dazzledavey36

Fantasia, Langford, Merrett and Kommer were all National Draft picks.

Agree with you 100%..

Personally i think he is gone. Whether its this year or 2017 either way i just think his heart is set back at being home. Whats interesting is that if he does go it would want to be one hell of a compensation trade!

Yeah im still shaking my head why we kept Terlich on after he didn't even remotely get close to a senior selection. Signing him to a 2 year deal was just as horrific.

Don't bother mate. According to that nuffy its Pedo's fault that Hogan had a shitfull day because 'he got in his way'... While trying to point out that there were many worse examples why Hogan had a bad day at the office.

You are [censored] clueless as usual. Missed the point completely what i was trying to make out to you simpleton. Seriously ENYAW makes more sense then you and thats saying something. bye

So when Pedersen went into the ruck and Gawn went to the bench where was our forward structure? nothing changed there.. at all. I pointed out to your that Pedersen was playing up field and the forward 50 was much more open. It was a clear message from last week. Pedo did what was asked and yet you still find something to sook about just because you dont like him. You tried to pump up Frost on here to everyone saying he was a better option and that backfired on you. Fact is we simply don't have anyone else better to play that 2nd forward role. Frost is clueless up forward. We recruited him as a backman so play him down there, again coaches have simply got this one wrong. Dawes is injured... Now the difference with Garland argument to yours is every single game Garland makes basic fundamental mistakes every single week. It costs us goals and for someone who is suppose to be a leader he drops his head and goes into his shell. He has not improved for the last 3 years at all. How are players ment to look to their leaders like McDonald and Garland to lead when they are the ones making simple errors that turn into goals. Garland is a liability to our side plain and simple. I wish Roosy would bite the bullet and drop him and give Frost a go down back. He'll actually give us some run and dash out of defence and is much stronger one on one then Garland.

I sorta wonderd that myself. There are reports that Hogan comes back in poor condition while Cripps puts on 6kg of muscle and comes back in ripping shape and you can now see the benefits as he has had a great start to the year while Hohan has been poor.

If we win il just shake my head. But we won't so il still shake my head.

Of course you are allowed to give your opinion. But at least get it right first you hack. If you actually take the time and watched the game properly the message was quite clear from last week that the forward line had to be be much more open. Pederson started at CHF and played more further upfield. Not once did Pedersen get in his way at all. The problem was the constant bombing it in to Hogan where Essendon had crowded quickly, Hogan not leading properly, and poor delivery into our forward fifty. Those were just some of the examples of why Hogan had a bad day. If your going to try and call a player out at least have a valid argument to back it up like i do with Garland and McDonald.

Give it a rest mate.

In all fairness Jnrmac im in your boat in that i don't rate Garland at all and personally i think he should be dropped as he offers nothing, but if Bugg made that handball to Garland he would have gotten caught and it would have been a poor decision. We have to take into account the speed and intensity of the game instead of judging from a photo. Daniher is literally only about 2m away from him.

What on earth does McCarthy walking out on GWS got to do with Jesse Hogan's poor body language?! And then to say that perhaps Hogans deliberately cracking the sads so just so that he can get dropped and go home?? By far the most bizzare thing i have read in a while. Your usually better then this ADC?

I think his name was Skills32 and he changed to Tigerdayz or something along those lines?

I don't mind supporters who want to take a bit of time off from following AFL. Il take that. Unlike the [censored] who posted on here couple of years ago saying he was changing teams to Richmond and had the guts to say they will have a more successful era then us.

Why does Dom Tyson have to get in a rubbish bin? Have i missed something..

No

Your a sad individual.

How would the players know if it was a done deal? Management deals in regards to contracts are kept in confidentiality. Players around the club wouldn't have a clue what Jesse and his management would discuss in regards to his contract status.

Actually i dont know if you noticed but Jones started in the backline yesterday while Oliver started on ball in the opening bounce along with Vince and Viney who seemed to be given a tagging role on Goddard.

It is a fair point you put up.. I guess i am only looking at it from an attacking point of view. I really do feel for Grimes. I still feel there is a spot somewhere because as you said he is one of our fittest and goes in hard. Defensive forward maybe? Couldn't have been any worse then Dean Kent and James Harmes who just let their opponents stroll right past them.

Jack Viney was just interviewd on Sunday footy show with Mitch Cleary and he just mentioned that maybe some players did go into the game thinking it will be a stroll in the park....

If the FD have faith in Garland then maybe its worth questioning it? because i am yet to see what he adds to this side. Leadership?? kidding yourself.. For example i dont mind Lumumba and thought his game was good for someone who has had no pre season. At least with him you know what your going to get. He is the only one that tries to take the game on and get it moving at all times.

Of course Dunn still has a big role to play. I still stand by that. But agaaaain when McDonald just keeps it simple and just limit those errors i find he is much more focused and is right up their as one of the best defenders of the game. Prime example is the Gws game early last year and late against Jeremy Cameron. His problem is his ego gets the better of him and he tries to bite off more then he can chew. Id also like a please explain why he didn't pay enough respect to Daniher and instead guys like Garland Mjones and even Bugg had to man him while he was too busy guarding space in the defensive 50.