its not like i dont think hes good.. i dont think we need him....

we have an never ending list of midfielders and smaller forwards who can play midfeild at times...

Great discussion guys, and from what I hear you may have a shot at both players.

Some trade suggestions for both?

Would you be interested in Jamar, since you're still desperate for a ruckman?

Great discussion guys, and from what I hear you may have a shot at both players.

Just to throw something in the mix:

Umm are you saying this just to tease us?

Seriously mate

still you would be mad to knock a quality midfield player back if you could pick him up for a decent trade you would be mad not to take him or at least bargain for him.

when nick "revolt" gets a boo-boo and cries who is gunna wipe away his tears? I want our team to become the hard-as-rock fierce team that other teams fear to play because of our physical and mental toughness....which we are starting to develop with jones, brocky etc. give bate time to improve and he will be better than revolt in my humble opinon.

And I love your humble opinion! I agree with what u say every time!

u and riewoldt have that in commen then

LMAO! Funniest thing I heard all day even tho it is 8.45

Would rather get judd

fact 1: roo cant kick goals unless hes lining up from the top of the square. still be nice to have him.

fact 2: no big name player will look at DEES with ND still running the ship.

People are talking about swapping Miller for Riewoldt???? HaHa thats Hilarious-But St.Kilda are that Loony they might just go for it!!!!

Bring me Whiskey

just watched the saints/kangas game. oh yeah revolt is a great player. had a MASSIVE impact on the game and was such an inspiring leader........hahaha more evidence the cream puff he truly is.... when the game gets a bit too hard for him his cream turns a bit sour..... still don't want him. never will.

A slightly better yet overrated version of miller, next.

just watched the saints/kangas game. oh yeah revolt is a great player. had a MASSIVE impact on the game and was such an inspiring leader........hahaha more evidence the cream puff he truly is.... when the game gets a bit too hard for him his cream turns a bit sour..... still don't want him. never will.

You are a clown

I guess you where not @ the G in 2004 when he kicked a lazy 9 against us.

Put him in the right enviroment & he is as good as most going around.

If on the market put him on the shopping list.

Or would you be happier to persist with Miller?

so he kicked 9 against us 3 seasons ago. WE MUST GET HIM QUICK...... doesn't change the fact that he has a soft creamy centre. Can't remember mentioning miller anywhere in this thread. Bate will be our man anyway. What is the right enviroment by the way , aren't all matches played on a footy field? or do u mean he is only good when its 26 degrees outside?

You are a clown

I guess you where not @ the G in 2004 when he kicked a lazy 9 against us.

Put him in the right enviroment & he is as good as most going around.

If on the market put him on the shopping list.

Or would you be happier to persist with Miller?

Stephen Milne kicked 11 goals once, what a superstar...

just watched the saints/kangas game. oh yeah revolt is a great player. had a MASSIVE impact on the game and was such an inspiring leader........hahaha more evidence the cream puff he truly is.... when the game gets a bit too hard for him his cream turns a bit sour..... still don't want him. never will.

im with you redandblue. on two occasions in the third nick had the potential to put the saints bk in it and on two occasions he failed them. He did the same thing against geelong - takes the marks most couldn't, yet fails to deliver time and again. Why can't he convert from places I could? No Saint supporter has faith in the man and I can't imagine his team mates do either.. When the chips are down, Nick cannot stand up..

comes from a massive losing culture and i don't know if you can suddenly transport a winning one into him.