How are we paying 5.25 to 1.16 to win this? that is waaay too long! Richmond are 2-5 and 15th on the ladder, and we beat them in the pre-season!

Good point C&B, maybe Nasher and the mods could put a lazy gorilla or two from the donations kitty on a win!

Does anyone know what stats they use at the club ? Would love to know .

It would most likely explain for example why Byrnes gets games ahead of the more talented guys like Bleasey.

I heard the other day that Port use meters gained as a key indicater . Im sure the stats we see in the media are the tip of the iceberg.

My old man keeps on saying if Blease isn't picked this week he'll be [censored]. I keep saying to him, until Blease can string a number of consistent, two-way running games together, he won't be going anywhere.

Edited May 15, 201411 yr by AdamFarr

Your argument was that McKenzie was in the same category as Magner and Couch. You were stupid to say so and have failed to back up that statement.

Nobody is arguing that McKenzie is the "complete" footballer, just that he's much better than the two you mentioned. Nobody has said he'll stay on the list or make a career of AFL footy from this point.

But don't be stupid enough to ignore his achievements.

Your understanding of my 'argument' was that I put them in the same category.

You can do all the changing of words you like BB, but if you go back to my initial post, all I said was that McKenzie, like Magner, Couch and Valenti are one-trick ponies.

I am ignoring his avhievments because they have nothing to do with what I'm talking about. Which is the here and now.

Please shut up with the emotional fixation you have on the guy. It's clouded your view so much so that you misinterpret and make up what I'm arguing all because I don't value him as highly as you'd like me to. The end BB.

Edited May 15, 201411 yr by stevethemanjordan

One of the things that has hurt Jordie is that there seems to have been a movement in thinking in how to use him. Whereas before he was playing as inside mid/tagger, Neeld changed his role to a tagging wingman, shutting down players like Steele Sidebottom for example and now Roos seems to favour using better overall players like Grimes and Jones in more accountable head to head rather than sacrificial tagging sort of roles. Unfortunately for McKenzie, Cross is an extremely effective outside run-with player and has taken his spot. Had he not been playing im sure McKenzie would have been in and playing on Macrae.

Comparing McKenzie and Magner and Valenti is like comparing apples and oranges.

Magner and Valenti are ball hunting feeders, McKenzie is a negator.

Magner and Valenit are mediocre at their craft, McKenzie is quite good at his when given the chance. Like a lot of stoppers he is let down by skill deficiency, which is usually the reason taggers are given those roles.

Edited May 15, 201411 yr by goodoil

In: Riley, Gawn

Out: Frawley, Byrnes

Does anyone know what stats they use at the club ? Would love to know .

It would most likely explain for example why Byrnes gets games ahead of the more talented guys like Bleasey.

I heard the other day that Port use meters gained as a key indicater . Im sure the stats we see in the media are the tip of the iceberg.

I'm sure too that there are plenty of stats we don't see in the papers, drilled down versions of things.

There is no stat, though, that says Blease should be getting a game right now.

Pretty happy with the changes, congrats to Riley on his first game no doubt he's earned it.

Happy with the changes. A little stiff on Georgiou, but I'm glad to see Gawny get a run finally, even if I don't think he's entirely capable of holding down a permanent forward position just yet. Will be interesting to see how his chop-outs in the ruck compare to Pedders' who I think has played the role admirably in the last couple of weeks. Am happy with the backline as long as Grimesy stays in it this week.

Such a tragedy to see Byrnes out of the team. Best of luck Pigdog.

Disappointing that Frawley won't be playing. Interested to see Riley's first game for us.

Been waiting for the Dog. Ought to add a bit I think. Great appetite for the game, probably looking to add Tiger to the menu.