Ben Rutten to the Demons

[Yze_Magic 3]

My offer

Brad Green , pick 18, pick 21 and Brad Miller

to Adelaide for

Ben Rutten and Brent Reilly

2008

B - Whelan Rutten Carroll

HB - Bell Rivers Bartram

C - Johnstone Jones Wells

HF Sylvia Newton Bate

F - Dunn Neitz Davey

R - Kreuzer McLean McDonald

IC - White Reilly Moloney Petterd

Emer - Robertson Yze Pickett Wheatley P.Johnson Bode Frawley etc...

[Jarka 767]

YM, if you keep posting possible trade you'll eventually get one that will be close, my guess is that you'll need about 42 more though.

[Cactus 2]

My offer

Cameron Bruce , pick 18, pick 21 and Brad Miller

to Adelaide for

Ben Rutten and Brett Reilly

i thought bruce and pick 18 were going to the Roos for Wells

[WonnaJurah 5]

crows wont take that

[The Fergburger 0]

Melbourne aren't the only team wanting Rutten so the odds are pritty low. I'd rather get wells.

[w00dy 146]

why don't you make one trade thread with all your trade theories in it? would save a bit of room, it's still a month before october rolls around

[Demon Disciple 12,452]

Apparently Wells suffered a knee injury at training yesterday. Just thought it would be worth posting. They don't know the exntent of the damage yet though.

[Demon Head 299]

YM, if you keep posting possible trade you'll eventually get one that will be close, my guess is that you'll need about 42 more though.

I get the feeling that any moment now Chilliboy is going to turn up around here. Can't wait!

[Scoop Junior 3,568]

Yep Adelaide will really look to trade a gun FB like Rutten. Last line gorilla defenders are expendable

[occo 2]

Haha this trate is stupid...yeha and lets pick up Judd too while were at it...oh and Cox and Sandilands, and Johno Brown. Adel would never give him up even for a 1st rounder

[Guest unstable punt]

My offer

Brad Green , pick 18, pick 21 and Brad Miller

to Adelaide for

Ben Rutten and Brent Reilly

2008

B - Whelan Rutten Carroll

HB - Bell Rivers Bartram

C - Johnstone Jones Wells

HF Sylvia Newton Bate

F - Dunn Neitz Davey

R - Kreuzer McLean McDonald

IC - White Reilly Moloney Petterd

Emer - Robertson Yze Pickett Wheatley P.Johnson Bode Frawley etc...

geez?????????

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

Yep Adelaide will really look to trade a gun FB like Rutten. Last line gorilla defenders are expendable

Spot on.

Why are trades always posted that are potentially good for MFC and absolutely rotten for the counterparty on this site?

[Kit Walker 225]

Spot on.

Why are trades always posted that are potentially good for MFC and absolutely rotten for the counterparty on this site?

Not sure you could call that trade rotten for Adelaide. Reilly is decent but fringe and Rutten is very good but with an ageing midfield they pick up a quality 26 year old goal kicking midfielder and two very early second round picks plus the speculative trade of Miller.

[Rhino Richards 1,467]

Not sure you could call that trade rotten for Adelaide. Reilly is decent but fringe and Rutten is very good but with an ageing midfield they pick up a quality 26 year old goal kicking midfielder and two very early second round picks plus the speculative trade of Miller.

They give up a high quality hard to find AA FB, an AFL standard player for a one paced middle of the road midfielder (how many goals has he kicked this year from the midfield?) and a NQR below AFL standard player and two second round picks.

Rutten would command more.

I would do it in a flash. Its a stinker for Adelaide

[tess 19]

I fancy bigfooty would appreciate this corker of a thread.

[Demons 32 235]

Never gonna happen.

The Wells thread was more realistic. Rutten won't go anywhere.

[Ash35 425]

2008

B - Whelan Rutten Carroll

HB - Bell Rivers Bartram

C - Johnstone Jones Wells

HF Sylvia Newton Bate

F - Dunn Neitz Davey

R - Kreuzer McLean McDonald

IC - White Reilly Moloney Petterd

Emer - Robertson Yze Pickett Wheatley P.Johnson Bode Frawley etc...

How the hell is Kreuzer in this team?

At what stage did Melbourne recieve the No.1 pick in the draft?

[Demons 32 235]

How the hell is Kreuzer in this team?

At what stage did Melbourne recieve the No.1 pick in the draft?

Think YM is assuming the Tigers will win and we will loose.

[Gouga 570]

What about...

Bruce and White to St.Kilda

St.Kilda's first pick (9 or 10) to Brisbane

Charman to Melbourne

[Demons 32 235]

What about...

Bruce and White to St.Kilda

St.Kilda's first pick (9 or 10) to Brisbane

Charman to Melbourne

No

[Gouga 570]

No

Why not?

Isn't everyone a winner?

[Jaded No More 68,975]

Why not?

Isn't everyone a winner?

I like it Gouga!

Would absolutely love Jamie Charman at Melbourne. Problem is, I really can't see Brisbane letting him go.

They are more likely to let Woods go than Charman.

[Curis 0]

What about...

Bruce and White to St.Kilda

St.Kilda's first pick (9 or 10) to Brisbane

Charman to Melbourne

Ummm... Where does Melbourne win in that one? We give up a decent player that just struggles to dispose of the ball by hand or foot (Can be worked on pre-season) and one decent, but fading ruckman who will quite often win the tap, but the mid-field isn't there for the clearance.

In return we receive Charman who is vastly inferior to White and much more injury prone. St Kilda is the only winner there.

[Gouga 570]

I like it Gouga!

Would absolutely love Jamie Charman at Melbourne. Problem is, I really can't see Brisbane letting him go.

They are more likely to let Woods go than Charman.

The only reason Brisbane would let him go is because he wants a 5 year contract and they are only prepared to offer 3.

Its not much but it is something.

[Bring-Back-Powell 15,261]

What about...

Bruce and White to St.Kilda

St.Kilda's first pick (9 or 10) to Brisbane

Charman to Melbourne

Highway robbery by the Saints