GCDee

wow our medical/high performance team truly are a joke.... Watch Melk come out of the game on the weekend with "awareness" in the foot and it ends up being a further fracture and career ending.

Agreed, P2 should have nothing to do will Hill. Freo paid P26 for Hill 2 years ago, his value will have only gone down or stayed the same given he is now older. P20 sounds pretty fair to me for Hill...

God I hope we are tanking, and not just this bad.

Well pick 2 is locked up now

FWIW I think they will get one, just an end of first round pick.

Making an informed & educated evaluation of how this year has panned out I think you can come to the conclusion that this year has been a big bleep in our development. We have been slowly but surely building a winning culture at the club with continued growth for 5+ years. I simply don't buy into this is who were are and where we belong given we really have been pushing for finals for the last 2-3 years with a VERY young list. Having a record amount of off season surgeries is not an ideal way to start pre season. Only being able to get 12 players on the park for a session at the start of the year should also be cause for concern and indicates how underdone or players were. Also being a young team we very much rely on confidence to get us through games, our confidence was absolutely shot by round 3 this year and there probably wasn't much hope in turning it around from there, especially with the injuries we were facing, just go back and look at how our backline lined up in the first few rounds. I think the media really has given us a bit of a mulligan this year, given its clear our list is talented and even though our season is shot we have not dropped our heads and are getting ourselves into winning positions weekly. However, 2020 there can be absolutely no excuses. We will be starting our pre season early, our list is beginning to look healthy again. We will also be "blessed" with a top 5 pick that we would not have been planning for or expecting. This pick will get more elite talent through the doors or could be traded for more ready made players to help us make a push back to September next year. As a previous poster mentioned, if we start next year 0-2 the pressure and media slagging will come down on the club and Goodwin like a brick [censored] house.

For those who were keen on Sam Day he has re-sign with the GC today....

In the back? Of course not

Wow... That might be the worst decision of the year.

Hibberd dragged off the contest... Also "not seen"

How's that shove from Kennedy of course... "Not seen"

Still didn't take the shot haha. We are so [censored].

Lol any one see ANB fall over nothing there? What a [censored] joke

WOWOWOOWOWOWOW WE GOT A FREE

0-9 hahahahhaa Where's the throw on redden? PRUESS let go knowing the fat [censored] big Mac McGovern would have just dropped in anyway and it would have been a free against

Free kick count 0-7.... I wonder if they will crack double digits before we get one.

I thought that was hilarious... Clearly the ump forgot who Gil wanted to win for a split second and actually was umpiring that contest on its merit. What umpire changes their mind like that during a decision... And just says oh sorry. I really don't think I'll be watching the AFL within the next year or two with what Gil and Hocking are doing to the game. And this is coming from a guy who was so AFL obsessed I got my first job so I could pay for Foxtel out of my own money because my parents wouldn't pay for it so I could watch each and every game week on week out, all whilst my team were lucky to win 3 games a year. I used to be so passionate about this game, now it just looks and feels corrupt, I feel sorry for the kids who have to grow up watching this mess.

I thought Maxys free against was the worst free kick of the year... But that one against Thompson really takes the cake. Yet another green maggot ruining a great game of footy by being completely incapeable of doing their job. Go get [censored] AFL you're a joke of a league

I highly doubt Goodwin is the next coach to get sacked.... Hinckley for one has had his list under performing for 4+ years

Imagine a GF being decided by that free kick? These are the exact reasons why umpires need to be given suspensions. He clearly does not know or understand the rules , he is not fit to complete his job correctly. There is no excuses with frees like that, he was 3 metres from the ball with no obstructions in his view.

I keep on saying it... Umpiring in the AFL is actually laughable. They are pathetic [censored] weak no hopers who couldn't get a kick when they were a kid and take out their pent up frustrations on the guys that could....

Plugger petty?

It's funny how we as supporters can have completely polar opposite opinions. IMO he is working really hard, competes in the air and on the ground. Just lacking a bit of strength and polish

I'm no doctor but the vision looks similar to Lever ACL last year.

If tmac has done his ACL we can continue this awesome form into 2020