Jump to content

The CHF Debate


CarnTheDees

Recommended Posts

Although I have been heavily critical of ND and Co in the past, I think that they deserve some credit. Although we haven't seriously challenged for a flag since 2000 (and that was never a serious challenge), the re-building of the club over the past 4 years both on and off the field is an impressive achievement. The sum of this is that now we are getting into a position where we can really start to challenge, due to good recruitment and list management, and strong support at board level.

However, we are still at least 1 key ingredient away from the ultimate success: a good CHF. Someone who has a physical presence, and draws the football to them. Look back at past premiership sides, and most of them had one. The evolution of the game toward speed may decrease the value of the power CHF slightly, but they will still be relevant for the next few years.

So what do we do?

Is Miller the solution? NO. Has the physical presence, but not the footballer's brains or basic skills. I see his role as either to learn to become a decent defender (unlikely), or out the door. Unfortunately he's probably our best choice currently, so he'll stay for the time being.

Dunn? NO. The opposite to Miller. Smart and skilful, but lacks menace and power in the air. Could become a good 3rd tall (Robbo, O'Keefe type), but never a KPP.

Is there anyone else on our list who could fill this void in the next few years? Bate, Holland, PJ... NO. I can't comment on the new recruits but the feedback I've read here doesn't describe them as future CHFs.

What about Neita to CHF? I know it has been tried in the past with minimal success, but it was only really used as a stop-gap. Maybe he could play an old-fashioned CHF role (Carey-like), staying around the 50, as opposed to the Tredrea, Miller type which relies on hard running to present on the wing. The reason that I suggest this is that we do have cover for him at FF. Obviously not as effective as Neita, but we could fill his presence in the square with Jamar or even Miller (teach him to kick first), and play Robbo permanently deep as well to add to the aerial threat. Rotate Green and Bruce through the forward line to present on the lead, and ensure Davey stays inside 50 (and probably Yze as well because surely the motivation of a few goals could fire him up) and we'd have a relatively well balanced forward line, that is still fairly potent, whilst ensuring a presence at CHF to straighten us up.

Comments?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Miller will be staying at CHF for the time being.

Neitz needs to play close to goals as our main target up forward, for both his sake and the teams. Dunn will take over from Miller at CHF, but for the time being Miller will stay there methinks.

I want to see our mids kicking heaps of goals, West Coast style. I want them to run hard, never stop running, and kick a stack of goals. I want to see Travis, Bruce, Green, Mclean, Jones, Moloney all amongst the goals when I read the match report in the paper.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The fact that we don't have a standout CHF is a worry, it's compounded even more by the fact that we don't have a successor to Neitz when he retires. So that's CHF and FF that we have to deal with in the near future and if you look at our list it's a choice out of these players:

Miller

Dunn

P.Johnson

Newton

Garland

Frawley

Newton I think has the talent to become our FF, whether he can get himself right is another question.

At the moment Dunn plays more like a flanker, he'll need to get stronger to be a better target.

Miller and PJ are not up to it, Frawley looks more like a defender and I don't know enough about Garland to pass judgement.

Our spine is a worry.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The fact that we don't have a standout CHF is a worry, it's compounded even more by the fact that we don't have a successor to Neitz when he retires. So that's CHF and FF that we have to deal with in the near future and if you look at our list it's a choice out of these players:

Miller

Dunn

P.Johnson

Newton

Garland

Frawley

Newton I think has the talent to become our FF, whether he can get himself right is another question.

At the moment Dunn plays more like a flanker, he'll need to get stronger to be a better target.

Miller and PJ are not up to it, Frawley looks more like a defender and I don't know enough about Garland to pass judgement.

Our spine is a worry.

I will disagree about our spine being the worry. From the full back we have: Carroll (who in my opinion will never be the best FB but is more than adiquate), Rivers (in my opinion could be better than Chad Cournes), McLean (a superstar), Dunn (is developing but will be a champion CHF) and Neitz (one of the best FF we have seen).

I agree there is a real issue with our CHF but i think Dunn will be a better play if we actually get him on the ground. Miller in my opinion is not worthwile. He promiced so much and has let us down and we cant keep giving chances for him ton show something. Have we thought about possibly playing Miller in the forward pockett (although his kicking would be an issue). If he could kick goals I think he could make our forward line dangerious

F: Davey Neitz Miller

HF: Robbo Dunn Pickett

Thats my thoughts anyway. Im not concirned with our spine...i am about our depth however. Reassess at the end of the year but i would get Miller to play pocket a few times. Last chace. If no difference hes off for a round pick or a midfielder (where our depth is weak)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I used to think Neitz to CHF would be the solution. It is probably a few years too late but. He won't be able to provide that contest we need for the whole game. We might get an extra year out of him if he continues to play close as well.

