dazzledavey36

Yep. Think he has a right time to actually glance first to see who was ahead of him..

Sydney absolutely killing their chances. Playing heaps better footy!

Oh so you weren't there to hear it at all but yet I've gotta "take your word" for it because someone else told you? I'm sold.

Didn't he pass a concussion test?

C'mon mate, you really suggesting that this actually should be looked at? Look at it from a vision point of view and not just a picture. This high tackles happen 10 times every single game. If Chol got weeks for this then shut the whole joint up for good because the game would be cooked. Just remember one got stretched off on a stretcher and one got caught a high tackle and played out the game with absolutely zero issues.

Great perspective. This is why last night's win was significant.

No BDA said Brodie felt totally disrespected, I'm asking him/her where's he's publicly stated this or got this quote from? Yeah look I'd maybe get it if he said this to a few of his teammates and family members behind closed doors but I'd be very surprised if he's been this open to a couple of random demon army supporters that he has no personal connection with? He's an incredible deep thinker and sensitive man but I'd still be surprised of he was still so open about this to any Joe Blow in the street especially as it would be a sensitive topic still. Anyway, he looks happy and he's adding a fair bit to our team and of the criticism on here post game has been unwarranted.

I'm sorry, can you provide a quote where he states he felt 'totally disrespected?'

Collingwood aren't the first and last club to do this kind of management. We did the exact same thing with Woewodin. They acknowledged that they stuffed up their list management by offering years on ridiculous money. They've now fixed that up and are benefiting in a huge way As I said, footy is a business now. A players heart and emotional attachment to a club is now 2nd. Even Grundy has acknowledged that footy is such a ruthless business and he's now accepted that Unfortunately that's just the way the industry is going.

Disgraceful is a bit of a stretch.. AFL is business now and they made a decision they thought would benefit their list. Getting rid of Grundy enables them to get in Hill, Mitchell, Frampton and McStay. Smart list management if you ask me because they've all contributed greatly so far this year. Think they're regretting the decision? Absolutely not, they'll be laughing. They've had a make shift ruckman in Billy Frampton for the past few weeks and yet are still churning out wins. They're in a great spot list management wise after a couple of years of getting it wrong.

My thoughts on the game. The ones complaining about how poorly we played are the same ones who said this would be an easy win in the pre game thread. You can never please them and should be ashamed to think that this would be a walk in the park. Supporters are still not getting it that you still need to respect every team you play regardless of how poor they are. GC are a good team that's being poorly coached imo. If Damien Hardwick ends up there they'll easily play finals. The QLD trip is nearly overcoming WA as one of the hardest trips on the road purely because of the climate and the fact that you're lucky to play there once every 2 years. It's still completely foreign. The game was sloppy but it was such a grinding win. Had we played this game in thr 2nd half of last year then GC simply overrun us. So just shows we're mentally improved from our 2nd half fade outs. I still hold some huge concerns with our forward line. It's a bit of a mess. That has to be Petty's last game as a forward. Either get Ben Brown in and tell him that it's time to compete and get on his bike otherwise against Collingwood and Geelong we'll be exposed big time. Now is the time to get that forward structure settled especially coming up against the likes of Hawthorn and Freo. Great win, and hopefully the lads recover well.

Or he could just simply be having an off night in general?? Sometimes things simply don't go your way on game day, this happens. Everyone is allowed to have a off day here and there without conclusions being jumped, especially mental health being brought into it.

Experiment over.

Its functioning well because we've played poor teams with a poor defence. Come up against Geelong and Collingwood and we'll get smoked. Petty is an absolute liability up forward and is robbing our defence with his ability to lock down and free Lever and May up. I threw up Brown more from a tactical point of view to free up JVR in getting best and bigger defenders which he's copped the past few weeks. Other then that we're completely bereft of other forward options.

Don't think Ben Brown is the answer to our forward line issues. He's past his best. What he does do well is draw an extra defender or two in the AFL. I believe this would relieve much needed pressure on JVR who at times had Collin and Ballard on him. Tough ask for a kid. Petty doesn't attract the better defenders like Brown does, and that's why the forward experiment needs to stop immediately. I think Brown comes in next week and I'd just leave him there for now to build momentum and form.

You know when D Spencer is hitting the bottle because of his inability to to control himself by making some ridiculous and outlandish comments. Wanting Fritsch who's our current leading goal kicker dropped but keeping Petty forward and bringing in Joel Smith... absolute FMD. You couldn't make this [censored] up.

To the ones who watches can I get a summary on how Woewodin, Howes and Jed Adams

Absolutely no way is he's still number 1 lol By your reckoning Sam De Koning should be number 1 because he's a premiership player and has higher ceiling? Played CHB for a premiership team which is just as hard as playing ruck. He's absolutely no way ahead of Kozzie Pickett as a starting point.

I'm not sure what you're talking about with the QLD stuff mate??

Think we'll start to see Judd McVee tire out as the season goes on. Been playing senior footy since the practise games and have noticed probably the last 2 weeks that he's just slightly off his composure and timing. Salem should at least have 2 weeks maybe 3 max at Casey then by then should be good timing for McVee to have a spell.

Hope they absolutely crumble to the lower depths like West Coast have.

If Spargo is coming back through the twos then bloody hell that's one impressive Casey team we'll have this week!

??