Duh

What games do you have him polling votes and how many? I could only find around 7-9

Gawn Vince Jones Dunn Garlett Tyson

Devastating, in particular for Jayden hunt who has never had a chance to have a good crack and may be getting delisted at the end of the season

Vince and jones are about par this season, T-Mac thereabouts as well. Id like to think that by the end of the year and into next year Tyson is back to his best and along with Viney these two should be challenging for the title as our clubs best/most important players. Watch for Salem's game to grow to a new level next season

The best match day experience is a win,

I guess he can provide good run from the back half but sometimes it seems to me that he's playing for himself not the team. Maybe dropping him's a bit harsh but hes got to improve in many areas of his game

Yeah we lost but no need for overreacting. As long as our young core of players; brayshaw, viney, salem, hogan, Tmac, Tyson, kent, jkh, stretch, ANB, toumpas, petracca etc stick together the pain we have faced over the last 10 years may just be worth it. Anyway can still see us winning 6-8 games this year, surely thats acceptable for a team who 2 years ago were playing some of the worst football ever played by an AFL club.

Never going to happen (in terms of lumumba) but Out: lumumba, howe, pedersen (apparently injured) In: Harmes, Fitz, Dawes

jones toumpas vince viney cross Hogan

Apparently Alex also had a Navicular fracture in his foot when he was around 16-17 so hopefully Trengove can overcome a similar sort of injury to the one Alex had.

is there any chance of the club actually trading Dawes though?

Or we could praise both of them; one for completing a marvellous achievement of 150 AFL games, and one for fulfilling a life long dream of playing AFL

At the half Jones 21, Bail 20 and Harmes 19 most disposals

ANB said that himself..

What is the possible scope or timeline for O-Mac's improvement? I'm not doubting his ability in any way or writing him off, just wondering how the club is expecting him to develop. ie. seniors next year and whether or not he could potentially be as good as his brother as well? It'll be exciting when O-Mac and T-Mac are lining up for us!

Gawn is thoroughly underrated and his tap work is quite good and will continue to improve if we keep giving him an opportunity. His height (208cm) is obviously a great asset, and he will need to improve his finishing in terms of marking/goal kicking to become the player he could be. Quite often he gets himself into position to mark the ball only to drop it, which is similar in terms of his goal kicking where he can often miss easy set shots. Definitely worth persevering with as he is the most promising out of spencer and Jamar.

Brayshaw and hogan have been great so far, but id have to say cripps would be the front runner

Id think we have a better/deeper midfield than the saints

Was really impressed with toumpas today, what a lot of people don't realise is in addition to gathering 20 odd touches he also tagged steele Sidebottom and did a bloody good job of it! I know he made some silly mistakes, like most players today, but his overall performance was quite good. Seems to be improving each week...

Reminds me of a young sam mitchell

Fitzy was quite poor today so he goes after the performaces he's had the last two weeks. Matt Jones out as well Bring back tyson, who should have played today, and grimes. One of ANB or Stretch to be included for vanders if he doesnt play

6 jones 5 vince 4 brayshaw 3 viney 2 cross 1 watts

Yes great idea. As a club with very few leaders I think it would be a fantastic idea to delist the few we have. Like James McDonald, that ended well. Our leaders aren't always the ones to stand up but they have been great servants of the club throughout the years and deserve a bit more respect than you are currently giving them (Dawes, cross and Lumumba are all recent additions to the club but you'd have to say they've given their all especially cross),

6 Garland 5 Brayshaw 4 Hogan 3 Grimes 2 Spencer 1 Pedersen -10 Jeremy Howe

6 vandenBerg 5 vince 4 hogan 3 jones 2 pedersen 1 spencer