On 26/10/2023 at 10:40, Bring-Back-Powell said:

Gone are the days are all of Trac, Oliver and Gawn having a mortgage of the top 10/15 of everyone's list but well done to Viney for cracking #7. Never thought I'd see him that high!

The umpires loved his season too.

Dwayne still can't convince me that Gawn isn't a better and more vaulable footballer than Zac Merrett or Tom Liberatore.

I love Jack Viney but that's some serious over-rating

12 hours ago, old55 said:

I love Jack Viney but that's some serious over-rating

It’s a judgement on season 2023. That’s not stupid if you take Jack’s performances. Clearly his best season by far. 

the majority of the list could be ratings for 2023. there are usually a couple of dozen surprises each year. Lazy effort

i wound predict :

Walsh to bolt into the top 10

Andy Brayshaw to bounce back hard and into top 25. smokey for the brownlow 

Dusty to slide

Larkey stiff as. North will improve. he should kick 90

Fritsch to be fit all year and kick 70. would be in my top 40

etc

On 25/10/2023 at 20:12, Palace Dees said:

Bit harsh. He's part of a 24/7 sports station, with an emphasis on AFL (thankfully). It was simply an opinion piece showing rare respect for our beloved Jack. I'd listen and read Dwayne's stuff any day if Corn 🌽  is the alternative. 

" Corn" is paid to be contentious..he does it very very well and sometimes is both amusing and self depreciating and even  occasionally on the money. 

Dwanye has no insight,nor virtues as a commentator or and analyst. 

Only BT is worse

 

Edited October 27, 20231 yr by IRW

On 26/10/2023 at 06:44, Kent said:

many on here speciously overate our list in my view WE will struggle to make the 8 WE blew two years of chances and other teams are now equal or better

I absolutely love your optimism, but here and on other threads.