Jump to content

The South Australians - why have they gone missing?


Whispering_Jack

Recommended Posts

South Australia has been strong in the AFL Under 18 National Championships in recent years but they haven't produced a proportionate number of draft picks. This year the Croweaters won the Division 1 championship and were far and away the best team - I think they might have lost just one game after all teams played each other twice.

They must have been a champion team rather than a team of champions because their players don't seem to rate among three of the best Phantom Draft gurus on bigfooty:-

KNIGHTMARE

1. St Kilda - Christian Petracca Eastern Ranges

2. Melbourne - Angus Brayshaw Sandringhan Dragons

3. Greater Western Sydney Jake Lever Calder Cannons

4. Brisbane - Patrick McCartin Geelong Falcons

5. Western Bulldogs Peter Wright Calder Cannons

6. Carlton - Sam Durdin West Adelaide

7. Gold Coast Jayden Laverde Western Jets

8. Collingwood Darcy Moore Oakleigh Chargers

9. Adelaide Jarrod Pickett South Fremantle

10. West Coast Paul Ahern Calder Cannons

11. Richmond Liam Duggan Western Jets

12. Fremantle - Caleb Marchbank Murray Bushrangers

13. Geelong Hugh Goddard Geelong Falcons

14. Gold Coast Lachlan Weller Broadbeach

15. North Melbourne Connor Menadue Western Jets

16. Port Adelaide Jordan De Goey Oakleigh Chargers

17 Hawthorn Connor Blakely Swan Districts

18. Sydney Isaac Heeney Cardiff

19. Essendon Peter Bampton Norwood

20. Greater Western Sydney - Corey Ellis Western Jets

CHRIS 25

1. St Kilda - Christian Petracca Eastern Ranges

2. Melbourne - Angus Brayshaw Sandringhan Dragons

3. Greater Western Sydney - Jake Lever Calder Cannons

4. Brisbane - Patrick McCartin Geelong Falcons

5. Western Bulldogs - Peter Wright Calder Cannons

6. Carlton - Lachie Weller Broadbeach

7. Gold Coast - Jordan DeGoey Oakleigh Chargers

8. Collingwood - Darcy Moore Oakleigh Chargers

9. Adelaide - Jayden Laverde Western Jets

10. West Coast - Jarrod Pickett South Fremantle

11. Richmond - Hugh Goddard Geelong Falcons

12. Fremantle - Sam Durdin West Adelaide

13. Geelong - Jack Steele Belconnen

14. Gold Coast - Paul Ahern Calder Cannons

15. North Melbourne - Liam Duggan Western Jets

16. Port Adelaide - Tom Lamb Dandenong Stingrays

17. Hawthorn - Kyle Langford Northern Knights

18. Sydney - Isaac Heeney Cardiff

19. Essendon - Jackson Nelson Geelong Falcons

20. Greater Western Sydney - Josh Glenn Central Districts

PAIGE CARDONA

1. St. Kilda Christian Petracca Eastern Ranges

2. Melbourne Angus Brayshaw Sandringham Dragons

3. Greater Western Sydney - Jake Lever Calder Cannons

4. Brisbane - Patrick McCartin Geelong Falcons

5. Western Bulldogs Peter Wright Calder Cannons

6. Carlton Sam Durdin West Adelaide

7. Gold Coast Jayden Laverde Western Jets

8. Collingwood Darcy Moore Oakleigh Chargers

9. Adelaide Hugh Goddard Geelong Falcons

10. West Coast Jarrod Pickett South Fremantle

11. Richmond Paul Ahern Calder Cannons

12. North Melbourne Caleb Marchbank Murray Bushrangers

13. Port Adelaide Liam Duggan Western Jets

14. Geelong Kyle Langford Northern Knights

15. Gold Coast Lachie Weller Broadbeach

16. Fremantle Jordan De Goey Oakleigh Chargers

17. Sydney Isaac Heeney Cardiff

18. Hawthorn Corey Ellis Western Jets

19. Essendon Jackson Nelson Geelong Falcons

20. Greater Western Sydney Brayden Maynard Sandringham Dragons

Only Sam Durdin, a highly rated tall KFP player makes it into all three phantom drafts. Peter Bampton and Josh Glenn each make it as late draft picks in only one phantom draft.

