dazzledavey36

Can we be the first team ever to sack a coach at half time. Take your [censored] game plan and [censored] off Goodwin

Unfortunately this is 100% correct. We have no pulling power or stand for anything. Until we get this right, we will continue to recruit VFL standard players such as Sharp, Campbell, Billings and Fullarton.

You have a minority of supporters who are as delusional as the coach. Head in sand stuff.

Harry Sharp is on par with Tom Gillies as one of te worst melbourne player i have ever seen and yet he stays in. Melksham is officially cooked has barely had an impact and he stays in. Fritta has been absolutely horrific and has been called out by ex footy greats for his selfish attitude but yet he stays. Goodwin is the most stubborn coach going around. He is delusional in his method and inability to clear out the mediocrity that has creeper in by the same players..they have been left to get away with the same [censored] every week. No wonder Petracca has had a gut full.

Goodwin is an absolute joke. Sooner he goes the better for us moving forward. Rewarding mediocrity performance week after week just proves so how incompetent he is now. Should have taken a leaf out of McQualter's book and made a statement, but no. Its the same [censored] different year.

Think we can all assume that's the case unfortunately.

Surely not already..

Why would Sam Draper, who like Grundy only wants to be the number 1 ruckman, come to a club to then play as a back up.. Our club is nothing but a negative stain on future ruck prospects who want to either play as back up or establish themselves at the club. The club have shown zero capacity in making two rucks work in the same team. We've just signed Gawn to another 3 year deal and whilst he's the top dog, forget about any opposition ruckman coming to the club as back. Draper would laugh at us.

Do you have evidence and data to back that up?? Curious if have to back up this claim?

https://x.com/FootyonNine/status/1909200718629687586

https://x.com/FootyonNine/status/1909200718629687586

Didn't know where to put this but absolutely love this from Jimmy Bartel. https://x.com/FootyonNine/status/1909202178117370251

Ha.. i was only pulling your leg my friend. Agree though, can never doubt his passion!

He's right here @picket fence

Hate to say it but we really going into Mark Neeld territory with some of these numbers that are starting to appear..

Gawn has been brainwashed.

https://www.3aw.com.au/is-it-time-matthew-lloyd-damning-comments-on-simon-goodwin-after-another-dees-loss/?fbclid=IwY2xjawJdOQtleHRuA2FlbQIxMQABHrGREZ9PAVmAGZNEOOkShFWbfiNouhRlKkc9TjYINJ59YED98_QB71iDk1-M_aem_Fdb3_P4EQwRqCA76L1qiPw

Billings character and standards is of high level. Nick Reiwoldt said this last year in one of our early coverage and i take his absolute word especially coming from someone whos known to be manic and elite with his preparation a driving standards. Billings issue is his consistency and development that has been his biggest downfall and I put that down to the [censored] poor development at St Kilda. That has absolutely nothing to do with standards and culture at the Dees. Ben Kennedy was a bad influence to the group due to his off field activities. You can figure that out yourself.. I have had this confirm to me previously by an ex Melbourne player. He was a bad influence on the likes of Harmes and Hogan. McKenna and Ben Newton fall into the same bracket as Harry Sharp. Genuine list cloggers that add no value to the team when called upon.

Correct.. So what do we do in the meantime when he was showing this last year? Offer him a [censored] 4 year deal. Gut the joint starting with Lamb, Goodwin and Griffiths.

Outs: Sharp - good lord never again. If Goodwin is fair dinkum, he never puts on a Melbourne jumper again.. ever. Spargo - What on earth are we doing here...any other club would let him rot in the VFL except us. This is one of the more bizarre team selections going around in my time supporting the dees with how much they rate Spargo over the past few weeks. Petty - Yo Adelaide.. can we do that trade?? Ins: Lever and two suburban footballers that will have a genuine crack.

Him and Bowey were BOG for me.