CASEY SCORPIONS v WILLIAMSTOWN

[Whispering_Jack 29,759]

1 hour ago, Nasher said:

Most of those players either haven't played much for Casey lately or have been bit parts. The only players they will miss are ANB (assuming he is the MFC emergency) and possibly OMac. The core of the side that annihilated Frankston and Collingwood is still there - I can't see any justification for Williamstown being favourites over the side on top of the ladder with 300%.

I can.

Firstly, Williamstown is the reigning premier. It lost last week to the previous season's premier Box Hill Hawks and in all likelihood would have been sitting undefeated with a percentage of over 300 had it played the opposition Casey has faced in its small sample of two games.

Secondly, history says that when less than half of the Casey team is comprised of MFC players, it struggles. In round 1, Casey had 16 Demons and the number was down to 14 last week. After seemingly being well off for injured players earlier in the week it was disappointing to learn we would be down to a maximum of 11 against a strong side like Williamstown. 

Thirdly, you can't downgrade the quality of the missing players. They are all AFL listed and will have to be replaced by kids coming up from the development league, many of them being smaller and lighter-bodied. 

Fourthly, I saw what Williamstown can do, albeit in a practice match earlier in the year. Despite being a stand alone side with no current AFL listed players, they do have a good number of former AFL players who have big bodies and used their greater physical strength in that game to wear down Casey's young, inexperienced team. Casey led a quarter time with three goals, kicked one goal in the second and lost control of the match and failed to kick a goal at all in the second half to lose by ten. They had 11 MFC players in the team that day and most of them were monstered by the opposition. The exceptions IMO were Jayden Hunt and Heritier Lumumba who are now playing for the Demons (in fact, when I raved a bit about Hunt's potential in that game, I copped some flak for saying so). 

Finally, Casey struggled in the ruck. It did best last year when it had Mark Jamar and Jake Spencer - neither of them are playing tonight and that spells trouble for tonight's game. The Scorpions need Jake back ASAP.

[MadAsHell 4,212]

10 minutes ago, Whispering_Jack said:

I can.

Firstly, Williamstown is the reigning premier. It lost last week to the previous season's premier Box Hill Hawks and in all likelihood would have been sitting undefeated with a percentage of over 300 had it played the opposition Casey has faced in its small sample of two games.

Secondly, history says that when less than half of the Casey team is comprised of MFC players, it struggles. In round 1, Casey had 16 Demons and the number was down to 14 last week. After seemingly being well off for injured players earlier in the week it was disappointing to learn we would be down to a maximum of 11 against a strong side like Williamstown. 

Thirdly, you can't downgrade the quality of the missing players. They are all AFL listed and will have to be replaced by kids coming up from the development league, many of them being smaller and lighter-bodied. 

Fourthly, I saw what Williamstown can do, albeit in a practice match earlier in the year. Despite being a stand alone side with no current AFL listed players, they do have a good number of former AFL players who have big bodies and used their greater physical strength in that game to wear down Casey's young, inexperienced team. Casey led a quarter time with three goals, kicked one goal in the second and lost control of the match and failed to kick a goal at all in the second half to lose by ten. They had 11 MFC players in the team that day and most of them were monstered by the opposition. The exceptions IMO were Jayden Hunt and Heritier Lumumba who are now playing for the Demons (in fact, when I raved a bit about Hunt's potential in that game, I copped some flak for saying so). 

Finally, Casey struggled in the ruck. It did best last year when it had Mark Jamar and Jake Spencer - neither of them are playing tonight and that spells trouble for tonight's game. The Scorpions need Jake back ASAP.

Good news is that if Casey & Melbourne can get through injury/suspension free then there could be up to 18 Melbourne listed players available next week.

The mystery absentees Dawes, Stretch & Smith plus Oliver, M. Jones, Oscar and Spencer could all also be available for selection.

Scorpions in a close one tonight for mine.

[MadAsHell 4,212]

Also think you've undersold Collingwood's VFL team WJ. Pretty sure most media outlets had them as top 4 at the start of the year. Below as an example.

http://www.theage.com.au/afl/vfl/vfl-2016-your-guide-to-the-year-ahead-20160401-gnw1fa.html

Edited April 23, 2016 by AngryAtCasey

[CBDees 3,167]

17 minutes ago, AngryAtCasey said:

Good news is that if Casey & Melbourne can get through injury/suspension free then there could be up to 18 Melbourne listed players available next week.

The mystery absentees Dawes, Stretch & Smith plus Oliver, M. Jones, Oscar and Spencer could all also be available for selection.

Scorpions in a close one tonight for mine.

Does anyone know where/when we can see the final team lineup for Casey now that Melbourne has finalised theirs?

[MadAsHell 4,212]

5 minutes ago, CBDees said:

Does anyone know where/when we can see the final team lineup for Casey now that Melbourne has finalised theirs?

Scorpions twitter accont may be best bet, unless KC knows of anything else?

[CBDees 3,167]

15 minutes ago, AngryAtCasey said:

Scorpions twitter accont may be best bet, unless KC knows of anything else?

Thanks. Stretch and Smith are two that I was wondering about.

