standard. Putting aside actual ladder position after a seven year rebuild we are only better than Crows and Kangas. Long suffering supporters deserve better.

Called out Preuss, Baker, ANB, Hunt, Bedford not up to AFL standard

Good on u Gary Lyon named names spot on