Farmer

The last 3 matches by Windsor showed why he is every bit an outside mid , which we badly need. On the other hand unless Sparrow makes great improvement , yes he should play as a Mid. At Casey! The last 3 matches showed why Windsor is a gun outside mid, with pace . On the other hand each year Sparrow’s stats get worse. Averaged 13 possessions a game in 25, compared with 17 in 23. I expected great things from him and have been SO disappointed . In the last match v Collingwood we would have won but for some real blunders by Sparrow in q4

I agree with you. Sparrow was extraordinarily poor in the last match v Collingwood. Seriously, we would have won but for a couple of his efforts. Sparrow should now be a major player within the club, he has had heaps of games but IMV he has not progressed one bit since 2021. If Culley were fit I doubt Sparrow gets a game

I would have let him go. He was bloody awful v Magpies. Has stagnated

Did u miss 55, 56, 57,59,60 and 64? I saw the lot. More flags-just a yawn!!!!

This is more like it. Those who are selecting a team without May at FB are deluded!

For Heavens’ Sake!!!!! If we are to go anywhere this year we need these two playing every match, or as many as injuries don’t prevent

Surprised that no one selects Tom MCD who, IMV was our best defender in 2025. Lever will have to improve a lot to be better than Tom. And I think Petty will still play forward . Mihocek is certainly not a CHF and Van Rooyen has shown nothing to suggest he is .

Bet u don’t say this after 6 weeks ! If Steele is not better than Sparrow I dont know the game . Absolutely nothing like Billings

Can’t believe this ! Salem had a great season

I thought the booing was a disgrace. Ended up supporting the Pies! So pleased Quaynor played brilliantly

Always on Hff, never on ball

Fullerton?

IMV it’s a no-brainer .we can be at Waverley next year. Caulfield in 5. Go to W now, even if it turns out to be temporary. All set up, great facilities NOW whilst we sort out issues at Caulfield. Personally I doubt we can. Ever heard of VCAT.

Fullerton has been great at CHB for the last 6 weeks. B o G twice. Definitely retain him another year. Our key defensive ranks are thin