Do any keen draft watchers have an explanation for the anomaly? Are our draft experts too Victoria-centric and are there some bargains available here because the recruiters might hold similar views.

[note: Billy Stretch would also be expected to be close to 20 by some but due to the father son nomination, he's been slotted in by Knightmare and Chris25 as going on the second round and by Paige as a third rounder.]

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I looked up the 2014 NAB AFL U18 All Australian team and found very few from SA and certainly far fewer than the number you would normally expect from the national champions:-

Defenders:

Harrison Wigg (South Australia), Ed Vickers-Willis (VIC- Metro/Sandringham Dragons), Josh McGuinness (Tasmania), Darcy Tucker (Vic Country/North Ballarat Rebels), Caleb Marchbank (Vic Country/Murray Bushrangers), Angus Brayshaw (Vic Metro/Sandringham Dragons)

Midfield:

Paul Ahern (Vic Metro/Calder Cannons), Christian Petracca (Vic Metro/Eastern Ranges), Peter Wright (Vic Metro/Calder Cannons), Isaac Heeney (NSW/ACT), Jake Johansen (South Australia), Billy Stretch (South Australia)

Forwards:

Callum Mills (NSW/ACT), Darcy Moore (Vic Metro/Oakleigh Chargers), Rhys Mathieson (Vic Country/Geelong Falcons), Jayden Laverde (Vic Metro/Western Jets), Patrick McCartin (Vic Country/Geelong Falcons), Caleb Daniel (South Australia)

Interchange:

Connor Blakely (Western Australia), Ben Keays (Queensland), Darcy Parish (Vic Country/Geelong Falcons), Jack Steele (NSW/ACT)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Do any keen draft watchers have an explanation for the anomaly? Are our draft experts too Victoria-centric and are there some bargains available here because the recruiters might hold similar views.

As I've said on another thread, I rate Gore. I reckon he beat Petracca around the stoppages in the champs. I'm surprised he is not rated higher and think he will be a good get for some club, I hope it's us.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Only Sam Durdin, a highly rated tall KFP player makes it into all three phantom drafts. Peter Bampton and Josh Glenn each make it as late draft picks in only one phantom draft.

Do any keen draft watchers have an explanation for the anomaly? Are our draft experts too Victoria-centric and are there some bargains available here because the recruiters might hold similar views.

[note: Billy Stretch would also be expected to be close to 20 by some but due to the father son nomination, he's been slotted in by Knightmare and Chris25 as going on the second round and by Paige as a third rounder.]

Knightmare has Billy Stretch as the 13th best player in the draft WJ, his power rankings are below his mock draft

2014 draft power rankings:

-- High level difference makers --

1. Christian Petracca (VIC Mid/Fwd)

2. Angus Brayshaw (VIC Mid)

3. Isaac Heeney (Syd Academy - NSW Mid)

4. Patrick McCartin (VIC - KPF)

5. Darcy Moore (Coll - F/S VIC KPF/KPD)

6. Peter Wright (VIC - KPF/Ruck)

7. Sam Durdin (SA KPD/KPF)

8. Jake Lever (VIC KPD)

9. Hugh Goddard (VIC KPD/KPF)

10. Jarrod Pickett (WA Mid)

-- Capable contributors --

11. Peter Bampton (SA Mid)

12. Lachlan Weller (QLD Util)

13. Billy Stretch (Melb F/S - SA Mid)

14. Connon Blakely (WA Mid)

15. Caleb Marchbank (VIC KPD)

16. Oscar McDonald (VIC KPD)

17. Connor Menadue (VIC Mid)

18. Jayden Laverde (VIC Util)

19. Alex Neal-Bullen (SA Mid)

20. Dean Gore (SA Mid/Fwd)

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 3 weeks later...

Chris25 posted this on Bigfooty in June and it basically answers my question about why SA players are not rated individually in the Phantom Drafts despite (now) being the championship state team:-

As the old saying goes, a champion team will beat a team of champions.

