Our results match our draft picks!

[dees64 104]

An article by James Bett - MELBOURNE DEMONS WILL TAKE LONG ROAD TO REBUILDING

Feel sorry for Neeld, the previous coaching/recruiter need to be shot!

[olisik 4,060]

I am Neeld fan but Taggart and Tynan arn't exactly setting the world on fire either.

[Sir Why You Little 37,242]

Makes you wonder whether BP actually ran for his life out of this club when Neeld arrived.

[old dee 23,928]

Makes you wonder whether BP actually ran for his life out of this club when Neeld arrived.

Don't think there is any "wonder" about it wyl

[old dee 23,928]

I am Neeld fan but Taggart and Tynan arn't exactly setting the world on fire either.

I will let them off so far olisik

Injury again means "how the hell would you know".

[old dee 23,928]

Good Article dees64

Thanks for it

Seems to make a lot sense to me.

Especially the bit about the youth only policy

[olisik 4,060]

I will let them off so far olisik

Injury again means "how the hell would you know".

I am half expecting at least 3 years worth of injuries for them.

That way we cant blame them or embrace them. List clogging drafting at its finest.

[Range Rover 1,935]

There can be little doubt that the recruiting decisions made by Barry Prendergast - ratified by Dean Bailey - have played a massive part in bringing this club to its knees.

'Diabolical', the fella writing the article says. I agree.

[Sir Why You Little 37,242]

Such a shame we did not stand up to The Filth & draft Luke Ball.

[Johnny Karate 559]

I am Neeld fan but Taggart and Tynan arn't exactly setting the world on fire either.

You're right, absolute hacks. There were clearly better players available during that stage of the draft. Looks like BP stuffed it up again.

[old dee 23,928]

There can be little doubt that the recruiting decisions made by Barry Prendergast - ratified by Dean Bailey - have played a massive part in bringing this club to its knees.

'Diabolical', the fella writing the article says. I agree.

On this RR we are going to be in total agreement

[Range Rover 1,935]

Such a shame we did not stand up to The Filth & draft Luke Ball.

I was at that draft at the convention centre and happened to be sitting 10 ft away from Eddie.

He had a [censored]-eating grin from ear-to-ear when Melbourne's turn came and we didn't call out Ball's name. He knew he'd put one over us and had Ball in the bag (pardon the pun) as soon as that happened.

I agree. It was pi$$weak by the club ... a true reflection of the Bailey ethos.

[Range Rover 1,935]

On this RR we are going to be in total agreement

We can only hope that the new regime can right the ship in time OD, otherwise we may well be looking back on Prendergast/Bailey as the architects of our demise.

[Sir Why You Little 37,242]

I was at that draft at the convention centre and happened to be sitting 10 ft away from Eddie.

He had a [censored]-eating grin from ear-to-ear when Melbourne's turn came and we didn't call out Ball's name. He knew he'd put one over us and had Ball in the bag (pardon the pun) as soon as that happened.

I agree. It was pi$$weak by the club ... a true reflection of the Bailey ethos.

Course it was. Broke my heart. I knew he was going to be a GUN foot soldier. Who trains 8 hours a day. What that would have taught our list even before a game

[Sir Why You Little 37,242]

People talk about his lack of medical records...i mean really...we all knew the Filth were happy. We should have pounced.

[dees64 104]

I know hindsight is a great thing any most clubs have early picks that fail but WTF the MFC just continue to get it wrong & when you look at the top clubs they get more right than wrong!

In fairness Tapscott & Gysberts will be good but the other decisions with early picks is absolute disaster!

Edited July 24, 2012 by dees64

[Range Rover 1,935]

In fairness Tapscott & Gysberts will be good

Will they? I had early hopes but am still not sold on either.

Time is still on their side but as high draft picks they should be having no problem commanding a spot in the senior team.

As it is, both are currently fringe players.

[Whispering_Jack 30,957]

I disagree with the writer's analysis.

It's superficial and doesn't allow for the fact that different players have different rates of development particularly if they have, as is the case with many of Melbourne's recruits, not had the opportunity to show their wares yet because of prolonged periods out of the game through injury.

I accept that some of the choices haven't come up to expectations but there's plenty of room for development among a number of our young players. How many of these blokes have played their 50-60 games yet? How many have had the opportunity to take part in a full pre season?

As for Taggert and Tynan from the 2011 draft, one hasn't been able to get onto the field much at all this year but is highly regarded and hopefully will get his chances next year. The other (Tynan) will definitely be a footballer IMO.

[Clark_Kent 315]

This article is very true but it begs the question......what if we can get all these blokes on the park together at the same time?

If we can have Gysberts,Clark,Tapscott,Strauss,Blease,Taggert,Jurrah,Jetta actually playing some continuous games together

along with the rest of the team maybe we will see some improvement. As much as we have really struggled this season we have

been cruelly hampered with injuries to our younger players really slowing their development. This still gives me hope. If they had

all been playing every game and we were still at this point then I would be even more worried but the fact is we have one of the worst

injury lists in the AFL and being a young struggling side we pay for it even more than others in similar situations.

[Scoop Junior 3,517]

The author obviously isn't aware that the 2007 ND selections were made by Craig Cameron, not Barry Prendergast.

[old dee 23,928]

I know hindsight is a great thing any most clubs have early picks that fail but WTF the MFC just continue to get it wrong & when you look at the top clubs they get more right than wrong!

In fairness Tapscott & Gysberts will be good but the other decisions with early picks is absolute disaster!

Jury is still out for Me

I see little so far to suggest they will be more than average AFL players.

One cannot stay healthy and they other cannot get a game when we are desperate for mid fielders.

[Sir Why You Little 37,242]

What's so great about Gysberts??

Please tell me. People just want him to be great....

[Biffen 12,949]

What's so great about Gysberts??

Please tell me. People just want him to be great....

Ball magnet mate.

First three games just got mid 20s touches in AFL and has PLENTY of time to deliver it .

[Sir Why You Little 37,242]

Ball magnet mate.

First three games just got mid 20s touches in AFL and has PLENTY of time to deliver it .

First 3 games and then everyone realized he had limited pace.

[Range Rover 1,935]

Ball magnet mate.

First three games just got mid 20s touches in AFL and has PLENTY of time to deliver it .

What about since then?