Coq au vin

looked like the ball hit his face.

Toda was a great effort overall against a top four team. Way better than last week's effort. Perhaps the guys were affected by the week before in the heat of Darwin. There were many skill errors and some silly decisions that in the end cost the game. But there's definite progress. Except for Grimes and Frawley.

Frawley's decision-making for the past three yeas has been worse than an 82yo grandma's. He is slow, stupid and thinks too highly of himself. Get rid of him!!!

How many games would our firsts team win in the VFL?

And junior macdonald

20 million years

Please give Sam Blease a go this year! Also Strauss. These guys are afl players and need some game time. They will reward you if given the chance!

I'd like Gary Ablett, Dane Swan, Lance Franklin, Kurt Tippett, dangerfield, swallow (both), Luke breust, Cyril Rioli, Stevie Johnson, Hawkins, Ron Barassi and Norm Smith

We'd have to hope they missed a lot of goal kicks again. Especially after the way they dismantled Collingwood on the weekend. I was hoping for a much better second half of the season ALA some of the years Neale Balme coached MFC and the return or commencement of Jesse Hogan.It appears I was sadly mistaken. The disaster that Casey has become and the return of the couldn't care less or we're no good attitude of many players will make it unlikely we will win any further games at all. Until there can be a sustained culture change we are doomed to be cellar dwellers for many years to come.

fair enough but he's not much good at the football! Can't mar or kick or hand pass or pick up the ball very well. It would have been a chance to delist and find a real football player with skills.

But why re-sign Jake Spencer???

So we might be stuck with a lot of them

Gee it'd be interesting to know what Roos really thinks of each individual player's performance this year. I guess we'll find out when the trades, delistings start!

hes not that talented

so if you disagree with someone you indulge in personal attacks rather than putting forward a logical and reasoned argument?

At least Jamar showed some intensity and appeared to be genuinely trying hard which is more than can be said of the pathetic efforts of many others.

The association with Casey was an idea of the ancien regime. Similar to the China syndrome. Funny how that's gone away.

So if someone disagrees with your assessment you insult them with children's puppet character references?

A rival to Cale Morton, Lucas Cook and Gysberts or maybe Tom Couch?

Spuds and duds Duds and spuds

I think you were watching another game. Riley was useless as were all the dees except Viney and jamar. Did any if you actually go to the MCG today?

you are so right. How many of these couch potatoes were actually threre? I was there and the dees were terrible except for Jamar and Viney. Riley was terrible.

Mckenzie doesn't leave his man because he is tasked as a tagger. The rest of the post I agree with. Roos has not yet gotten rid of the scared rabbit behaviour and the interminable waiting before kicking the ball from a mark or free kick until the opposition has time to man up and then the ball is kicked to an impossible contest and turned over. Frawley is a master of this.

Young guys should have more energy. Being younger is no excuse.