For starters, the SA U18 program is far better than the Victorian ones. From top to bottom, our players are more physically ready for AFL football. They train and prepare that way. And more importantly, they play that way. Brenton Phillips is a very good coach, and prepares them for what lies ahead - whereas at times the TAC Cup compares to Auskick, with the way players run free and the best players are always put in positions to succeed. It's no real surprise that when the pressure kicks up a gear, it's the South Australians who are able to handle it.

And they pick a side to win, as opposed to just the 22 most talented players. Guys like Bower and Watchman are two of the more talented players from SA, but didn't immediately fit the team structures and had to wait their turn. And because of the more disciplined and defined playing style, it means these lesser known but physically more developed players have success.

So why are SA winning? They're stronger, better coached and more disciplined.

Why aren't they going to be the first 22 picks in the draft? Well, they're just not the most purely talented players around. Some of the Victorians are the better players, they just happen to play in a worse side. They have a lot of taller midfielders, and generally 'sexier' players. But talent alone doesn't win games.

I've got a whole thread devoted to South Australians, and I'll talk them up forever. Caleb Daniel and Jake Johansen are super players, but are just so tiny. As good as they are, they're not going top 20. Dean Gore, Peter Bampton, Brad Coulson, Alex Neal Bullen and Cory Gregson are all very good, strong inside midfielders. But they aren't the players a recruiter is going to sell the farm for. They're nice to haves, not must haves - typically these guys will go anywhere from the top of the second round to third/fourth round to potentially rookies. Harrison Wigg, Declan Hamilton and James Rose have all had great U18 Championships, but that doesn't automatically make them first round picks - I could see them all jumping into the top 30, but they also have question marks and limitations. Jack Hayes, Keenan Ramsay and Callum Wilkie have been really solid KPPs in every game, but they're not the talls that you'll be building a side around. I could list another 10 or so players who have a very good chance of getting drafted - Ethan Haylock being one, who I think Knightmare may have sold a little short.

It's also worth noting that some of the best players for South Australia have been underaged players - Ryan Burton is shaping as a top 5 pick next year. Aaron Francis, Luke Partington, Stephen Tahana and Tim Sullivan have also all played well and should be looked at as early picks. That's arguably where the talent is hiding, while the 18 year olds are doing their roles.

SA should go back to back. But when it comes draft time, you're picking individuals not a team.

Quite simple and straight-forward really.

Link to comment
Share on other sites


  • 4 weeks later...

Seven days before draft day the media realises that SA appears underrepresented at the top end of the draft.

SA's first round drought

I asked the question at last week's MFC draft info night and Jason Taylor agreed that while SA was extremely well coached, it was a team that was was very even in ability and didn't have as many outstanding players as the two Victorian teams in the national carnival. On top of that, they tended to select some players who would do well at this level but might not have the attributes necessary to go further. I got the impression that this was a reference to the likes of pocket sized Caleb Daniel who starred in the champs but most pundits are suggesting might only get picked in the rookie draft.

Taylor did suggest that there were a few players from SA who might come into contention when our selection at #40 comes around.

  • Like 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

pre the Frawley compensation pick

All of the draft orders have changed now too. Lever has dropped to 6-12 in most phantoms, and McCartin is tipped to go at three in almost every one. Wright's stock has dropped too.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Seven days before draft day the media realises that SA appears underrepresented at the top end of the draft.

SA's first round drought

I asked the question at last week's MFC draft info night and Jason Taylor agreed that while SA was extremely well coached, it was a team that was was very even in ability and didn't have as many outstanding players as the two Victorian teams in the national carnival. On top of that, they tended to select some players who would do well at this level but might not have the attributes necessary to go further. I got the impression that this was a reference to the likes of pocket sized Caleb Daniel who starred in the champs but most pundits are suggesting might only get picked in the rookie draft.

Taylor did suggest that there were a few players from SA who might come into contention when our selection at #40 comes around.

Looks like you were ahead of the game on this one 'Jack' as with many issues.

