NON-MFC: Round 23

[titan_uranus 25,014]

48 minutes ago, Demonstone said:

If I've read the ladder correctly, Fremantle make the eight if they beat Port next week and any of Carlton (v St Kilda), Hawthorn (v North) or Footscray (v GWS) lose.  They're in with a show but have to win to be any chance.

Correct. 

Fremantle’s destiny is out of their hands. They may be eliminated by the time they play, if those three sides all win. But if any lose, they will pass the loser(s) with a win because of their draw. 

Collingwood effectively eliminated (mathematically alive but need 150+ point swings or something).

[John Demonic 5,790]

54 minutes ago, picket fence said:

How Fagan continually puts up with that perenial big game choker in ERIC HIPWOOD Bafles me. Until they banish him and a few others who choke in big games, they will go nowhere

He's only ever played a big final against us in 22 lol  ....And inducted himself into: The Kent Kingsley Memorial Society of Spuds Who Play Well Against Melbourne

Edited August 18 by John Demonic

[DubDee 25,848]

Freo missing finals on 13.5 wins will be pretty funny

Although the Blues losing on 13 would be better 

[dees189227 12,390]

Ha ha 24 hours ago the ferals were [censored] a hoot, the players were celebrating.

24 hours later they're flat & now whinging about games they lost earlier in the season. 

Just would have been sweeter if they lost that gf last year.

Oh well. After next week I don't have to see them or essendon play again this year

[binman 42,903]

So, the pies win a flag - and fail to make the finals the following year.

Culture issues?

Edited August 18 by binman

[Gawndy the Great 9,011]

1 hour ago, binman said:

So, the pies win a flag - and fail to make the finals the following year.

Culture issues?

On First Crack, all three panelists had us as the most disappointing club 2024. Collingwood 4 pts in front of us was 2nd, 3rd most disappointing and Huddo didnt even have them in the top 4 most disappointing. 

Im not suggesting we don’t belong there but surely that #1 spot solely goes to the pies - the reigning premiers ? 
 

Edited August 18 by Gawndy the Great

[Jaded No More 68,906]

Just now, Gawndy the Great said:

On First Crack, all three panelists had us as the most disappointing club 2024. Collingwood 4 pts in front of us was 2nd, 3rd most disappointing and Huddo didnt even have them in the top 4 most disappointing. 

Im not suggesting we don’t belong there but surely that #1 spot solely goes to the pies - the reigning premiers ? 
 

Guess they all know Pies fluked a flag they didn’t really deserve. Hence it’s little wonder they are where they are. 

[titan_uranus 25,014]

8 hours ago, Gawndy the Great said:

On First Crack, all three panelists had us as the most disappointing club 2024. Collingwood 4 pts in front of us was 2nd, 3rd most disappointing and Huddo didnt even have them in the top 4 most disappointing. 

Im not suggesting we don’t belong there but surely that #1 spot solely goes to the pies - the reigning premiers ? 
 

How are Adelaide and St Kilda not numbers 1 and 2?

David King had written us off prior to the Carlton pre-season game, whilst he talked St Kilda up all summer.

Adelaide was supposed to be the next big thing and are going to finish bottom 4.