45HG

Agreed. Would you go for a Robbie Campbell?

It is also unrealistic to use Jamar as the only example of a ruck coming on and to use his progress as the benchmark for all others. I don't think it's unrealistic to say a player of any type should be in and around the 22 5 years after he's drafted.

He is the only player in the top 17, aside from Hayes, to not have made the All-Australian side. There was almost universal uproar when Hayes missed. Hardly the case with Thomas, who didn't even make the squad of 40. He's been very good this year, but not top 10 - no way. Pavlich at 23...behind Rawlings. Pull the other one.

Mike's top 50 for the year. Thomas number 9? Honestly? Riewoldt 10? Kelly/Didak top 20... Interesting. Not an easy job to do, though.

Ah, thanks mate.

I'm confused. Didn't trade week finish yesterday at 2 p.m.?

For anyone who feels, as I do, see my sig and feel free to do the same.

Yeah...because Dawes is such an underwhelming prospect...

Disagree...He causes much more frustration!

Maybe they should put it on ESPN 8 - The Ocho!

No...

Today I've seen that we should get rid of Bate and get Brennan. Did I miss any others?

Great match, epic finish!

Adelaide 1996 winning in '97 comes to mind.

Sorry, but I don't see the Dogs making the granny next year...

Surely... SURELY, Marcus North will be dropped now. Averaging 29 in his last 13 matches.

Would that phone call be coming from Mr. Scott? Disagree. That list basically has us coming 10th next year, which seems about right/a bit low. 26-1 are still very long odds.

Just like his brother Anthony.

Mmm, it may be true - but if it was me making the call I'd have told him to sit down and rest up. I said as much when I was watching the coverage at the time.

I'm still grumpy that we left him on when it already looked dodgy and the match was shot, but anyway.

My other favourite on the forum (and i've been guilty of this on occassion) is the sweeping generalization that isn't backed up with a shred of evidence.

Oh the horror! On Roughy though, if I was the Hawks I'd either try and fix their forward set up or get Roughy to play back when Franklin is in the team. He is just lost/ignored when Buddy is in.

I put 50 into an account almost two years and about 700 bets ago. At the moment I'm about a dollar down, it's certainly paid for itself in terms of entertainment.

Because it was Newton in '07