I agree that Dunn and Miller are both not up to the task.

My solution would be to play two mobile CHF at all times. The candidates are Bate, Dunn, Miller and Robbo. Bate and Miller could be the lead up CHF's and Dunn and Robbo would be the stay at home 40m out type CHF. As long as their are two blokes at all times whose job it is to make that contest and provide that link we are better off than relying on just Dunn or Miller.

50% of the time we need a mark, the other 50% of the time we just need a contest to give our small forwards a chance!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Teams only need one power forward. Neitz can play CHF-FF like Hall does, they're fairly similar players.

Succession plan is a problem but it's not for want of trying. I was keen that we went for KPPs in this year's draft for that reason and we went for them with 1st and 3rd pick. Nick Smith, Luke Molan, Brent Grgic ... Power forwards are hard to come by. Got any trade ideas? Don't think J.Brown, Pavlich or N.Riewoldt will be available.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Teams only need one power forward. Neitz can play CHF-FF like Hall does, they're fairly similar players.

Succession plan is a problem but it's not for want of trying. I was keen that we went for KPPs in this year's draft for that reason and we went for them with 1st and 3rd pick. Nick Smith, Luke Molan, Brent Grgic ... Power forwards are hard to come by. Got any trade ideas? Don't think J.Brown, Pavlich or N.Riewoldt will be available.

Agree. I think the modern game is moving away from the standard FF/CHF model. I think Tredrea, Brown, Hall all float in that role. Toss in Pavlich ( On song he can play anywhere).

Power forwars are hard to come by and we probably wont appreciate the importance of Neitz until he is gone.

Link to comment
Share on other sites


I'm not convinced that the modern game is moving away from the need for power forwards. Out of the last five premiership teams only the Eagles lacked a serious heavyweight forward but they got away with it because of their awesome midfield which is full of talent and depth. Judd, Cousins, Kerr, Fletcher, Stenglein, Embley etc. We simply cannot match them in that department so our success must come from a different route.

Let's look at the recent winners and their forwards:

Eagles - No standout forward but have an awesome midfield. Lynch their best with 65 goals

Swans - B.Hall 80 goals 15 touches 7.9 marks

Port - Tredrea 81, 15.6, 7.7

Brisbane 3 - Lynch 78, 9.3, 4.6

Brisbane 2 - 74, 9.2, 4.6

Brisbane 1 - 53, 9.3, 4

Brisbane also had a couple of handy blokes roaming around the forward line in Bradshaw and J.Brown.

Essendon - Lloyd 105, 14, 7.5

Now I love our captain, he's a club champion, but he turned 32 this year and there is no way that he is going to be able to provide us with those types of output this year, and who will fill his shoes when he retires?

Our spine is still a worry, Carroll is as honest as they come but he struggles against the better forwards, and in the finals that's where he'll get tested the most. Rivers (and McLean) is the only top class long term prospect but most of the time he doesn't even play CHB, normally as a loose third tall.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Comments?

good post miller likes to lead and neitz could play the bang and crash style needed for chf, however i feel they have left this move too late

Edited by Nasher
Removed huge quote
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I dont think its a move away from power forwards. I think it is a matter that you need one rather than two.

I also think that the changes that have occurred in the game have happened within the last 3 to 5 years. So I think the Lions hat trick may be the somewhat during the start of the changes. I note that the Lions will be having J Brown up forward but not sure they will play another power forward.

I am not sure that the Saints with Gehrig and Riewoldt work smoothly last year and they became somewhat predictable for oppositions to counter.

I disagree that the Eagles dont have a power forward. They have Quinten Lynch (194cm/103kgs) who in last years GF displayed some of the awesome marking potential he has and kicked 3 crucial goals. If he blossoms then WCE will be even more potent.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The power forward in many teams is now playing a mixed CHF-FF role, getting out of the goalsqaure and moving his defender around. Barry Hall does it brilliantly.

I'm told that Matthew Bate went to CHF in the last quarter last week and I'm wondering if he might end up there as a run and carry type CHF who can bob up and kick a goal and roam down to the wings to create space for the other forwards when required.

