Billy

He was Okay, not great just okay

Put his head over the ball, 20 possessions, 6 tackles 8 contested possessions & as l said played his role as an inside mid Disposal efficiency was average at 60% As l said he played ok

The two scapegoats every week Thought JJ was good & Harmesy was ok. The amount of criticism for these two is unbelievable Harmes is a great clubman & used to be a fan favourite, how things have changed

That’s a blow, anyone who thinks that Brown, McDonald or Smith can replace him need to take their rose coloured glasses off

It’s a great day for football, surely there must be the flu running though the Pies camp, that’s what the media comes up with after they lose. l think we’re now favourites 😉

Fair enough selections, Tomlinson was very poor last weekend & Woey will be good but not up to it yet. Harmes was good & would’ve been in the best players had he converted & kicked two goals JJ is doing his job while Clarry is out

God l hope they don’t read this, we could get stereotyped 😉

Have l opened the wrong thread???

Jordon was a bit quiet last week but has been good at playing specific roles since Clarry has been out. There’s more to footy than stats alone

In Hibberd Clarry & Sparrow out Tomlinson Woey & Harmes

I feel a bit for Grundy, but he did choose us, he could’ve gone to a least half a dozen clubs. To he’s credit he hasn’t complained yet, he needs to knuckle down now & get his spot back. Would be pretty poor to give up after one season

Seriously???

How BAD Is Tomlinson, he’s a shocker

That’s really poor by Harmes, has put himself into a good position & to miss from directly in front twice is not good enough, every possie he’s had has been a turnover Give Dunstan a go we’ve seen enough

The conditions again were against us, when the lights are on at 11.30am with a heavy cloud cover it’s always going to swing Aussies we’re a bit negative with the bat but overall a good effort to get a lead It wasn’t INSIPID at all, are you always such an angry man?

Yep he like Ben Brown

Agree If he can’t run out a full game he doesn’t deserve a game in a team that’s in the premiership race

So you’ve been happy with Browns output since he has come back in? Seriously???

We’ll said, one poster thinks we’re beat up & Viney needs a rest then every one jumps on board & now we’re buggered Get over yourselves & give the team & coaches a bit of credit

6. Viney 5. Kozzie 4. Gus 3. Gawn 2. Chandler 1. Lever

Agree he’s almost playing as a decoy, but he just doesn’t look fit enough anymore

Surely Brown has to go, unfortunately he’s just not getting it done anymore Woey not quite ready yet Petty if fit to go forward, if not Smith for a full game Hibbo in for his bunny Dusty

I agree with the JJ - JMac comparison Given time l really think he can be very good 200 game player Jmac was given that time hope JJ does too

Source, is pretty disappointed with not getting much of a chance at the top level. In my opinion l don’t think he’s up to it anyway

No Bailey Laurie won’t be at the MFC next year so no chance he plays