[Bonkers 994]

Am I right in assuming that the VFL free to air games won't be shown until round 4? If so its pretty [censored] poor by channel 7. They were supposedly championing their promotion of the local game when purchasing the TV rights. I preferred the abc at least you knew a game would be broadcast every Saturday afternoon.

[boydie 655]

1 hour ago, Bonkers said:

Am I right in assuming that the VFL free to air games won't be shown until round 4? If so its pretty [censored] poor by channel 7. They were supposedly championing their promotion of the local game when purchasing the TV rights. I preferred the abc at least you knew a game would be broadcast every Saturday afternoon.

Not sure what the actual deal is but they've shown a game on 7 for at least the last 2 weeks.

They show a Sunday game now rather than a Saturday.

[Samael 560]

On 4/21/2016 at 9:34 PM, bjDee said:

Keilty and Max King. Keilty copped a head knock last week so we were short of a ruckman occasionally.  I saw Hulett shape up to ruck at one stage before being relieved by Keilty returning to the fray with head in a bandage. 

Keep your eye on McInerney. Looks pretty capable and isn't far off playing in the firsts. Wont be surprised if he plays tonight.

[Samael 560]

5 hours ago, Nasher said:

Most of those players either haven't played much for Casey lately or have been bit parts. The only players they will miss are ANB (assuming he is the MFC emergency) and possibly OMac. The core of the side that annihilated Frankston and Collingwood is still there - I can't see any justification for Williamstown being favourites over the side on top of the ladder with 300%.

Willy smashed Casey in a practice match. Very good side. 

[KC from Casey 7,057]

1 hour ago, Samael said:

Willy smashed Casey in a practice match. Very good side. 

Agreed. Underestimate Williamstown at your own peril.

Meantime, the Development League game is under way and it's a close contest as it was when they last met here in the practice match.

Casey lead 3.3.21 to 3.1.19 at QT but Willi has the advantage of the breeze coming up. Ed Morris is playing a great game and is clearly in contention for a senior berth in his comeback from injury.

[KC from Casey 7,057]

Sensational news in another game down by the bay. Frankston seniors who Casey thumped by 24 goals just two weeks ago have gotten up to beat the Richmond Tigers. 

Their first win since July 2014. 

[What 18,810]

39 minutes ago, KC from Casey said:

Sensational news in another game down by the bay. Frankston seniors who Casey thumped by 24 goals just two weeks ago have gotten up to beat the Richmond Tigers. 

Their first win since July 2014. 

haha brilliant., Tigers a rabble from top to bottom

[La Dee-vina Comedia 16,687]

4 minutes ago, KC from Casey said:

Sensational news in another game down by the bay. Frankston seniors who Casey thumped by 24 goals just two weeks ago have gotten up to beat the Richmond Tigers. 

I wonder how many and who of the Tigers' emergencies played in that game. If Deledio is in any way doubtful, you'd think they might need to keep 2 emergencies up their sleeves for tomorrow night.

[Whispering_Jack 29,759]

Sounds like trouble in the Tiger camp.

[What 18,810]

20 minutes ago, La Dee-vina Comedia said:

I wonder how many and who of the Tigers' emergencies played in that game. If Deledio is in any way doubtful, you'd think they might need to keep 2 emergencies up their sleeves for tomorrow night.

Taylor Hunt didnt play. If he replaces Deledio Richmond effectively have 21 players.

[KC from Casey 7,057]

Half Time: Williamstown 9.5.59 to Casey 5.4.34

Scorps outplayed and lacked a bit of discipline giving away some costly frees in front of the opposition goal plus a 50m penalty.

[Whispering_Jack 29,759]

16 minutes ago, Petraccattack said:

 

Taylor Hunt didnt play. If he replaces Deledio Richmond effectively have 21 players.

I wouldn't get too excited. He's probably the emergency.

[Adam The God 30,112]

Does anyone know if Petracca is playing tonight? I'm thinking about heading down. 

[Whispering_Jack 29,759]

2 minutes ago, AdamFarr said:

Does anyone know if Petracca is playing tonight? I'm thinking about heading down. 

It's pretty safe to drive down. I can't see them making Petracca the emergency for tomorrow if they reckon he needs more time at Casey.

[Adam The God 30,112]

7 minutes ago, Whispering_Jack said:

It's pretty safe to drive down. I can't see them making Petracca the emergency for tomorrow if they reckon he needs more time at Casey.

Thanks Jack.

[KC from Casey 7,057]

The lights are on and the young Scorpions are struggling to make up the leeway.

I hope that plenty of Demon fans make it down tonight and provide comments. Apart from anything else, I need to conserve my battery power.

[Whispering_Jack 29,759]

2 minutes ago, KC from Casey said:

The lights are on and the young Scorpions are struggling to make up the leeway.

I hope that plenty of Demon fans make it down tonight and provide comments. Apart from anything else, I need to conserve my battery power.

Car or phone?

[KC from Casey 7,057]

3 minutes ago, Whispering_Jack said:

Car or phone?

Ha ha

[KC from Casey 7,057]

After allowing Willi to sneak away to a 36 point lead early in the quarter, Casey fought back but trail by 17 points at the final break - 9.7.61 to 12.6.78.