Bate is about the same height as Matthew Pavlich in some footy guides (although not yet as heavy).

Link to comment
Share on other sites

we probably wont appreciate the importance of Neitz until he is gone.

How very true, Rhino

this is neitz's 14th season in the AFL (93-07)

Lets us appreciate the importance he gives to the team now while he is still playing

in regards to a CHF

For the time being, i think Miller will stay there

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Agree. I think the modern game is moving away from the standard FF/CHF model. I think Tredrea, Brown, Hall all float in that role. Toss in Pavlich ( On song he can play anywhere).

Only one problm Rhino. At 32 Neitz is not nearly as athletic and agile as those players listed above. He needs to stay close to goal. This means we need another player to step up and play that role.

Last year we fell over at half forward most games. Relying on our 32 year old captain to fix this problem by pushing up the ground is too much. Especially when you consider we are also relying on him to kick the majority of our goals.

I still favour the two mobile CHFs like I suggsted above.

If only Robbo was 10cm taller, our problem would be solved!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Only one problm Rhino. At 32 Neitz is not nearly as athletic and agile as those players listed above. He needs to stay close to goal. This means we need another player to step up and play that role.

Last year we fell over at half forward most games. Relying on our 32 year old captain to fix this problem by pushing up the ground is too much. Especially when you consider we are also relying on him to kick the majority of our goals.

I still favour the two mobile CHFs like I suggsted above.

If only Robbo was 10cm taller, our problem would be solved!

I dont propose Neitz play a CHF role. But the changing demands of football suggest to me that you need only one gorilla most of the time up forward. At 32, Melb does have an issue as to what to do for succession. As Old 55 pointed out it is not that the Club has not tried. And good gorilla forwards are so hard to find.

We fell over more often in the midfield more than CHF and much of the weakness resulted from the way we moved the ball.

But you are right about the issue of mobility but I dont know if they are CHFs. I would suggest there more roaming HFs. I guess you might have been referring to Dunn and Miller. i think Dunn has to the ability and will rise to the occassion over time. I dont see Miller cutting it no matter how much posters are willing him to be what he ihas shown that is not.

I think Robbo is a dilemna. His best work is done in the FF line where he is hard to mark up as plays "tall". However he is not mobile enough for HFF. My concern this year is that he carries the knee injury from last year and if his mobility is reduced he will close to useless and end up at Sandy.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

My concern this year is that he carries the knee injury from last year and if his mobility is reduced he will close to useless and end up at Sandy.

He was close to useless last year and didn't end up at Sandy. Lets hope 2007 ain't a repeat.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Dunn has always looked more comfortable closer to goal, were Miller looks his best on the lead around midfield. Both aren't that good in a contested Mark, as stated Miller wins as a Lead up CHF but Dunn is better at ground level and has goal sense. I post in my starting 22 for ST kilda that we play 2-3 HHF and for fo the traditional CHF because we don't have one.

Robbo, Bate, Bruce accross HFF with the late Bruce and Bate playing more a a midfielder role that works to become the link between coming out of defense and setting up attack. If we need a strong presents upfield let Neitz gat out to CHF5-10min per quater and send Robbo to the leading FF role. I suggest that we play Bate like O'Keefe from Sydney, someone suggest that it works for Sydney because thay play on the small SCG, IMO it will work on the larger grounds because you have super fit tall midfielders playing this role not many tall defenders will be able to run with Bate/Bruce.

The defenders may not run with them and zone off, bad move Bate can kick 55-60m and if you leave him loose he will carve them up and Bruce has the footy brain to do the same, no AFL coach will leave Bruce by himself he can all so kick bags of goals on his day.

I think we are all looking for the J Brown, Carey type we don't have one so we need to find what suites th MFC.

Link to comment
Share on other sites


What about Neita to CHF? I know it has been tried in the past with minimal success, but it was only really used as a stop-gap. Maybe he could play an old-fashioned CHF role (Carey-like), staying around the 50, as opposed to the Tredrea, Miller type which relies on hard running to present on the wing. The reason that I suggest this is that we do have cover for him at FF. Obviously not as effective as Neita, but we could fill his presence in the square with Jamar or even Miller (teach him to kick first), and play Robbo permanently deep as well to add to the aerial threat. Rotate Green and Bruce through the forward line to present on the lead, and ensure Davey stays inside 50 (and probably Yze as well because surely the motivation of a few goals could fire him up) and we'd have a relatively well balanced forward line, that is still fairly potent, whilst ensuring a presence at CHF to straighten us up.

