Billy

Not sure about Salem, a few too many health & injury issues for over a year now & will have to earn his spot after another injury to be in the best 23

Tell that to Oliver, try’s guts out every minute of every game

Yep best Melbourne player all night long What’s he supposed to do!!!!!

Whoa let’s not get to carried away, it’s round 2 this week

Didn’t like it, could’ve killed the bloke poor effort from Kozzie Take the two weeks & move on

Yep l thought he was great again, just shows how high a level this bloke plays at week on week, was in the best 5 on the ground again

6 Gawn 5 Lever (next Captain) 4 Pickett 3 Petracca 2 Oliver 1 Rivers

Fritsch (if fit)for Laurie, he’s not up to it yet, couldn’t understand how he played in front of others Viney (if fit) for Kozzie (1-2 weeks) May (if fit) for Thommo unlucky Salem (if fit) or JJ for Hunter (I’m with you ANG13) not convinced with Hunter yet

Early days, but that’s not a premiership line up How does Laurie get a game before Jordan, looked totally overwhelmed in the praccy match Tomlinson looked way below senior standard, where’s Disco? Chandler doesn’t excite me at all & McVee before Hibbo Van Rooyen, still can’t get a game even when Fritsch is out & Ben Brown is still ahead of him? Selection blunders all round

Clarry The Ox The Wizard Tingay Neitz Jimmy

Would be nice if we could beat them for a change

Oliver, Petracca, Gawn & May should all be top 10 With Clarry#1

Who cares

Totally agree, some people need to toughen up, it’s a tough physical game, that’s what we love about it

Could imagine Charles with a flogger😂

Depends on if he wants to play senior footy l suppose There will have to be a lot of injured players in the back six on that performance

I really like James Jordon, do we all think, Hunter is a better player? l don’t

12-14 too many if he plays like last season

C’mon people he’s one of the best we’ve had, but that man bun is a stinker

Worth every cent, but l worry about his current man bun situation 😉

I like the guy, he seems like a good bloke Really hope he embarrass the CFC

Thought he was bloody good this year and can’t understand why posters are so quick to write him off and think that Hunter is the answer for 2023 Hope he keeps Hunter out out of the side, I’ve always thought he was a head ducking receiver at the Buldogs

Are you dropping Hibberd on his very good 2nd half of 2022 season or is it based on his age? Do you understand ANBs role Turner holding down CHB after 2 quarters played in 2022? Not having a crack, just interested in your thoughts with these 3 players

Because they’re both not good enough & Smith will unfortunately probably get injured again

Essendon & StKilda should merge