M_9

Bobby Hill methinks. Four days to get over a sprained ankle. He’ll be right (unfortunately).

I wouldn’t be dropping Tommo. He was far from our worst player yesterday. Furthermore, I seem to recall him playing pretty well on KB last year (15 disposals, 10 marks) only to be dropped the following week. He’d remember that and IMO have something to prove.

Fieldman.

In fairness, his 2 disposals today was only marginally less than the 6 disposals he’s averaged over the last six weeks.

Joeboy - showed admirable constraint.

Go via Adelaide and drop Petty off.

No, no, you’re wrong there. I was at that game. Much more commitment shown that day.

Still, it presents an opportunity for those at Casey who are pressing for senior selection. Oh, wait …

‘Career worst game’ won’t get a run now I’ve used it.

Joeboy thumbing through his thesaurus as we ‘speak’. Keen to see how many derogatory descriptors he can find.

Your last three words are superfluous.

No Tiger on the goal line.

Hundreds, possibly thousands of hours transferring code in Fortran, Algol and COBOL onto cards never to use one iota of what I learnt - ended up teaching maths!

I too like this selection. Assuming we make the top eight we’re going to need Max for at least three, possibly more tough finals. He’ll be rucking significantly less time post bye you’d think. Similarly JvR is hardly battle-hardened and his TOG may decrease a tad. Luker could well be centre stage by round 20.

Me too. Totally confused by that interweb thingy. PS I graduated in 1975 with a degree in Computer Science.

I’m sure Staff is a ripping bloke. I’m more than happy to have him coaching the likes of Max, JvR, Petty, Fullarton (?), BBB and our new recruit in ruck craft. But when it comes to coaching players where to position themselves inside the forward 50, how to rove to a pack etc he’s not drawing on his experience. We could well use the likes of Matthew Lloyd, J Brown or even Eddie Betts.

The Keakouer bros had a reputation for waxing. Worked pretty well for them. The Kosimcadam bros - yeah, that’d work.

With Kosi, McAdam, Fritta, Chin, JvR, Fritta, Perry and (soon) Melksham we’ve got a veritable smorgasbord of talent, youth, experience and ability among our forwards. As I’ve said elsewhere, I have my doubts that Stafford is up for the challenge to have them work as a team. Exhibit A: Kosi and McAdam hopelessly flying for a speccy simultaneously.

Not our game but that dirty cheat C.Scott at it again. Votes in Cats v GWS 9 Toby Green GWS 5 M.Holmes Cats 5 Briggs GWS 4 Idun GWS 3 Riccardi GWS 2 Aleer GWS 2 Stengle GWS Ny tip Scott: 5 Holmes, 4 Green, 2 Stengle …

My sentiments exactly. Three marks and seven disposals between them. Petty laid one tackle. Similarly poor results for Petty last week - five disposals and one mark. As you rightly say, the cupboard is bare as far as a replacement for Petty, but surely BBB on one leg or Sestan, albeit 9cm shorter, would offer more of a contest.

As far as I'm aware Troy Chaplin is our Backs' coach and Stafford our Forwards' coach. The reason I bring that up because, IMV, our forward line has not improved one iota in the last two and a bit years. I know I'm off-topic but: We're expecting a former ruckman (Stafford) to turn a beckman (Petty) into a forward. That is failing miserably on every measure. Petty is a great, one grab, mark. But we've only seen it twice this year (v Hawks and Cats). He's a nice kick but we've seen that once as a forward (Tigers last year). Petty is frequently out of position when the ball enters our fifty. I can't recall seeing him on a lead. Currently Harrison is not deserving of his place in the team. A knowlegeable forwards' coach may change that. Similarly McAdam would benefit from having a former player experienced in forward craft coaching him.

Petty. [censored]. Can’t hold a chest mark. Trips over. Well win this with Chin, Petty and McAdam with no goals between them.

Leigh Montagnia on the money re Saints dysfunctional backline. 20 goal haul should be in our sights.

‘an MCG final against the Cats in two weeks’. Self medicating and then posting at 2am is not a good idea.