Some have been iffy but Fyfe is still dirty.

The day of the dirty footballer is dead and buried - everything gets picked up on camera now

Fyfe dirty ...seriously...

I don't see why anybody cares about the AA side......It rates with Mike's top 50 in the HS.....for me anyway......I couldn't care less

I don't see why anybody cares about the AA side......It rates with Mike's top 50 in the HS.....for me anyway......I couldn't care less

I bet your interest will increase as we rise up the ladder Bossdog.

The day of the dirty footballer is dead and buried - everything gets picked up on camera now

Fyfe dirty ...seriously...

In Today's game he is dirty.

In Today's game he is dirty.

please stop.

Nathan Jones not named in AA 40?

Nor should he be.

A very good ordinary B-grader, with an A-grade attitude and work-ethic.

Doesn't make him an A-grader though.

please stop.

Never.

Nathan Jones not named in AA 40?

Nor should he be.

A very good ordinary B-grader, with an A-grade attitude and work-ethic.

Doesn't make him an A-grader though.

You'll be burnt at the stake around here for such comments.

I love Jonesy as much as the next Melbourne fan. A star who will end his career being one of the club's all-time greats. But he's a good player in a bad team. If he were as good as people say he is, we wouldn't be drooling over the prospect of Dangerfield coming to the Dees.

He's been the only player from 2008-2012 who has been a genuine treat to watch every single week. He bleeds red and blue.

You'll be burnt at the stake around here for such comments.

I love Jonesy as much as the next Melbourne fan. A star who will end his career being one of the club's all-time greats. But he's a good player in a bad team. If he were as good as people say he is, we wouldn't be drooling over the prospect of Dangerfield coming to the Dees.

He's been the only player from 2008-2012 who has been a genuine treat to watch every single week. He bleeds red and blue.

pretty sure your the one who said if he was on Hawthorne list wouldn't be in best 22, so do you mean he would be all time great for Box Hill FC

pretty sure your the one who said if he was on Hawthorne list wouldn't be in best 22, so do you mean he would be all time great for Box Hill FC

I said he would struggle to make their top 22. Who in the midfield would come out in favour of Jones?

Comparatively, Melbourne is far, far below Hawthorn's best standard. Jones is a good player in a bad team. What makes you think he would walk into Hawthorn's side?

During the year when Melbourne gets flogged, everyone hyperventilates and says we don't have a single player that would get a game in a top 8 side. Why? Jones gets a very loose tag every game. He simply isn't damaging enough with the football.

Don't put words in my mouth and equate that to being, "Jones is not a good football". He's just nothing more than a good player in a bad side.

We need much more talent and depth in a midfield area already with Jones, Tyson, Vince and Viney. I think that's quite telling.

I'm just trying to rationalise why he isn't in the AA side. I don't think I'm the only one who thinks this.

Edited September 4, 201411 yr by praha

I said he would struggle to make their top 22. Who in the midfield would come out in favour of Jones?

Comparatively, Melbourne is far, far below Hawthorn's best standard. Jones is a good player in a bad team. What makes you think he would walk into Hawthorn's side?

During the year when Melbourne gets flogged, everyone hyperventilates and says we don't have a single player that would get a game in a top 8 side. Why? Jones gets a very loose tag every game. He simply isn't damaging enough with the football.

Don't put words in my mouth and equate that to being, "Jones is not a good football". He's just nothing more than a good player in a bad side.

We need much more talent and depth in a midfield area already with Jones, Tyson, Vince and Viney. I think that's quite telling.

I'm just trying to rationalise why he isn't in the AA side. I don't think I'm the only one who thinks this.

i dont understand they are your word's, struggle to make their top 22 & nothing more than a good player in a bad side, yet one of the clubs all time greats. how can he be both, thats what my post was about. What words have i put in your mouth.

Edited September 5, 201411 yr by budge

Are you [censored] tealeaf. Next you will suggest getting phobia crazed h.l from the pies. Cannot under the sh.t you write. You like to call natives of oz sunshine….another name for retard..

^^ classic

ENYAW hahahahhahahaha what a unit

Are you [censored] tealeaf. Next you will suggest getting phobia crazed h.l from the pies. Cannot under the sh.t you write. You like to call natives of oz sunshine….another name for retard..

My shitty day just got better.....classic

Ahh the inverted WAYNE