Jibroni

Surely Luke Darcy you would not go on National TV and declare he is gone without a solid source.

Yes I would be shock if the players/coaching staff did not know his intentions for 2019 and beyond.

Surprised Cats would not be showing interest.

Melksham, Pederson, Hibberd and even Frost have worked out pretty well? I understand your point but perhaps look at each individual in isolation and not the collective.

Concerned about his concussion issues, but can play. Would be similar value to Kent I would have thought?

Didn't know that.

Im predicting tomorrow that Hogan will announce that he is staying and this thread will get to 100 pages.

Yes, he has skills, strong but can be bit of a hot head. I would not be giving up a top 10 pick without May + something in return.

The more this pans out the more I want Jesse to stay (at the right price!).

I think Kent is worth a pick between 30 and 40 which the Saints don't have. Might have to form part of the Pruess trade; hence a three way deal. Sad to see him go.

That's a long straw to bow isn't it?

And you will have to find a new profile pic as well DL? Im still 50/50 on trading him.

Like his attitude but realistically if Hunt can have a big preseason there will be at least 2 blokes capable of playing his position. Depth player for me.

So would I hence I would want S May with a 2nd rounder in return. Otherwise no deal and move on.

SEN radio just said the trade is a goer, if that mans anything.

Have to remember he has spent most of his life in a shizen team; if we re to join us would be great addition. Any pick between 11 and 15 is fair value.

Good to hear and will certainly be a handy addition.

I would as well by I doubt Freo would.

Why not? Crows got two 1sts for Lever with an exchange of later picks. A recent example would be Pies giving up Pick 7 and future 1st for Treloar.

Freo fans are talking pick 5 and future first for Hogan which seems fair value. I would trade the future first for May with a swap of their 2nd and our third rounder this year.

Rick Ashley, Gold WB! One of the posts of the year.

Hey McQueen, The $377 m assuming that is on top the interstate membership cost? (mine was $145 this year). If so I will prob do the same.

I find the Scotch is helping with this situation

Im sorry but after todays effort he is done for me; we have Hunt and Fritsch who can develop into that role.

Rather take Pick 5 and Brayshaw's brother if that were to happen. For the record Im against trading Hogan.