DubDee

couple of upsets are on the cards I reckon the dogs will get up tonight. Carlton a real chance against GWS and the bombers are now without McGrath, Francis, Shiel, Hurley, Caldwell. but still should beat the Hawks

interesting read Hemingway, I completely agree. do you think Mackay should have been suspended though?

this is the part that I am not sure I agree with. Imo he did not elect to bump. he is going for the ball, I think gets a hand on it and the players collide in an accidental or incidental collision. This is the crux of what will be debated tonight. If you think he chose to bump he should get weeks if not, we should be cleared. If they declare it incidental contact but still suspend him then the game is in trouble and we will start to see players not attack the footy at 100% which will ruin it

Wins: Bombers GWS Hawks Gold Coast Dogs Crows Losses: Port (away) WC (away) Cats (away) Will leave us 17-5 and in the top 2. Obviously we could easily win against Port/WC/Cats, conversely we could easily lose to the six easer games. On balance and if we keep up the form we have shown in the first 13 games we should finish with 17 wins The games need to freshen up for sure over the bye and unlike many of our challengers we do not have many injuries to significant players (eg, Butters, Treloar, Shuey etc)

We were favoured by the umpires if anything. Bad decisions on both sides Collingwood deserved the win

Good to have confirmation that PF is Damian Barrett. I had suspected for a while

Likely changes based on emergencies this week viney and M Brown in sparrow and Weed out we desperately need a leading fwd.

We were off all game. Keen to get these ones out of system mid season and learn from it. second to ball, outnumbered at contests, making silly errors. anyone blaming individuals has no idea, the whole team blew this game

6. Jackson 5. salem 4. Gawn 3. May 2. Jordon 1. Trac

Any chance of us actually kicking it to Weideman?

Good lift in intensity that Q. Gawn was very good. we will win this we need to look at that first half.

WHY DO WE ALWAYS KICK IT SO WIDE?!?!

Our whole defensive structure is gone. Could be from a breakdown at any line. Once we lift our intensity we will be fine and get the job done. Jackson continues to improve. 12 touches a goal and 6 marks for a 19yo 2nd ruck. His second efforts and running are great

I reckon Clarry more than anyone has some credits in the bank. He can’t win every game for us. He get 20+ touches in the second half. No doubt

How does Kozzi do what he does and then drop a chest mark?? Absolute sitter inside 50

So good to see so many MND beanies in Perth!

Hope all is well Nasher. Good luck with your new era.

In fairness it’s unlikely he is living with your ex-wife

I like big cans too

I’ve had 3 weetbix with a light dusting of sugar, drenched in 4oC milk. hopefully that will prepare my body for the onslaught of alcohol today

They’ll both be gone by years end. clubs foolishly signing on caretaker coaches coz they win a few meaningless games.

Good to see Melksham held accountable for some average games. It’ll be hard for him to get back into the team now. chandler should be ahead of him in the pecking order

The Saints kicked one goal in a half of footy and got out run and out worked. that’s why they lost

The ball bounced over the line. Saints had no-one on the line when up by a point in the last minute at a stoppage. They are a shambles

yeah my dislike for them is probably clouding my judgement. They have been up for 16 bloody years. although they havent won it in 10. losing to them in a GF I am not sure I could take. bunch of oiled up wankers