bjgc

B: Whelan Warnock Garland HB: Wheatley Martin C.Johnson C: Bruce Dunn McDonald HF: Bate Miller Green F: Davey P.Johnson Wonaeamirri Foll: White McLean Jones I/C: Buckley Morton Valenti Jamar Em: Bartram Sylvia Frawley In : Buckley Martin Morton Valenti Out: Bode (useless) Bartram (may keep his spot but Buckley has been doing some good stopping jobs lately) Sylvia (continues to do nothing we are better off playing a strong midfielder in Valenti) Frawley (we need a stronger body like Martin).

1 MCLEAN 2 GREEN 3 WHEATLEY 4 BRUCE 5 DAVEY I have to give credit to Wheatley. I have always thought he was a front runner but he has really put in this year and is having a good year.

I would only pick him up in the PSD and that is only if Warnock(1st choice) or Hansen(2nd choice) are not available. His work ethic will be a benefit for our young midfielders but his age and lack of football work against him.

Another CAC beauty. Enjoy this year Richmond it's all down hill from here on. Even when he plays with Spencer he is the second string ruckman the man is a joke he should be playing with Weetra. The only thing that will save Meeson is his contract, on form he should be sacked.

I didn't think pick 30 was too much of a stretch for Bell. The chances of picking up a star at 30 is remote we picked up Bell at 14. Remember everyone was in love with Bell last year now no one is. He's had a bad year which can happen to anyone. At 23 I think he's worth more than what you think.

I think you could get a pick around 30 for him he had a good year last year if he had a good year this year we wouldn't be looking at getting rid of him.

I'm not worried about the salary cap, I'm worried about our list management. I don't think we have the money to waste by paying him out and he has done nothing to suggest that he will ever improve. The only difference between Meeson and Jamar is that Jamar has been around forever while it's Meeson's first year at the club if Meeson keeps on playing like this he will be the first one to get sacked at the end of next year if they can do it earlier I won't be shedding a tear.

I think Frawley will be the other one dropped Bailey praised Morton and C.J so I can't see them going out. Whelan and Valenti in.

Is Dal Santo contracted?

Id be surprised if we didn't get Robbie Warnock with this pick. He has the chance to go home, play with his brother and become the no1 ruckman at the club all things he will never be able to do at Freo.

McNamara's busy

I don't think so. He's a long way off from playing AFL football. If we recruit 2 key forwards I don't see why we would need him. We already have Spencer as a long term prospect we don't need another I would prefer us to go for more runners.

What happended to 2009? I think we can only go year by year we have had the same problems for a while with pace and key position players. Who gave Jamar 2 years? the clown should be shot. Jamar must be traded for pick 100 and a set of steak knife's if need be. He can not be on the list next year we will have Naita, Warnock, White, P.J, Messon, Jamar and Spencer. That is disgraceful list management we will have more ruckman than midfielders on the list. Trade Bell to Adelaide for about pick 30 he's just another Chisholm no awareness and produces basic turnovers that cost plenty of goals. Adelaide picked up Symes for about the same pick I don't think he is any worse than him. Tell Sylvia to shape up or ship out he is far too lazy we can't wait 4ever 4 him to turn it on. Trade pick 17 for Prismall (hoping by the end of the year he will dropped again, surely Geelong have enough midfielders give us some please PS: Not Tenace) We will then have 4 picks in in the top 40 (or 5 if we can't get Prismall) hopefully Naita, a running utility and 2 key forwards. Pass on our last pick to get Warnock in the PSD and promote Aussie and Valenti. Use the rookie draft to get some running utilties. Holland, Neitz, Yze(retired) Bell and Jamar(traded) C.J, Weetra and Carroll sacked along with rookie Zomer. Bode and Meeson lucky to survive the cut (next year's list cloggers like Weetra and C.J were this year). If Whelan gets injured again this year it could be the end of him. Rivers is a big worry. White and McDonald 1 more year. '09 TEAM B: WHELAN, M.WARNOCK, GARLAND HB: WHEATLEY, RIVERS, BRUCE C: DAVEY, MCLEAN, MOLONEY HF: BATE, MILLER, GREEN F: NAITANUI, ROBERTSON, WONAEAMIRRI FOLL: R.WARNOCK, PRISMALL, JONES IC: BARTRAM, MORTON, MCDONALD, WHITE REPLACEMENTS B: MCNAMARA, FRAWLEY, CHENEY HB: BUCKLEY, MARTIN, BODE C: SYLVIA, VALENTI, DRAFT PICK HF: MARIC, DRAFT PICK, PETTERD F: MEESON, NEWTON, DRAFT PICK FOLL: P.JOHNSON, DUNN, GRIMES IC: ROOKIE, ROOKIE, ROOKIE, SPENCER

