Lil_red_fire_engine

6 Lever 5 Melksham 4 Rivers 3 Viney 2. Langdon 1 Gawn

Mitch Lewis was the one went for and didnt land,

His last 3 weeks have been mediocre. Not comparing the two players as they play different roles and would also have different values in market. Not saying I would trade him but he is not “Heart and Soul” and is tradeable at the right price.

How many heart and soul players does a team have? I dont class Salem as one of them and his 2023 has been poor after a middling injury impacted 2022. We have others for the role on lesser $$$. I would not say he cant be traded at the right price.

It’s hard to do anything right or wrong if you cant run to a contest or jump at the ball. There is no way he plays his week.

Based on today our best options of not many is to play Tomlinson back, Smith forward and bring one of Spargo, Woey or Laurie in for Jordon. Anyone who looks at the stats and see they are led by Dunstan and Harmes need to recognise their games dont translate to anything that solves our problems at AFL level.

Not giving him credit, although I would back him to contest TDK better than Lever did for goal 2. Its more so that I dont recall a single thing he did in the 20 q1 inside 50s that would support him not being a good backline option.

Its interesting how we all see it differently. We gave up 20 inside 50s in the first quarter yet a backline with Smith in it repelled them to maintain the damage to one goal. We gave up ascendency for the first 8 minutes of the last to Carlton and they kicked 3 goals in a Smithless backline. Martin had next to no impact prior to Hibbo's entry into the game. Not saying Hibberd shouldnt be in the 22 but we defended much better with Smith in the back 6.

Even if Clarry’s not ready please get Harmes out of our side. I suggest we may see the Grundy forward experiment. In Oliver Grundy Out Harmes Petty

6 Petracca 5. Pickett 4. Nibbler 3. Brayshaw 2. Viney 1. Hunter

Did Tom Sparrows poorly executed kick to the leading Petty just massively impact our premiership chances? That ankle did not look good.

Salem just throws it on his boot. Lever outbodied by someone half his size. It’s going to be one of those days.

I would be angry if I was actually surprised. Too easily get ahead of themselves and/or cant handle expectation.

Did not come out with any pressure against a lower ranked side. May and Lever make amateur errors early to give the Roos a sniff. Players unable to execute a kick forward of centre.

One of the greatest players and showman the game has ever seen. How he could be that good at his size/role and not be a decent contested mark is insane.

The thing I loved most yesterday which maybe was more noticeable due to my sitting behind the goals with the Demon Army. How great it was to see two key forwards working in continual motion offering multiple leads not just pointing for it to be put on their heads.

6 Petty 5 Gawn 4 Viney 3 Langdon 2 Melksham 1 Petracca

Acknowledged. Most of the others are smaller. Random not extensive sample below. MCG 171m x 146m Coburg 165m x 140m Sandringham 160m x 120m Punt Road 159m x 124m Williamstown 165m x 135m Preston 169m x 127m Footscray 161m x 123m

Dunstan masses stats on smaller VFL ground that I suggest have more stoppages and less open transitional play. He is AFL standard around the stoppage offensively and defensively. Unfortunately away from the stoppage he lacks the transitional movement to defend and when he gets ball in open play lacks effectiveness by foot. Harmes has him well covered generally but most importantly can fill multiple roles. Dunstan is purely a first dibs inside mid with no further flex.

The last game Petty was tried properly forward against Hawthorn when get got injured. 2 goals, 6 marks (2 contested) in 33% game time. With Tomlinson form and the lack of form from Brown surely people get this is worth another look?

I would go Petty forward with Woewodin, Hibberd and McVee. I would give Sparrows midfield time to RIvers alllowing both Hibbo and Judd to play back 7. In saying this I reckon it will be Petty, Harmes, Hibberd, Woewodin with Smith again as Sub and McVee taking a well earnest rest.

6. Brayshaw 5. Viney 4. Chandler 3. Gawn 2. Pickett 1. Rivers

Cant possibly see us being able to afford even close to what others would pay and would only make sense if we are set on moving Petty. He will be at the Bombers or the Swans is my opinion (no source).

Need to consider JVR, McVee and Woewodin have developed to the point of being in the 22 of a top 4 side at the minute. Howes, Laurie and Disco Turner who are all are consistently impacting at VFL not playing makes the cupboard look barer as well.

This is what I have been considering more and more. If WC truly want Curtin they may need to bite the bullet at 1 otherwise high risk he is not there at 4 and beyond. North have loaded on mids in Wardlaw, Powell, Phillips with early picks as well as Sheezel. They have LDU and Simpkin in their prime. They are about to lose McKay and other than Larkey have no other quality young talls. Hawthorn have a young deep midfield brigade but have no real quality keys aside Lewis forward and the undersize Sicily. Good chance either of them take Curtin.