Comments?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Unfortunately, your content contains terms that we do not allow. Please edit your content to remove the highlighted words below.
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Demonland Forums  

  • Match Previews, Reports & Articles  

    2024 Player Reviews: #31 Bayley Fritsch

    Once again the club’s top goal scorer but he had a few uncharacteristic flat spots during the season and the club will be looking for much better from him in 2025. Date of Birth: 6 December 1996 Height: 188cm Games MFC 2024: 23 Career Total: 149 Goals MFC 2024: 41 Career Total: 252 Brownlow Medal Votes: 4

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Melbourne Demons 8

    2024 Player Reviews: #18 Jake Melksham

    After sustaining a torn ACL in the final match of the 2023 season Jake added a bit to the attack late in the 2024 season upon his return. He has re-signed on to the Demons for 1 more season in 2025. Date of Birth: 12 August 1991 Height: 186cm Games MFC 2024: 8 Career Total: 229 Goals MFC 2024: 8 Career Total: 188

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Melbourne Demons 5

    2024 Player Reviews: #3 Christian Salem

    The luckless Salem suffered a hamstring injury against the Lions early in the season and, after missing a number of games, he was never at his best. He was also inconvenienced by minor niggles later in the season. This was a blow for the club that sorely needed him to fill gaps in the midfield at times as well as to do his best work in defence. Date of Birth: 15 July 1995 Height: 184cm Games MFC 2024: 17 Career Total: 176 Goals MFC 2024: 1 Career Total: 26 Brownlow Meda

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Melbourne Demons 7

    2024 Player Reviews: #39 Koltyn Tholstrop

    The first round draft pick at #13 from twelve months ago the strongly built medium forward has had an impressive introduction to AFL football and is expected to spend more midfield moments as his career progresses. Date of Birth: 25 July 2005 Height: 186cm Games MFC 2024: 10 Career Total: 10 Goals MFC 2024: 5 Career Total: 5 Games CDFC 2024: 7 Goals CDFC 2024: 4

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Melbourne Demons 6

    2024 Player Reviews: #42 Daniel Turner

    The move of “Disco” to a key forward post looks like bearing fruit. Turner has good hands, moves well and appears to be learning the forward craft well. Will be an interesting watch in 2025. Date of Birth: January 28, 2002 Height: 195cm Games MFC 2024: 15 Career Total: 18 Goals MFC 2024: 17 Career Total: 17 Games CDFC 2024: 1 Goals CDFC 2024:  1

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Melbourne Demons 15

    2024 Player Reviews: #8 Jake Lever

    The Demon’s key defender and backline leader had his share of injuries and niggles throughout the season which prevented him from performing at his peak.  Date of Birth: 5 March 1996 Height: 195cm Games MFC 2024: 18 Career Total: 178 Goals MFC 2024: 1 Career Total: 5

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Melbourne Demons 1

    2024 Player Reviews: #13 Clayton Oliver

    Lack of preparation after a problematic preseason prevented Oliver from reaching the high standards set before last year’s hamstring woes. He carried injury right through the back half of the season and was controversially involved in a potential move during the trade period that was ultimately shut down by the club. Date of Birth:  22 July 1997 Height:  189cm Games MFC 2024:  21 Career Total: 183 Goals MFC 2024: 3 Career Total: 54 Brownlow Medal Votes: 5

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Melbourne Demons 17

    BLOODY BLUES by Meggs

    The conclusion to Narrm’s home and away season was the inevitable let down by the bloody Blues  who meekly capitulated to the Bombers.   The 2024 season fixture handicapped the Demons chances from the get-go with Port Adelaide, Brisbane and Essendon advantaged with enough gimme games to ensure a tough road to the finals, especially after a slew of early season injuries to star players cost wins and percentage.     As we strode confidently through the gates of Prin

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Melbourne Demons 3

    2024 Player Reviews: #5 Christian Petracca

    Melbourne’s most important player who dominated the first half of the season until his untimely injury in the Kings Birthday clash put an end to his season. At the time, he was on his way to many personal honours and the club in strong finals contention. When the season did end for Melbourne and Petracca was slowly recovering, he was engulfed in controversy about a possible move of clubs amid claims about his treatment by the club in the immediate aftermath of his injury. Date of Birth: 4 J

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Melbourne Demons 21
  • Tell a friend

    Love Demonland? Tell a friend!
×
×
  • Create New...