2 hours ago, spirit of norm smith said:

I agree with negatives

I agree with positive for Gawn Viney Harmes

but but but

Hogan !! No way. Half hearted.  Appealed for frees. Two soft free kicks for goals. No contested marks. Missed a goal in the last. Going at the ball one handed. At least 4 slipped missed tackles

Salem also well down 

No Fritsch?? His class was apparent

Fritsch was good Norm and certainly if i watched the replay i might change my view.

From where i am sittingbehind punt road goals i missed much of the play up the other end so my votes probably lack accuracy and clarity at times.

I just saw Hulk as doing what was expected (mostly in the 2nd half) and getting back to something resembling a CHF role.  Regardless of how they were presented him he did kick 3.  Missed a few tackles yes but also thought he brought a bit of pressure inside 50 with some tackles that stuck (probably the only one of any note) and got himself involved in a fair number of chains around the ground that also resulted in us scoring.   His handballs away from congestion to players free was also pretty accurate vs others who seemed to be selling their team mates into trouble a fair bit resulting in a stack of ruined transitions and too many turnovers.

Edited July 1, 20186 yr by Rusty Nails

Hogan needs to lift.  He cannot just throw his hands up and expect free kicks.

Bottom line from today is that he kicked one goal , missed another crucial shot in the last and was gifted two goals.  He needs a crumber like Garlett or Spargo to help.

It will come as no surprise that Maxy got full marks for his inspirational performance yesterday. Truth be told, nobody else came close to the mark with his influence on the game (unless you include the three blind mice who officiated)

126. Max Gawn
106. Clayton OIiver
90. Jesse Hogan
70. Nathan Jones
62. Angus Brayshaw
49. Tom McDonald
46. Neville Jetta
35. Christian Salem 
34. Bayley Fritsch
33. Jake Melksham 
32. Jack Viney
31. Michael Hibberd
29. Jake Lever Oscar McDonald
26. James Harmes Christian Petracca 
20. Jordan Lewis
16. Jeff Garlett 
7. Alex Neal-Bullen
6. Tom Bugg 
4.  Joel Smith
2. Dean Kent
1. Bernie Vince Josh Wagner

		PLAYER	VOTES
1		Max Gawn	126
2		Clayton Oliver	106
3		Jesse Hogan	90
4		Nathan Jones	70
5		Angus Brayshaw	62
6		Tom McDoanld	49
7		Neville Jetta	46
8		Christian Salem	35
9		Bayley Fritsch	34
10		Jake Melksham	33
11		Jack Viney	32
12		Michael Hibberd	31
13		Jake Lever	29
13		Oscar McDoanld	29
15		Christian Petracca	26
15		James Harmes	26
17		Jordan Lewis	20
18		Jeff Garlett	16
19		Alex Neal-Bullen	7
20		Tomas Bugg	6
21		Joel Smith	4
22		Dean Kent	2
23		Bernie Vince	1
23		Josh Wagner	1

6 - Gawn

5 - Harmes

4 - Fritsch

3 - Viney

2 - Hibberd

1 - Gus

Hannan & ANB need a rest at Casey but not sure who comes in, should have played Frosty.

4 hours ago, Demonland said:

It will come as no surprise that Maxy got full marks for his inspirational performance yesterday. Truth be told, nobody else came close to the mark with his influence on the game (unless you include the three blind mice who officiated)

???

18 hours ago, Earl Hood said:

6. Gawn

5. Fritsch

4. Hibberd

3. Harmes

2. Jones

1. Brayshaw

This (saves me typing)