In the paper I think they wrote that Warnock is almost a certainty to join his brother next year. We will then have a ruck division of White, Naitanui and Warnock with P.J and Meeson as backups (Jamar has to be gone). Can we sack Meeson? He will clearly be a list clogger next year he had his chance early this year and stuffed it with continual bad form. Cousins has dodgy hamstrings and has missed are year of footy and at 30 so I doubt we will go for a quick fix in Cousins. I'd prefer to give pick 17 or 18 for Prismall.

B: WHELAN, WARNOCK, MCDONALD HB: BARTRAM, GARLAND, WHEATLEY C: DAVEY, MCLEAN, DUNN HF: BATE, MILLER, GREEN F: P.JOHNSON, SYLVIA, WONAEAMIRRI FOLL: WHITE, BRUCE, JONES IC: C.JOHNSON, BODE, FRAWLEY, YZE EMERG: MORTON, JAMAR, BELL Matchups Dunn V Goodes Bartram\McDonald v Kirk Warnock V O'Loughlin Garland V Hall

For the second time this year he has surprised me he actually looked like he wanted to kick goals on Sunday when it's usually the last thing he wants to do. If he keeps that up I may have to change my about him.

I can't believe the improvement in this kid by rnd 2 I thought he would spend the rest of the year with Weetra in Sandy's 2's now he's playing like a gun. He's quick can play forward or back and is a good mark is a real find.

I would play Morton at Sandy. His skill level has been disgraceful I thought that was what we got him for cause he was skilled. He was clearly worst on ground and I thought he cost us the game I can't believe he was named in the best in the paper. I'd prefer to see Whelan in the team but Morotn will bounce back he's a quality kid but needs to get back some confidence.

I thought the whole team was very ordinary. I was amazed when Valenti leveled the score in the last quarter. I don't think any player deserves a recall after that effort. Great to see Newton and Petterd back. Carroll worst on ground give it away please.

I can't believe that we have that high a number with the problems we face. The ex members should be ashamed of themselves there is no excuse not to be a member.

WHAT DOES HE SEE IN FRAWLEY?

B: WHELAN, WARNOCK, BELL HB: BARTRAM, GARLAND, WHEATLEY C: DAVEY, MCLEAN, BRUCE HF: BATE, MILLER, GREEN F: SYLVIA, HOLLAND, WONEAMERI FOLL: WHITE, JONES, MCDONALD IC: YZE, MORTON, DUNN, P.JOHNSON EMERG: C.JOHNSON, BODE, MARTIN I don't want to see Carroll or Frawley they are hopeless. Martin to CHB and Garland to FF if Holland is not fit.

I don't agree 1 bit Garland has been one out of the box but he also mentioned Weetra who is a joke, so I think it's more luck than anything that he has improved so quickly(like Rivers in '04). Warnock has been given a chance due to the woeful form of Carroll and has taken it so it was more about opportunity than anything. Aussie (Davey in '04) Morton has been OK nothing to rave on about though. I wonder if Bruce kicked the way Morton kicked on the weekend what you would say about him. Moloney and Sylvia were never fully fit under Daniher. I still don't rate them Moloney still can't hit a target and Sylvia had the chance to turn the game and didn't with poor kicking not the only one mind you (Green and Yze come to mind) but until he can win us some games he will continue to be a disappointment. I still think he will be better off at half back.

I think Jamar is stiff not to be in even though I don't rate him I think he has been rucking better than P.J. If Bailey's is picking on form C.J should have got a game in front of Yze, Dunn and Bode. Whelan should never be left out of the team for this long he is just too good. In the Age they wrote that Carroll was awesome on that dud Egan. Gavin Brown said that we just couldn't stop him. I don't want to see Carroll in the seniors but I thought you should know that the Age wrote exactly the opposite. I would say that Holland is still injured but I hope that he does play.

I think I said last year we should go for Prismall. We desperately need another ball winner. I would go for Rooke also, our forwards have been [censored] weak a hard nut like Rooke could only help that. I'm not sold on Warnock I'd prefer Seaby. We will have White and Naita next year who generally aren't strong and Warnock is the same I think we need some variety in the ruck someone stronger. I'd have a look at Hansen too.