DubDee

I agree PG. i see it as a good sign that 2nd year players cant just walk into the 22. we have unusually decided to play the best fit players in all 3 games and he hasnt made the cut as our midfield is actually decent now. Matt jones is probably the one taking his spot. so now - unlike other years - the young guy will have to knuckle down and lift his game and training strandards to a higher level Good signs! Hopefully he dominates at casey as he did last year and knocks the door down I think Mitch White had an injury concerns a few weeks back so maybe not fully fit

only a praccy match but it will be telling how we use the ball at etihad and how our skills look. we've had 2 hit outs to blow out the cobwebs will also be interesting to see us having to stick to 90 rotations and how our fitness looks against the saints. Hogan will come back in, wouldn't think they will be too many other first 22 players left out of the side as we'll have 2 weeks to rest up. Carn the Dees!

why does the media give such credence to what Eddie suggests? such ridiculous ideas. premiership points from the NAB challenge, knock down a stadium and build another one. how about getting back to grass roots and putting the money into stadiums around Melbourne, Princes park, waverly wherever. it would add a lot to the game

dont think the Dogs will back up there season last year. best senior players all on the wrong side of 30 and that should start to show, much harder draw too i think we'll see the rise of two of my least favourite teams in GWS and the Pies. think Port will just miss out as well. Westcoast Sydney Richmond Hawthorn Collingwood Fremantle GWS Geelong

you know you've been a Dees fan for a while when I had to scan the article for sarcasm. Hmm, not written by Titus O'reilly... it seems to be a serious article actually saying we could get around 15 wins. positive press! go Dees! everything would have to go right for us to do that. Dogs had an easy draw and the planets aligned for them. its nice to be a position to even dream about this rather than go kinto the season dreading most games

Schwadda, love him. so fked he didnt get a few seasons to fulfil his potential. Was a bittersweet treat watching those highlights. that team was terrific. worlds away from what we have been watching over the past decade like him in the media too

i just expected us to comfortably beat a beat missing their 15 best players. i acknowledged we were good in the last quarter. overall our effort was good all day - the skills were shocking. hopefully the conditions were mostly to blame

some are seriously arguing that they only had their best 15 players out - they still had a good team. hilarious. we were poor for 3 quarters and finally started playing in the 4th. if we dont play better than that we wont win many more than last year

i dont mean play well every now and again and then be terrible, I mean play consistent;y well and be leading by 4 goals. we were losing after each of the first 3 quarters. our last quarter was good but thats the least you would expect - our senior players to run over the top of their kids

still not sure what to make of yesterday. Great to have won 2 practice games on the trot. but the Dogs team was a VFL team, they werent just missing 'a few'. maybe 4 guys playing that will be in the 22 for round 1. do you think we would have competed if that was the case for us? we should have looked a class above. we should have lead comfortably all day. So overall, despite winning, I am less confident going into round one than I was before this game. you just have to look at how the Pies and GWS are playing. they look organised, highly skilled. And again - terrible start to the game! what are the odds of GWS being 3 goals+ up at 1/4 time round 1? I would put money on it. it'll be very interesting to see how we go against a near full strength St kilda

It means a little ive seen article saying demons win 2 from 2. God knows we need some positive press good for membership. Good for confidence.

He was notably poor today with the ball. Although his number one role is to beat his opponent and he did that. He still needs coaching on how to play to his strengths when he gets the ball i think garland was worse today. Really just seemed off. Hopefully just cobwebs

He was the main positive out of today. 9 contested possessions, showed he can take a mark and most importantly looks so comfortable at afl level on the ball or smashing someone is a tackle. If he stays fit he will play 15 games plus. Wont be long til he has the best handball in the team

Hi guys, looking for a league to join. Team name: not rebuilding cheers

I assume it will allowed for dees supporters to bring banners saying beat the cheats and drug cheats etc? I'll be getting the textas out! Once I think of something witty enough

Guide says it's on at 5 and 6pm on foxportsnews. Ch 500

theyll have a crack down for 6-7 rounds and then relax the interpretation and then at some unknown point later in the season will go hard again and wonder why players are confused what a joke the AFL and umpires are. its the one thing i dont miss about footy - pulling my hair out at the inconsistent, rubbish umpiring. Umpires should have to have played the game for 5+ years in my opinion. its too fast and complex a game to read about in books ill try to stop my rant there!

Get in Kieran Jack's ear Roosey!

are you referring to the Pedersen that over 3 seasons has played 36 games and kicked 25 goals? (I know some games were played in defence) he doesnt get involved enough in games and is too slow to put any pressure on. having said that, he will be CHF for round one I'd say, given dawes is injured. but to say he is streets aheads of the other options is crazy. fact is we have no good 2nd fwd/ruck and we need to deal with what we have

so good to see a first game player getting in trouble for being too rough. can you imagine that happening to the draft class of 2009? [JT aside] maybe change thread title from 'Oliver avoids ban' to 'Oliver gets BS fine'? hate how the AFL comes out every year with issues they are "going to crack down on". how about you just enforce the rules that are there fairly and consistently? Viney and Vandaberg are gonna be suspended every third game at this rate

couldn't love this bloke anymore without needing a restraining order if he stays fit he will play 24+ great games and make AA or come very close. NAB game shortened by 30+ minutes so it really was a 35+ posession game he is absoluetly pivitol to our teams rise and will certainly be named in the leadership team next month - perhaps VC

what a joke. Oliver didnt pin his arms. the bloke went to kick the ball like an overhead kick type motion, so he was moving that way and off balance. hope the senior players pay the fine for him. he would barely have gotten a pay cheque yet!

and collingwood are the experts in managing injuries? Reid, Elliot, Daisy Thomas, freeman, etc they usually have one of the longest injury lists and a lot of soft tissue injuries our medical staff know what they are doing and if there was any risk, they would do what they need to. a knee injury is very different to a hot spot on a foot so they would be trated differently

yeah one game in 6 months is too much. best rest them up and the quote "we now know we are going to be competative this year" are you for real? so you expect us to be good based on that one practice match? just like when we beat geelong away last year and then lost to bombers and Blues. Gee I hope the Dees do not have this soft, defeatist attitude. what if they injured? they could just as easily get injured in training - eg elliot, swallow, jones etc we need to get this young team playing together at every possible chance, how many games has our best players under 21 played together?

Great win. Was very impressed that we didn't let port come back. Thought harmes was good. Gave high hope for that kid kennedy surprised me in a good way viney had 28 and 16 contested in a short game. Equivalent of a 40 touch game kent, van denburg, Salem Oliver etc make me excited!!