Dee Boys

Remember listening to an interview with Windsor last year where he was asked whether he was the quickest player at the club. "Nah Chin's got me covered comfortably".

You’d hope so!

That was directed at @bing181

I can't see a single example of anyone sniping at @Ghostwriter on this thread though. Sniping and discussing are two completely different things!

I'm staggered that anybody could possibly argue with this. @Ghostwriteryour insight is appreciated. But chats like this should of course be taken with a grain of salt. If he is thinking of leaving (not saying he is!) of course he's not going to tell supporters that!

Her bio on the MFC website says she's from Tasmania, but moved to South Australia post-school to pursue her footy. After playing locally she got drafted by Port Adelaide. She then only moved to Melbourne earlier this year when she got traded to us.

Cal Twomey said on a recent Gettable podcast that West Coast were coming hard for McVee with big $ being thrown around. You'd hope he stays loyal seeing as we picked him up in the rookie draft when there wasn't much interest from elsewhere, and the fact he's become good mates with a number of the other young players at the club. Plus he's from Geraldton, a 4 and a half drive from Perth.

McDonald has said a number of times in interviews that because of the state of his ankles, he no longer has the mobility required to play as a forward. Those days are over.

Can someone please tell me how you put someone on mute?

Every player in the competition can improve, it's a pretty vacuous observation. But expecting Clarry to become something he's not, and taking away from his strengths by trying to do so, is brainless.

I'm sorry, saying Oliver is an average decision maker is absolutely insane.

Of course it has everything to do with roles. For someone who constantly derides others for lacking football knowledge when they don't agree with you, you really do come out with some idiotic things. Oliver's main strength is a first possession player, where there have been few better in the modern era. He's managed to add an outside element and a burst away from stoppages to his game which has seen him win 4xBnF, 3xAA and 2xAFLCA awards by the age of 25. Because of the state of his shoulders, there's little point in him resting forward as he can't take a contested mark. He'd purely be a threat on the ground. Why would you take away from his strengths and magnify his weaknesses by playing him in a position he's not suited to? Petracca is obviously a completely different player, for reasons everyone knows and surely I don't need to get into. It absolutely stands to reason that he kicks a lot more goals than Clarry due to the difference in roles they play. Both have been equally important to our success.

Clarry or Viney?

Petracca will turn 30 before the 2026 season starts. The days of getting a huge bounty for him if he leaves are sadly over.

You're eligible to be drafted the year you turn 18.

Also enjoyed it. The stuff around the draft is about the most interesting stuff a club can put out I reckon. Loved after the 2019 draft when the club put out the behind the scenes video of conversations and deliberations the footy department had had before drafting Jackson, Pickett and Rivers, and also on the two draft nights, and wish they'd do it every year.

Langford and Tauru would be a dream result.

As much as I’d be thrilled with that, he clearly doesn’t know his stuff if that’s what he’s got happening!

Every expert has said we’re not keen on Draper, and Smith is likely to be gone.

By all reports FOS is the one out of all of them with the lowest floor but the highest ceiling. The same type of player as these two - could be Col Sylvia and have all the tools but never quite kick on…or could be Dangerfield. Not as foolproof as Smith or Draper who have much higher floors but if you back our development team in then there’s a hell of a lot to work with and he could end up being the best of the lot of them.

As much as Tauru has huge potential it's going to take a fair bit of time for him to realise it. Think I'd feel a bit flat if we ended up with him at 5 rather than the premium mid I'd been thinking we'd take. Getting him at 9 would be a different story, would be stoked with that.