Scott Cummings just announced on 3AW that "Whispers", a person who is usually spot on, says and I quote "Judd will announce very soon (today???) that Melbourne is his club of choice.

Another sitting panelist said he has heard the same thing!!!

Those who listen to Sports Tonight on 3AW would know of Whispers and the predictions he passes on to the 3AW team of Gerard Healy and Dwayne Russell and co.

Just before 7 tonight, he called and Scott Cummings mentioned on air that Judd wants to go to the Dee's.

So I am now officially getting excited, as Whispers has a great strike rate of getting it right!!!

Those who listen to Sports Tonight on 3AW would know of Whispers and the predictions he passes on to the 3AW team of Gerard Healy and Dwayne Russell and co.

Just before 7 tonight, he called and Scott Cummings mentioned on air that Judd wants to go to the Dee's.

So I am now officially getting excited, as Whispers has a great strike rate of getting it right!!!

And I've been looking at big footy and I KNOW that they are very unreliable but there is lots of evidence there.

I saw this at West Coast [Re: Chris Judd sweep]

"to Melbourne for Picks 4 and 5 (5 via Bulldogs for Robbo) enabling WC to draft 2 young WA mids"

I saw this at Carlton [Re: Judd will nominate Melbourne]

"Bad news...Judd will nominate Mlebourne. Heard it at the a MFC Past players function last night!!!!

I really hope i'm wrong!!!"

And I saw this at Collingwood [Re: Judd May Chose Melbourne]

"Sen have reported according david schartz that Judd is very clse to announcing his club of choice.It will be melbourne according to the Ox.

If true at least we don't have to sell off the farm.Hooray i reckon."

Now I know that bigfooty is unreliable but the fact that these three clubs reckon he is coming to melbourne is a good sign. Considering i dont see any ppl here hearing insider info about judd going to Collingwood, Carlton or Essendon, I think all looks good.

Whispers isn't our own Whispering Jack is he?

Whispers isn't our own Whispering Jack is he?

Definitely NOT!!!

And I've been looking at big footy and I KNOW that they are very unreliable but there is lots of evidence there.

Big Footy isn't evidence

Anyhow, even if Judd has decided on a Club and the news is somehow out (which I'm doubtful of), I don't think the trade talk is anything more than speculation.

I really don't want to get excited, but it's been practically the same thing on SEN and 3AW; Judd is coming to Melobourne.

Oh god...

I really don't want to get excited, but it's been practically the same thing on SEN and 3AW; Judd is coming to Melobourne.

Oh god...

Let's not get ahead of ourselves. We can start celebrating if and when he makes an announcement in our favour and not before.

In the meantime, let's not speculate about who we're going to trade to get him. IMHO it's unhealhty and a waste of time.

Pretty much what Hirem says !!

Practically all that could be stitched up is a deal with what we do have plus what we might get..etc. Trade week hasn't started (offically, well and truly started already for mine..lol ) so until trades are firmed up who knows what really will be exchanged?

Let's balance this out:

What do we know ?? umm....hmmm....ummm... well ...nah!! lol oh...Judd is coming to town...and thats it Not much is it !!! lol

What don't we know ?? everything else !!! lol

All sounds good, but i won't start celebrating until we give him his Dees jumper and he signs on the dotted line!