I heard a caller on SEN this morning suggest this trade:

- GWS gets their man Daisy

- Collingwood gets Scully

- Melbourne get Malthouse + 2 picks from GWS

It would never, ever happen but would could you stand seeing Scully in the filth for Malthouse and 2 compo picks in our camp?

Edited August 24, 201114 yr by daveytrain1

Callers on SEN are more often than not, idiots. Lets leave it at that.

Edited August 24, 201114 yr by Jimmi C

I heard a caller on SEN this morning suggest this trade:

- GWS gets their man Daisy

- Collingwood gets Scully

- Melbourne get Malthouse + 2 picks from GWS

It would never, ever happen but would could you stand seeing Scully in the filth for Malthouse and 2 compo picks in our camp?

MM is not a player why should he be included in anything.

How about GWS gets Daisy - Collingwood gets nothing.

How about Melbourne gets Malthouse - Collingwood gets nothing

How about Scully stays at Melbourne - Collingwood gets nothing.

I heard the call also the guy could hardly put two words together

MM is not a player why should he be included in anything.

How about GWS gets Daisy - Collingwood gets nothing.

How about Melbourne gets Malthouse - Collingwood gets nothing

How about Scully stays at Melbourne - Collingwood gets nothing.

I heard the call also the guy could hardly put two words together

+1 - when we get, and the filth get nothing...sign me up! LOL

Umm...what is wrong with this post?

1. You cannot trade coaches for players or picks

2. Mathouse has "categorically" denied he will coach next year

3. Thomas is about to re-sign with Collingwood

If you think Malthouse would say anything else then you are challenge enough

Thomas Signed for 2 years today...so it aint going to happen

Slow SEN day obviously.

Interesting quote by Eddie

"That's 100 per cent correct – not signed yet, but close enough," McGuire said.

in the Herald Sun Here

I know it's probably is all done and dusted but until he signs there is Hope for GWS...isn't there...lol

Oh well one can Dream!

Edited August 24, 201114 yr by Felix da Dee

This deal HAS NOT BEEN THOUGHT OUT because how on earth are Collingwood going to match GWS money for Scully? He would get more staying at Melbourne.

Rates up there in great SEN calls with the guy who rang this morning to say Sam Mitchell to GWS was 100% confirmed. Ignoring the fact he's under contract...

Do we need a thread for every dumb rumour off the radio? I'd rather a thread dedicated to Chris From Camberwell and the guy who rang up and cried after the Richmond game.

Rates up there in great SEN calls with the guy who rang this morning to say Sam Mitchell to GWS was 100% confirmed. Ignoring the fact he's under contract...

Do we need a thread for every dumb rumour off the radio? I'd rather a thread dedicated to Chris From Camberwell and the guy who rang up and cried after the Richmond game.

Agree with this.

I love Chris from Camberwell's passion on SEN

Driving home from The G I also heard the caller crying about Melbourne's effort V The Tiger's

In a strange sort of way he 100% expressed how most of us feel watching The Dee's over the past 5 years.

2012 simply has to be the start of the upward spiral in our history.