Hopefully we have another SA kid join Stretch in the 40's...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Unfortunately, your content contains terms that we do not allow. Please edit your content to remove the highlighted words below.
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Demonland Forums  

  • Match Previews, Reports & Articles  

    2024 Player Reviews: #31 Bayley Fritsch

    Once again the club’s top goal scorer but he had a few uncharacteristic flat spots during the season and the club will be looking for much better from him in 2025. Date of Birth: 6 December 1996 Height: 188cm Games MFC 2024: 23 Career Total: 149 Goals MFC 2024: 41 Career Total: 252 Brownlow Medal Votes: 4

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Melbourne Demons 8

    2024 Player Reviews: #18 Jake Melksham

    After sustaining a torn ACL in the final match of the 2023 season Jake added a bit to the attack late in the 2024 season upon his return. He has re-signed on to the Demons for 1 more season in 2025. Date of Birth: 12 August 1991 Height: 186cm Games MFC 2024: 8 Career Total: 229 Goals MFC 2024: 8 Career Total: 188

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Melbourne Demons 5

    2024 Player Reviews: #3 Christian Salem

    The luckless Salem suffered a hamstring injury against the Lions early in the season and, after missing a number of games, he was never at his best. He was also inconvenienced by minor niggles later in the season. This was a blow for the club that sorely needed him to fill gaps in the midfield at times as well as to do his best work in defence. Date of Birth: 15 July 1995 Height: 184cm Games MFC 2024: 17 Career Total: 176 Goals MFC 2024: 1 Career Total: 26 Brownlow Meda

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Melbourne Demons 8

    2024 Player Reviews: #39 Koltyn Tholstrop

    The first round draft pick at #13 from twelve months ago the strongly built medium forward has had an impressive introduction to AFL football and is expected to spend more midfield moments as his career progresses. Date of Birth: 25 July 2005 Height: 186cm Games MFC 2024: 10 Career Total: 10 Goals MFC 2024: 5 Career Total: 5 Games CDFC 2024: 7 Goals CDFC 2024: 4

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Melbourne Demons 6

    2024 Player Reviews: #42 Daniel Turner

    The move of “Disco” to a key forward post looks like bearing fruit. Turner has good hands, moves well and appears to be learning the forward craft well. Will be an interesting watch in 2025. Date of Birth: January 28, 2002 Height: 195cm Games MFC 2024: 15 Career Total: 18 Goals MFC 2024: 17 Career Total: 17 Games CDFC 2024: 1 Goals CDFC 2024:  1

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Melbourne Demons 15

    2024 Player Reviews: #8 Jake Lever

    The Demon’s key defender and backline leader had his share of injuries and niggles throughout the season which prevented him from performing at his peak.  Date of Birth: 5 March 1996 Height: 195cm Games MFC 2024: 18 Career Total: 178 Goals MFC 2024: 1 Career Total: 5

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Melbourne Demons 1

    2024 Player Reviews: #13 Clayton Oliver

    Lack of preparation after a problematic preseason prevented Oliver from reaching the high standards set before last year’s hamstring woes. He carried injury right through the back half of the season and was controversially involved in a potential move during the trade period that was ultimately shut down by the club. Date of Birth:  22 July 1997 Height:  189cm Games MFC 2024:  21 Career Total: 183 Goals MFC 2024: 3 Career Total: 54 Brownlow Medal Votes: 5

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Melbourne Demons 20

    BLOODY BLUES by Meggs

    The conclusion to Narrm’s home and away season was the inevitable let down by the bloody Blues  who meekly capitulated to the Bombers.   The 2024 season fixture handicapped the Demons chances from the get-go with Port Adelaide, Brisbane and Essendon advantaged with enough gimme games to ensure a tough road to the finals, especially after a slew of early season injuries to star players cost wins and percentage.     As we strode confidently through the gates of Prin

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Melbourne Demons 3

    2024 Player Reviews: #5 Christian Petracca

    Melbourne’s most important player who dominated the first half of the season until his untimely injury in the Kings Birthday clash put an end to his season. At the time, he was on his way to many personal honours and the club in strong finals contention. When the season did end for Melbourne and Petracca was slowly recovering, he was engulfed in controversy about a possible move of clubs amid claims about his treatment by the club in the immediate aftermath of his injury. Date of Birth: 4 J

    Demonland
    Demonland |
    Melbourne Demons 21
  • Tell a friend

    Love Demonland? Tell a friend!
×
×
  • Create New...