Joel Smith

[TeamPlayedFine39 8,495]

1 minute ago, Ethan Tremblay said:

I’ve put it down to who his old man is. 

And he was 100% worth a shot on the back of who his father was and being able to sign him as a Category B Rookie.
He can fill some gaps and is a decent athlete.
I just can't see him solving any of our onfield programs and would see him as the back-up to the back-up in just about every part of the ground.

[bobby1554 1,244]

1 hour ago, spirit of norm smith said:

Agree. His footy IQ is poor and not the answer imo. I know others don’t agree, but I think the Kangas could look at him and whilst a punt, we could try to grab the out of favour Mason Wood off the Roos as a swap. 

We could throw Preuss in as the steak knives. The two dumbest players on our list

[WERRIDEE 5,457]

He didn't come through the under 18's like most give him time he's worth persisting with.

[bobby1554 1,244]

6 minutes ago, WERRIDEE said:

He didn't come through the under 18's like most give him time he's worth persisting with.

How much time do you give someone who has shown nothing? He isn’t a natural footballer and unfortunately will never be. And that is because he didn’t have that junior development.  Clutching at straws with this bloke, time to move on

[WERRIDEE 5,457]

14 minutes ago, bobby1554 said:

How much time do you give someone who has shown nothing? He isn’t a natural footballer and unfortunately will never be. And that is because he didn’t have that junior development.  Clutching at straws with this bloke, time to move on

Another year I say his form in the scratch matches have been good.

[bobby1554 1,244]

3 minutes ago, WERRIDEE said:

Another year I say his form in the scratch matches have been good.

I would rather see a spot given to Nathan Jones so he can get to 300 games. Even though I believe the game has gone past Nathan as well, if that is what it comes down to..........

[rjay 24,898]

9 hours ago, DeeZee said:

He is a natural forward and looked in form in the preseason.

Then they decided to play him back.

Like Harmes could ruin his career

 

9 hours ago, Pickett2Jackson said:

 

Yes.  Hes a forward.  Totally lost down back.  Another ridiculous decision from our coaching staff.

He's really not...

Been tried there before in real games and it didn't work.

'Wise' spells it out pretty well here.

6 hours ago, Wiseblood said:

Is he a forward?  Apart from a few goals in a pre-season game, what has he done to suggest he'll be any good there?

I was happy to give him time to develop down back, but I'm not sure if he's going to solve many issues by getting a run up forward.  He strikes me as a very athletics, but low football IQ, type of player, and we don't really need that right now.

 

[Adam The God 30,153]

I've been on record since just about Joel's first game as been one of his detractors. He has great athleticism, we all know that and poor IQ etc, but we may need someone to play foil for Weideman at the expense of Tom, who can barely run right now.

Would we prefer Smith or Brown? Brown can get out the back for a cheapie, but can he play second ruck? It's dangerous to mix the midfield set up too much, given the lack of connectivity and understanding between Preuss and the on ballers yesterday, but perhaps that was a misnomer?

I think we're going to be forced to make a move on McDonald sooner or later though.

[Go the Biff 3,414]

Smith is no forward but there may be a place for him on the half back flank. Replacing Harmes who is hopelessly out of form.

Brown can be a good lead up target. Did that well in R1 but dropped every ball he got his hands to. Usually a safe uncontested mark & kick. No value as a second ruck though. Sorry @A F, I haven't helped at all

Edited August 23, 2020 by Go the Biff
sp

[whatwhat say what 22,713]

if it's 40 + 2 then i can see smith surviving on the list next year, and i suspect the fact that josh wagner has been pushed out of playing a defensive role - his natural position - in these scratch matches in favour of smith indicates that the footy dept see him as a defender and worth persisting with in that role

i don't see him being in the best 22 of an afl side that is going to be featuring in finals football

if we are reliant upon the likes of smith, baker, hunt, anb, the wagners being in our afl-level side then we're in a bit of trouble

a lot of them are fine athletes and probably very good at lower levels, but there's nothing about their games that makes me think they're worth persevering with if list reductions are completely ott in 2021