Geddy Lee

You stole my line DD.

You will not get a definitive answer I'm afraid. I want to see Bohdan gone, but I understand that the majority of injuries have had nothing to do with his work. I want the new coach to bring his own fitness man so a cohesive direction is given to young malleable players like Jones and Frawley etc etc.

The kids raw, and I'd love to see him improve next year, and I think he will. I'm underwhelmed at present, but it's far too early to tell.

Why don't you do one so we can all take pot shots at your effort? I thought it was reasonably accurate.

Mark Riley - what's a structure? I thought players deserving commendation were Carrol, Brown, Green, Pickett and Robbo. CJ and Bode did a few very good things, and massive kudos to Jamar for flattening that Freo player, easily the highlight of the match.

Five of the seven are allegedly top of the tree at ********* Big names indeed!

I sure as hell don't want Pick #4, except Pavlich it's usually crap.

It's not about how you feel, it's just about who you think will get the gig. I want Sheeds but I think Bailey will get it.

I don't think anyone here thinks Mark Riley will be coach. Choose who you think will be our next senior coach? And post your choice as well so that you can claim retrospective glory. I think Dean Bailey will get the gig. Edit: *If a mod could set up a poll with the coach choices it'd be much appreciated, this BB system is a nightmare to use*

I think Carlton are going to lose, and there will be a massive unprecedented media and public uproar and the Carlton FC name will be tarnished beyond recognition. I hate the tanking bastards and the system needs an overhaul.

BeeDee over on BigFooty says it's down to Connolly and Bailey, and he is right 5% of the time

I honestly cannot say. Bruce or Green and neither one of those is particularly inspiring.

2 out of 4 ain't bad, a DUI and a sook and he'll complete the quaddy.

NO! Don't say that!!! Alas, another one afflicted.

Fantastic work Scoop, great read. Carter Beauford coincidently is the best drummer in the world, much to Neil Peart's chagrin.

My mail is the club is keen on Sheedy and they have gone off Bond. This game is fun!

Don't care who wins it, although if Hawthorn or Geelong win it I will vomit my gizzards into a nearby gutter because I cannot stand either of those football clubs.

That's what I thought about last night; didn't think he had much of a night at all. I'm stunned that he's getting all the 6s.

Great post Fan. I don't know if there has been a modern Melbourne side as bereft of leadership as Melbourne 2007. I thought someone would have stood up in the last four years but no-one has.

6 free kicks against and a stack of ineffective possessions.

Whatever happens I don't want people to say 'Jones for captain' and the like because we all know what happens once the fans decide on our next captain . . .

You can't be talking about Green . . .

Jones was our 3rd best I thought. Got caught multiple times and so deserved the comment. He's one of my favourite players, I don't have a specific agenda to taint any particular player's name on here like some people.

We had six players deserving recognition?!? 6 - Nathan Brown 5 - David Neitz 4 - Nathan Jones 3 - Colin Sylvia (I'm struggling) 2 - Brad Green 1- Lynden Dunn

R.I.P Dutchy? Won't be signed for next year with an injury like that and already so far on the fringe. How ironic that he hit two lace-out passes consecutively and then was injured so badly. Nathan Brown - some people think he should be delisted at the end of the season but he shows the most heart week in, week out; great tonight again. Nathan Jones & Brock McLean - pull your heads in kids, you are not nearly as fast as you think you are. Good signs - Lynden Dunn and to a lesser extent Jace Bode. Very strange game but I am proud of the way the boys fought in the second half. I was yelling so much I can't actually talk which is why I'm on here venting. Share your thoughts on the game.